Comparison of electrical collection topologies for multi-rotor wind turbines
Abstract. Multi-rotor wind turbines (MRWT) have been suggested in literature as a solution to achieving wind turbine systems with capacities greater than 10 MW. MWRT's utilise a large number of small rotors connected to one support structure instead of one large rotor, with the aim of circumventing the square cube law. Potential benefits of MRWT's include cost and material savings, standardisation of parts, increased control possibilities and improved logistics for assembly and maintenance. Almost all previous work has focused on mechanical and aerodynamic feasibility, with almost no attention being paid to the electrical systems. In this research eight different topologies of the electrical collection network for MRWT's are analysed to assess which are the most economically and practically viable options. AC and DC collection networks are presented in radial, star, cluster and DC series topologies. Mass, capital cost and losses are estimated based on scaling relationships from academic literature and up to date commercial data. The focus of this study is the assessment of the type of electrical collector topology so component type and voltage level are kept consistent between topology designs in order to facilitate a fair comparison. Topologies are compared in terms of four main criteria; capital cost, cost effectiveness, total mass, and reliability. The most suitable collection topology for MRWT's is shown to be of the star type, in which each turbine is connected to the step up transformer via its own cable. DC topologies are generally found to be more expensive when compared to their AC counterparts due to the high cost of DC-DC converters and DC switchgear.