Progressive enhancement of kinetic proofreading in T cell antigen discrimination from receptor activation to DAG generation

T cells use kinetic proofreading to discriminate antigens by converting small changes in antigen binding lifetime into large differences in cell activation, but where in the signaling cascade this computation is performed is unknown. Previously, we developed a light-gated immune receptor to probe the role of ligand kinetics in T cell antigen signaling. We found significant kinetic proofreading at the level of the signaling lipid diacylglycerol (DAG) but lacked the ability to determine where the multiple signaling steps required for kinetic discrimination originate in the upstream signaling cascade (Tischer and Weiner, 2019). Here we uncover where kinetic proofreading is executed by adapting our optogenetic system for robust activation of early signaling events. We find the strength of kinetic proofreading progressively increases from Zap70 recruitment to LAT clustering to downstream DAG generation. These data suggest a distributed kinetic proofreading mechanism, with proofreading steps both at the receptor and at downstream signaling events. Leveraging the ability of our system to rapidly disengage ligand binding, we measure slower reset rates for downstream signaling events. Our observations of distributed kinetic proofreading and slowed resetting of downstream steps suggest a basis of cooperativity between multiple active receptors with implications in tissue homeostasis, autoimmunity, and immunotherapy off-target effects.

Deliver on Time or Pay the Fine: Scheduling in Membrane Trafficking

Membrane trafficking is all about time. Automation in such a biological process is crucial to ensure management and delivery of cellular cargoes with spatiotemporal precision. Shared molecular regulators and differential engagement of trafficking components improve robustness of molecular sorting. Sequential recruitment of low affinity protein complexes ensures directionality of the process and, concomitantly, serves as a kinetic proofreading mechanism to discriminate cargoes from the whole endocytosed material. This strategy helps cells to minimize losses and operating errors in membrane trafficking, thereby matching the appealed deadline. Here, we summarize the molecular pathways of molecular sorting, focusing on their timing and efficacy. We also highlight experimental procedures and genetic approaches to robustly probe these pathways, in order to guide mechanistic studies at the interface between biochemistry and quantitative biology.

Kinetic proofreading of lipochitooligosaccharides determines signal activation of symbiotic plant receptors

Plants and animals use cell surface receptors to sense and interpret environmental signals. In legume symbiosis with nitrogen-fixing bacteria, the specific recognition of bacterial lipochitooligosaccharide (LCO) signals by single-pass transmembrane receptor kinases determines compatibility. Here, we determine the structural basis for LCO perception from the crystal structures of two lysin motif receptor ectodomains and identify a hydrophobic patch in the binding site essential for LCO recognition and symbiotic function. We show that the receptor monitors the composition of the amphiphilic LCO molecules and uses kinetic proofreading to control receptor activation and signaling specificity. We demonstrate engineering of the LCO binding site to fine-tune ligand selectivity and correct binding kinetics required for activation of symbiotic signaling in plants. Finally, the hydrophobic patch is found to be a conserved structural signature in this class of LCO receptors across legumes that can be used for in silico predictions. Our results provide insights into the mechanism of cell-surface receptor activation by kinetic proofreading of ligands and highlight the potential in receptor engineering to capture benefits in plant–microbe interactions.

The discriminatory power of the T cell receptor

T cells use their T-cell receptors (TCRs) to discriminate between lower-affinity self and higher-affinity non-self pMHC antigens. Although the discriminatory power of the TCR is widely believed to be near-perfect, technical difficulties have hampered efforts to precisely quantify it. Here, we describe a method for measuring very low TCR/pMHC affinities, and use it to measure the discriminatory power of the TCR, and the factors affecting it. We find that TCR discrimination, although enhanced compared with conventional cell-surface receptors, is imperfect: primary human T cells can respond to pMHC with affinities as low as KD ~1 mM. The kinetic proofreading mechanism fit our data, providing the first estimates of both the time delay (2.8 s) and number of biochemical steps (2.67) that are consistent with the extraordinary sensitivity of antigen recognition. Our findings explain why self pMHC frequently induce autoimmune diseases and anti-tumour responses, and suggest ways to modify TCR discrimination.

Erleuchtete Erforschung von biologischen Signalprozessen

Die molekulare Optogenetik hat zum Ziel, molekulare Prozesse in Zellen durch Lichtsignale zu steuern, indem genetisch kodierte Photorezeptoren an zelluläre Proteine fusioniert werden. Dadurch kann die zelluläre Signalleitung mit einer bisher nicht möglich gewesenen zeitlichen und örtlichen Präzision gesteuert werden. Hierzu wurden in den letzten Jahren zahlreiche Methoden entwickelt und neue Einblicke gewonnen. Beispielsweise konnte durch lichtabhängige Aktivierung des T-Zell-Rezeptors das kinetic proofreading Modell bestätigt werden. Außerdem ermöglichen lichtinduzierbare Cre-Rekombinasen eine noch präzisere Kontrolle über Genmanipulationen. Dieser Übersichtsartikel soll als Inspiration dafür dienen, wie die molekulare Optogenetik in der präklinischen Forschung Anwendung finden kann.

Coupling of spliceosome complexity to intron diversity

We determined that over 40 spliceosomal proteins are conserved between many fungal species and humans but were lost during the evolution of S. cerevisiae, an intron-poor yeast with unusually rigid splicing signals. We analyzed null mutations in a subset of these factors, most of which had not been investigated previously, in the intron-rich yeast Cryptococcus neoformans. We found they govern splicing efficiency of introns with divergent spacing between intron elements. Importantly, most of these factors also suppress usage of weak nearby cryptic/alternative splice sites. Among these, orthologs of GPATCH1 and the helicase DHX35 display correlated functional signatures and copurify with each other as well as components of catalytically active spliceosomes, identifying a conserved G-patch/helicase pair that promotes splicing fidelity. We propose that a significant fraction of spliceosomal proteins in humans and most eukaryotes are involved in limiting splicing errors, potentially through kinetic proofreading mechanisms, thereby enabling greater intron diversity.

Transient Kinetic Proofreading

We propose a 2-dimensional Markov chain model to understand and efficiently compute the transient behavior of the kinetic proofreading mechanism in a single T-cell. We show that a stochastic version of absolute ligand discrimination is a direct consequence of the finite number of receptors on the cell surface; thus, pointing to number control as being important for absolute ligand discrimination. We also develop 1-dimensional approximations for several limiting regimes that significantly decrease the computational time. We present results of numerical experiments that explore the behavior of the new model for a wide range of parameters, and its robustness to parameter errors.

The possible fidelity-speed-proofreading cost trade-offs in DNA replication due to the exonuclease proofreading

DNA replication is a high-fidelity information-copying processes which is realized by DNA polymerase (DNAP). The high fidelity was explained on the basis of the well-known kinetic-proofreading mechanism (KPR), under which the so-called fidelity-speed trade-off was studied theoretically. However, numerous biochemical experiments have shown that the high fidelity of DNA replication is achieved due to the initial discrimination of polymerase domain of DNAP, as well as the proofreading of the exonuclease domain of DNAP. This exonuclease-proofreading mechanism (EPR) is totally different from KPR. So the trade-off issues are worth being re-examined under EPR. In this paper, we use the first-passage method recently proposed by us to discuss the possible trade-offs in DNA replication under EPR. We show that there could be no fidelity-speed trade-off under EPR, i.e., the fidelity and the speed can be simultaneously enhanced by EPR in a large range of kinetic parameters. This provides a new perspective to understand the experimental data of the exonuclease activity of T7 DNAP and T4 DNAP. We also show that there exists the fidelity-proofreading cost trade-off, i.e., the fidelity is enhanced at the cost of increasing the futile hydrolysis of dNTP. A possible way to avoid this trade-off is to regulate the rate of DNAP translocation: slowing down the forward translocation (in the presence of the terminal mismatch) can enhance the fidelity without changing the speed and the proofreading cost. Our theoretical analysis offers deeper insights on the kinetics-function relation of DNAP.PACS numbers: 82.39.-k, 87.15.Rn, 87.16.A-