Overall, the general public tend to oppose excessive inequality and support a degree of redistribution as a matter of principle. However, differences in welfare attitudes are clearly observable between institutional regimes, ideological systems and socio-demographic groups. Drawing on analysis of the British Social Attitudes survey, this chapter begins by outlining how rich and poor citizens differ in terms of their attitudes towards welfare, inequality and social citizenship. It then turns to demonstrate how this attitudinal divergence is mediated by material position and the knowledge accumulated through lived experiences of inequality. The main body of the chapter pivots on a series of vignettes that are used as a heuristic to explore tacit and explicit intuitions about the structural determinants of agency and outcome. These vignettes were presented to those interviewed for this study to explore operational notions of justice, responsibility and fairness. The vignettes draw upon caricatures of individuals commonly (mis-) represented in policy discourse and the media: ‘the deserving workless poor’, ‘the undeserving workless poor’, ‘the deserving working poor’ and ‘the undeserving working rich’. The chapter demonstrates that affluence and deprivation engender distinct understandings, and explanations of social stratification that, in turn, affect attitudes towards welfare, rights and responsibilities.