The Statistics of Causal Inference: A View from Political Methodology

2015 ◽  
Vol 23 (3) ◽  
pp. 313-335 ◽  
Author(s):  
Luke Keele

Many areas of political science focus on causal questions. Evidence from statistical analyses is often used to make the case for causal relationships. While statistical analyses can help establish causal relationships, it can also provide strong evidence of causality where none exists. In this essay, I provide an overview of the statistics of causal inference. Instead of focusing on specific statistical methods, such as matching, I focus more on the assumptions needed to give statistical estimates a causal interpretation. Such assumptions are often referred to as identification assumptions, and these assumptions are critical to any statistical analysis about causal effects. I outline a wide range of identification assumptions and highlight the design-based approach to causal inference. I conclude with an overview of statistical methods that are frequently used for causal inference.

Author(s):  
Janet Peacock ◽  
Sally Kerry

Presenting Medical Statistics includes a wide range of statistical analyses, and all the statistical methods are illustrated using real data. Labelled figures show the Stata and SPSS commands needed to obtain the analyses, with indications of which information should be extracted from the output for reporting. The relevant results are then presented as for a report or journal article, to illustrate the principles of good presentation.


2018 ◽  
Vol 116 (12) ◽  
pp. 5311-5318 ◽  
Author(s):  
Paul J. Ferraro ◽  
James N. Sanchirico ◽  
Martin D. Smith

Coupled human and natural systems (CHANS) are complex, dynamic, interconnected systems with feedback across social and environmental dimensions. This feedback leads to formidable challenges for causal inference. Two significant challenges involve assumptions about excludability and the absence of interference. These two assumptions have been largely unexplored in the CHANS literature, but when either is violated, causal inferences from observable data are difficult to interpret. To explore their plausibility, structural knowledge of the system is requisite, as is an explicit recognition that most causal variables in CHANS affect a coupled pairing of environmental and human elements. In a large CHANS literature that evaluates marine protected areas, nearly 200 studies attempt to make causal claims, but few address the excludability assumption. To examine the relevance of interference in CHANS, we develop a stylized simulation of a marine CHANS with shocks that can represent policy interventions, ecological disturbances, and technological disasters. Human and capital mobility in CHANS is both a cause of interference, which biases inferences about causal effects, and a moderator of the causal effects themselves. No perfect solutions exist for satisfying excludability and interference assumptions in CHANS. To elucidate causal relationships in CHANS, multiple approaches will be needed for a given causal question, with the aim of identifying sources of bias in each approach and then triangulating on credible inferences. Within CHANS research, and sustainability science more generally, the path to accumulating an evidence base on causal relationships requires skills and knowledge from many disciplines and effective academic-practitioner collaborations.


2017 ◽  
pp. 37
Author(s):  
Eduardo Morales

In this paper a review of the uses of the comparative method in plant eco logy is presented. Particular attention is devoted to statistical methods that analyze variation in continuos phenotypic traits. The comparative method incorporates the phylogenetic relationships of the species in recognition that species usually do not provide independent points in statistical analysis because they share characteristics through descent from common ancestors. This review is divided in three sections. In the first one, the different statistical analysis that comprises the comparative method are presented, particular attention is devoted to: i] Evolutionary correlations, ii] phylogenetic inertia, and iii] ancestral character estimation. The second section presents the different papers that had applied these different methodologies, in both, origin al or reanalyzed data. Finally, in the third section the use of comparative methods to study adaptation and the debate between the use of phylogenetically based statistical methods and conventional statistical analyses are discussed.


2019 ◽  
Vol 24 ◽  
pp. 02002
Author(s):  
Viera Pacáková ◽  
Pavla Jindrová ◽  
Lucie Kopecká

Efficiently functioning health systems are a prerequisite for high-quality health care and healthy life expectancy. Health care management at all levels requires a lot of information that can be obtained only by relevant analyses of health data. There are collected and regularly updated on-line published a large number of databases and enormous number of indicators about health status, health expenditures and health systems functioning at regional, national, EU member countries, OECD countries and on the world level. Paradoxically, the extent of these data sets is the reason why without at least basic statistical analysis the level of provided information is minimal. Advanced statistical methods aimed at reducing the dimension and quantification of causal relationships can provide significant information added value. The objective of this article is to analyse causal relationships between health status, health expenditures and sources of health care in selected European countries and to identify determinants of health inequalities in European countries by applying multidimensional statistical methods.


2020 ◽  
Vol 1 (1) ◽  
pp. 41-51
Author(s):  
SAJID KHAN ◽  
Uzma Sadiq ◽  
Sayyad Khurshid

Research displays an extensive investigation for different factual statistical estimates and their practical implementation in picture handling with various noises and filter channel procedures. Noise is very challenging to take out it from the digital images. The purpose of image filtering is to eliminate the noise from the image in such a way that the new image is detectible. We have clarified different calculations and systems for channel the pictures and which calculation is the best for sifting the picture. Signal and maximum Peak proportion parameters are utilized for execution for factual estimating, Wiener channel performs preferred in evacuating clamor over different channels. Wiener channel functions admirably for a wide range of clamors. The exhibition of Gaussian channel is superior to anything Mean channel, Mask Filter and Wiener channel as per MSE results. In picture setting up, a Gaussian fog generally called Gaussian smoothing is the result of darkening an image by a Gaussian limit. We reason that Gaussian separating approach is the best method that can be effectively actualized with the assistance of the MSE of picture. The Gaussian channel is certifiably superior to different calculations at expelling clamor. The outcomes have been looked at for channels utilizing SNR, PSNR and Mean Square Error esteem.


2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Suzie Cro ◽  
Gordon Forbes ◽  
Nicholas A Johnson ◽  
Brennan C Kahan

AbstractBackgroundChoosing or altering the planned statistical analysis approach after examination of trial data (often referred to as ‘p-hacking’) can bias results of randomized trials. However, the extent of this issue in practice is currently unclear. We conducted a review of published randomized trials to evaluate how often a pre-specified analysis approach is publicly available, and how often the planned analysis is changed.MethodsA review of randomised trials published between January and April 2018 in six leading general medical journals. For each trial we established whether a pre-specified analysis approach was publicly available in a protocol or statistical analysis plan, and compared this to the trial publication.ResultsOverall, 89 of 101 eligible trials (88%) had a publicly available pre-specified analysis approach. Only 22/89 trials (25%) had no unexplained discrepancies between the pre-specified and conducted analysis. Fifty-four trials (61%) had one or more unexplained discrepancies, and in 13 trials (15%) it was impossible to ascertain whether any unexplained discrepancies occurred due to incomplete reporting of the statistical methods. Unexplained discrepancies were most common for the analysis model (n=31, 35%) and analysis population (n=28, 31%), followed by the use of covariates (n=23, 26%) and the approach for handling missing data (n=16, 18%). Many protocols or statistical analysis plans were dated after the trial had begun, so earlier discrepancies may have been missed.ConclusionsUnexplained discrepancies in the statistical methods of randomized trials are common. Increased transparency is required for proper evaluation of results.


2022 ◽  
Vol 22 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Bas B. L. Penning de Vries ◽  
Rolf H. H. Groenwold

Abstract Background Case-control designs are an important yet commonly misunderstood tool in the epidemiologist’s arsenal for causal inference. We reconsider classical concepts, assumptions and principles and explore when the results of case-control studies can be endowed a causal interpretation. Results We establish how, and under which conditions, various causal estimands relating to intention-to-treat or per-protocol effects can be identified based on the data that are collected under popular sampling schemes (case-base, survivor, and risk-set sampling, with or without matching). We present a concise summary of our identification results that link the estimands to the (distribution of the) available data and articulate under which conditions these links hold. Conclusion The modern epidemiologist’s arsenal for causal inference is well-suited to make transparent for case-control designs what assumptions are necessary or sufficient to endow the respective study results with a causal interpretation and, in turn, help resolve or prevent misunderstanding. Our approach may inform future research on different estimands, other variations of the case-control design or settings with additional complexities.


2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Luis Anunciacao ◽  
janet squires ◽  
J. Landeira-Fernandez

One of the main activities in psychometrics is to analyze the internal structure of a test. Multivariate statistical methods, including Exploratory Factor analysis (EFA) and Principal Component Analysis (PCA) are frequently used to do this, but the growth of Network Analysis (NA) places this method as a promising candidate. The results obtained by these methods are of valuable interest, as they not only produce evidence to explore if the test is measuring its intended construct, but also to deal with the substantive theory that motivated the test development. However, these different statistical methods come up with different answers, providing the basis for different analytical and theoretical strategies when one needs to choose a solution. In this study, we took advantage of a large volume of published data (n = 22,331) obtained by the Ages and Stages Questionnaire Social-Emotional (ASQ:SE), and formed a subset of 500 children to present and discuss alternative psychometric solutions to its internal structure, and also to its subjacent theory. The analyses were based on a polychoric matrix, the number of factors to retain followed several well-known rules of thumb, and a wide range of exploratory methods was fitted to the data, including EFA, PCA, and NA. The statistical outcomes were divergent, varying from 1 to 6 domains, allowing a flexible interpretation of the results. We argue that the use of statistical methods in the absence of a well-grounded psychological theory has limited applications, despite its appeal. All data and codes are available at https://osf.io/z6gwv/.


1992 ◽  
Vol 25 (4-5) ◽  
pp. 399-400 ◽  
Author(s):  
L. Cingolani ◽  
M. Cossignani ◽  
R. Miliani

Statistical analyses were applied to data from a series of 38 samples collected in an aerobic treatment plant from November 1989 to December 1990. Relationships between microfauna structure and plant operating conditions were found. Amount and quality of microfauna groups and species found in activated sludge proved useful to suggest the possible causes of disfunctions.


2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Wan-Jun Guo ◽  
Xia Yang ◽  
Yu-Jie Tao ◽  
Ya-Jing Meng ◽  
Hui-Yao Wang ◽  
...  

BACKGROUND Evidence indicates that Internet addiction (IA) is associated with depression, but longitudinal studies have rarely been reported, and no studies have yet investigated potential common vulnerability or a possible specific causal relationship between these disorders. OBJECTIVE To overcome these gaps, the present 12-month longitudinal study based on a large-sample employed a cross-lagged panel model (CLPM) approach to investigate the potential common vulnerability and specific cross-causal relationships between IA and CSD (or depression). METHODS IA and clinically-significant depression (CSD) among 12 043 undergraduates were surveyed at baseline (as freshmen) and in follow-up after 12 months (as sophomores). Application of CLPM revealed two well-fitted design between IA and CSD, and between severities of IA and depression, adjusting for demographics. RESULTS Rates of baseline IA and CSD were 5.47% and 3.85%, respectively; increasing to 9.47% and 5.58%, respectively at follow-up. Among those with baseline IA and CSD, 44.61% and 34.48% remained stable at the time of the follow-up survey, respectively. Rates of new-incidences of IA and CSD over 12 months were 7.43% and 4.47%, respectively. Application of a cross-lagged panel model approach (CLPM, a discrete time structural equation model used primarily to assess causal relationships in real-world settings) revealed two well-fitted design between IA and CSD, and between severities of IA and depression, adjusting for demographics. Models revealed that baseline CSD (or depression severity) had a significant net-predictive effect on follow-up IA (or IA severity), and baseline IA (or IA severity) had a significant net-predictive effect on follow-up CSD (or depression severity). CONCLUSIONS These correlational patterns using a CLPM indicate that both common vulnerability and bidirectional specific cross-causal effects between them may contribute to the association between IA and depression. As the path coefficients of the net-cross-predictive effects were significantly smaller than those of baseline to follow-up cross-section associations, vulnerability may play a more significant role than bidirectional-causal effects. CLINICALTRIAL Ethics Committee of West China Hospital, Sichuan University (NO. 2016-171)


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document