Meta-analysis of Corneal Biomechanical Effects after SMILE and FS-LASIK
Abstract Background: To evaluate and compare corneal biomechanics after treatment of myopia using small-incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) and femtosecond laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis (FS-LASIK). Methods: We performed a meta-analysis and searched for reports concerning corneal biomechanics after SMILE and FS-LASIK using MEDLINE, EMbase, CNKI and the Cochrane Library. The analysis included corneal hysteresis (CH) and corneal resistance factor (CRF) before and 3 months after the surgery. The quality of the reports was evaluated using the Newcastle-Ottawa scale (NOS). Statistical analysis was performed using RevMan5. Results: Only six studies with a total of 771 eyes were ultimately included in this meta-analysis, and the random effects model was adopted. The preoperative and three-month postoperative CH and CRF of SMILE and FS-LASIK were compared by the meta-analysis. No statistically significant difference was found in CH or CRF between the SMILE group and the FS-LASIK group before the surgery (WMD,-0.12; 95% CI,-0.31~0.06; P,0.19; WMD,-0.05; 95% CI,-0.29~0.19; P,0.69). There was no statistically significant difference in CH between the two surgical methods 3 months after the operation in the foreign group (WMD,0.19; 95% CI,-1.02~1.41; P,0.75) or in the Chinese group (WMD,0.13; 95% CI,-0.16~0.41; P,0.75). Likewise, no statistically significant difference was found in CRF between the two surgical methods in the foreign group 3 months after the operation (WMD,-0.11; 95% CI,-2.53~-2.31; P,0.93). Nevertheless, the difference in CRF between the two surgical methods was statistically significant in the Chinese group (WMD,0.26; 95% CI,0.06~0.47; P,0.01). Concusion: This meta-analysis indicated that SMILE showed no significant postoperative advantage in CH in comparison with FS-LASIK. For CRF, SMILE exhibited no obvious postoperative advantage in comparison with FS-LASIK in the foreign group, whereas SMILE was superior to FS-LASIK in the Chinese group.