This is an advance summary of a forthcoming article in the Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Religion. Please check back later for the full article.
Women’s embodiment has often historically been denigrated in many religious traditions as a limited or inferior avenue to spiritual realization, sparking widespread feminist criticism of orthodox religious observances as a perpetual reinscription of patriarchal power structures. However, a growing body of feminist scholars is rejecting the false dichotomization of agency and complicity. Saba Mahmood and Orit Avishai, for example, discuss the role of agency within “conventional” religious observances of hijab and niddah in the discipline of living according to these rules and developing an inward virtue of modesty, piety, and discipline despite ambivalence. Especially in the Indian context of dharma, which privileges duties over rights and interconnected community over individual freedom, agency and power cannot mean individual self-promotion or resistance to responsibility, but instead reinforce one’s identity in responsibility to others.
Investigation into three ritual traditions of goddess worship (the Varalakshmi puja performed by Telugu women, the Kanya puja performed by many Indian communities, and the Tamil worship of Adhiparasakthi both in Chennai and in the Hindu diaspora) reveals the extent to which ritual embodiment of the goddess may translate into spiritual agency and empowerment for women. Whether the ritual explicitly extols conventionally feminine ideals of selflessness and caring for others, as in the Varalakshmi puja, or subverts conventional orthodoxy and male religious authority, as in the Adhiparasakthi worship, the agency and empowerment described by the worshipers largely reflect the values of interconnection, responsibility, and worldly concerns of practical flourishing of family and society. According to the ethnographic work of recent scholars, women worshipers often express emotional satisfaction, spiritual peace, and a marked sense of empowerment in their being able, through their worship, to affect the practical well-being of their families in myriad ways. Such reports offer a serious challenge to the previous view, suggested by Judith Butler, for example, that locates agency in one’s resistance to received norms.