A meta-analysis of neuroimaging studies on pain empathy: investigating the role of visual information and observers’ perspective

Abstract Empathy relies on brain systems that support the interaction between an observer’s mental state and cues about the others’ experience. Beyond the core brain areas typically activated in pain empathy studies (insular and anterior cingulate cortices), the diversity of paradigms used may reveal secondary networks that subserve other more specific processes. A coordinate-based meta-analysis of fMRI experiments on pain empathy was conducted to obtain activation likelihood estimates along three factors and seven conditions: visual cues (body parts, facial expressions), visuospatial (first-person, thirdperson), and cognitive (self-, stimuli-, other-oriented tasks) perspectives. The core network was found across cues and perspectives, and common activation was observed in higher-order visual areas. Body-parts distinctly activated areas related with sensorimotor processing (superior and inferior parietal lobules, anterior insula) while facial expression distinctly involved the inferior frontal gyrus. Self- compared to other-perspective produced distinct activations in the left insula while stimulus- versus other-perspective produced distinctive responses in the inferior frontal and parietal lobules, precentral gyrus, and cerebellum. Pain empathy relies on a core network which is modulated by several secondary networks. The involvement of the latter seems to depend on the visual cues available and the observer's mental state that can be influenced by specific instructions.

Download Full-text

Grey matter abnormalities in Tourette syndrome: an activation likelihood estimation meta-analysis

BMC Psychiatry ◽

10.1186/s12888-021-03187-1 ◽

2021 ◽

Vol 21 (1) ◽

Author(s):

Fang Wen ◽

Junjuan Yan ◽

Liping Yu ◽

Fang Wang ◽

Jingran Liu ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Tourette Syndrome ◽

Grey Matter ◽

Meta Analysis ◽

Likelihood Estimation ◽

Anterior Cingulate ◽

Precentral Gyrus ◽

Healthy Controls ◽

Activation Likelihood Estimation ◽

Lentiform Nucleus ◽

Postcentral Gyrus

Abstract Background Tourette syndrome (TS) is a neurodevelopmental disorder defined by the continual presence of primary motor and vocal tics. Grey matter abnormalities have been identified in numerous studies of TS, but conflicting results have been reported. This study was an unbiased statistical meta-analysis of published neuroimaging studies of TS structures. Methods A voxel quantitative meta-analysis technique called activation likelihood estimation (ALE) was used. The meta-analysis included six neuroimaging studies involving 247 TS patients and 236 healthy controls. A statistical threshold of p < 0.05 was established based on the false discovery rate and a cluster extent threshold of 50 voxels. Results We found that grey matter volumes were significantly increased in the bilateral thalamus, right hypothalamus, right precentral gyrus, left postcentral gyrus, left inferior parietal lobule, right lentiform nucleus, and left insula of TS patients compared to those of healthy controls. In contrast, grey matter volumes were significantly decreased in the bilateral postcentral gyrus, bilateral anterior cingulate, bilateral insula, left posterior cingulate and left postcentral gyrus of TS patients compared to those of healthy controls. Conclusions Our present meta-analysis primarily revealed significant increases in grey matter volumes in the thalamus and lentiform nucleus, and decreased grey matter volumes in the anterior cingulate gyrus, of TS patients compared to those in healthy controls. Most of these identified regions are associated with cortico-striato-thalamo-cortical circuits. Further studies with larger sample sizes are needed to confirm these changes in grey matter volumes in TS patients.

Download Full-text

The Role of the Right Prefrontal Cortex in Self-evaluation of the Face: A Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study

Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience ◽

10.1162/jocn.2008.20024 ◽

2008 ◽

Vol 20 (2) ◽

pp. 342-355 ◽

Cited By ~ 69

Author(s):

Tomoyo Morita ◽

Shoji Itakura ◽

Daisuke N. Saito ◽

Satoshi Nakashita ◽

Tokiko Harada ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Prefrontal Cortex ◽

Face Recognition ◽

Inferior Frontal Gyrus ◽

Video Recording ◽

Imaging Study ◽

The Self ◽

Anterior Cingulate ◽

Precentral Gyrus ◽

Self Evaluation ◽

The Right

Individuals can experience negative emotions (e.g., embarrassment) accompanying self-evaluation immediately after recognizing their own facial image, especially if it deviates strongly from their mental representation of ideals or standards. The aim of this study was to identify the cortical regions involved in self-recognition and self-evaluation along with self-conscious emotions. To increase the range of emotions accompanying self-evaluation, we used facial feedback images chosen from a video recording, some of which deviated significantly from normal images. In total, 19 participants were asked to rate images of their own face (SELF) and those of others (OTHERS) according to how photogenic they appeared to be. After scanning the images, the participants rated how embarrassed they felt upon viewing each face. As the photogenic scores decreased, the embarrassment ratings dramatically increased for the participant's own face compared with those of others. The SELF versus OTHERS contrast significantly increased the activation of the right prefrontal cortex, bilateral insular cortex, anterior cingulate cortex, and bilateral occipital cortex. Within the right prefrontal cortex, activity in the right precentral gyrus reflected the trait of awareness of observable aspects of the self; this provided strong evidence that the right precentral gyrus is specifically involved in self-face recognition. By contrast, activity in the anterior region, which is located in the right middle inferior frontal gyrus, was modulated by the extent of embarrassment. This finding suggests that the right middle inferior frontal gyrus is engaged in self-evaluation preceded by self-face recognition based on the relevance to a standard self.

Download Full-text

Sensory perception in autism: an fMRI ALE meta-analysis

10.31234/osf.io/p9n2z ◽

2020 ◽

Author(s):

Nazia Jassim ◽

Simon Baron-Cohen ◽

John Suckling

Keyword(s):

Meta Analysis ◽

Likelihood Estimation ◽

Sensory Perception ◽

Superior Temporal Gyrus ◽

Occipital Cortex ◽

Anterior Cingulate ◽

Future Research ◽

Precentral Gyrus ◽

And Control ◽

Lateral Occipital Cortex

Sensory sensitivities occur in up to 90% of autistic individuals. With the recent inclusion of sensory symptoms in the diagnostic criteria for autism, there is a current need to develop neural hypotheses related to autistic sensory perception. Using activation likelihood estimation (ALE), we meta-analysed 52 task-based fMRI studies investigating differences between autistic (n=891) and control (n=967) participants during non-social sensory perception. During complex perception, autistic groups showed more activity in the secondary somatosensory and occipital cortices, insula, caudate, superior temporal gyrus, and inferior parietal lobule, while control groups showed more activity in the frontal and parietal regions. During basic sensory processing, autistic groups showed hyperactivity in the lateral occipital cortex, primary somatosensory and motor cortices, insula, caudate, and thalamus, while controls showed heightened activity in the precentral gyrus, middle frontal gyrus, precuneus, and anterior cingulate cortex. We conclude that autistic individuals, on average, show distinct engagement of sensory-related brain networks during sensory perception. These findings may help guide future research to focus on relevant neurobiological mechanisms underpinning the autistic experience.

Download Full-text

Neural predictors of cognitive-behavior therapy outcome in anxiety-related disorders: a meta-analysis of task-based fMRI studies

Psychological Medicine ◽

10.1017/s0033291721005444 ◽

2022 ◽

pp. 1-9

Author(s):

Maria Picó-Pérez ◽

Miquel A. Fullana ◽

Anton Albajes-Eizagirre ◽

Daniel Vega ◽

Josep Marco-Pallarés ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Anxiety Disorder ◽

Behavior Therapy ◽

Cognitive Behavior Therapy ◽

Meta Analysis ◽

Inferior Frontal Gyrus ◽

Anterior Cingulate ◽

Cognitive Behavior ◽

Brain Response ◽

Dorsal Anterior Cingulate Cortex ◽

Compulsive Disorder

Abstract Background Cognitive-behavior therapy (CBT) is a well-established first-line intervention for anxiety-related disorders, including specific phobia, social anxiety disorder, panic disorder/agoraphobia, generalized anxiety disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, and posttraumatic stress disorder. Several neural predictors of CBT outcome for anxiety-related disorders have been proposed, but previous results are inconsistent. Methods We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of task-based functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies investigating whole-brain predictors of CBT outcome in anxiety-related disorders (17 studies, n = 442). Results Across different tasks, we observed that brain response in a network of regions involved in salience and interoception processing, encompassing fronto-insular (the right inferior frontal gyrus-anterior insular cortex) and fronto-limbic (the dorsomedial prefrontal cortex-dorsal anterior cingulate cortex) cortices was strongly associated with a positive CBT outcome. Conclusions Our results suggest that there are robust neural predictors of CBT outcome in anxiety-related disorders that may eventually lead (probably in combination with other data) to develop personalized approaches for the treatment of these mental disorders.

Download Full-text

Altered neural activities during response inhibition in adults with addiction: a voxel-wise meta-analysis

Psychological Medicine ◽

10.1017/s0033291721000362 ◽

2021 ◽

pp. 1-13

Author(s):

Zeguo Qiu ◽

Junjing Wang

Keyword(s):

Response Inhibition ◽

Substance Dependence ◽

Brain Activity ◽

Meta Analysis ◽

Inferior Frontal Gyrus ◽

Activity Patterns ◽

Behavioral Addiction ◽

Middle Temporal Gyrus ◽

Precentral Gyrus ◽

Meta Analyses

Abstract Background Previous literature has extensively investigated the brain activity during response inhibition in adults with addiction. Inconsistent results including both hyper- and hypo-activities in the fronto-parietal network (FPN) and the ventral attention network (VAN) have been found in adults with addictions, compared with healthy controls (HCs). Methods Voxel-wise meta-analyses of abnormal task-evoked regional activity were conducted for adults with substance dependence (SD) and behavioral addiction during response inhibition tasks to solve previous inconsistencies. Twenty-three functional magnetic resonance imaging studies including 479 substance users, 38 individuals with behavioral addiction and 494 HCs were identified. Results Compared with HCs, all addictions showed hypo-activities in regions within FPN (inferior frontal gyrus and supramarginal gyrus) and VAN (inferior frontal gyrus, middle temporal gyrus, temporal pole and insula), and hyper-activities in the cerebellum during response inhibition. SD subgroup showed almost the same activity patterns, with an additional hypoactivation of the precentral gyrus, compared with HCs. Stronger activation of the cerebellum was associated with longer addiction duration for adults with SD. We could not conduct meta-analytic investigations into the behavioral addiction subgroup due to the small number of datasets. Conclusion This meta-analysis revealed altered activation of FPN, VAN and the cerebellum in adults with addiction during response inhibition tasks using non-addiction-related stimuli. Although FPN and VAN showed lower activity, the cerebellum exhibited stronger activity. These results may help to understand the neural pathology of response inhibition in addiction.

Download Full-text

Identification of the cerebral effects of paracetamol in healthy subjects: an fMRI study

British Journal of Pain ◽

10.1177/2049463719854483 ◽

2019 ◽

Vol 14 (1) ◽

pp. 23-30 ◽

Cited By ~ 1

Author(s):

Olivier De Coster ◽

Patrice Forget ◽

Johan De Mey ◽

Peter Van Schuerbeek ◽

Jan Poelaert

Keyword(s):

Healthy Volunteers ◽

Regional Blood Flow ◽

Inferior Frontal Gyrus ◽

Anterior Cingulate ◽

Precentral Gyrus ◽

Posterior Cingulate ◽

Analgesic Effects ◽

Volume Of Interest ◽

Fmri Study ◽

The Right

Introduction: Paracetamol is commonly used for its antipyretic properties and analgesic effects, but the central mechanism remains elusive. We designed a study in healthy volunteers to detect the central functional working mechanism of paracetamol. Subjects, material and methods: A total of 20 subjects had a baseline functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) before the intake of 1000 mg paracetamol orally; 60 minutes later, a second fMRI was made aiming detection of regional blood flow differences. Results: A decreased connectivity was observed in the ventral volume of interest (VOI), with the posterior cingulate (with both the left anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) and right ACC: respectively, Ke = 576; t = −6.8894 and Ke = 185; t = −4.8178) and the inferior temporal left (Ke = 103; t = −5.0993); in the combined ventral and dorsal VOIs, the posterior cingulate (with the left ACC; Ke = 149; t = −4.5658) and, both with the right ACC, the inferior temporal left (Ke = 88; t = −3.8456) and the inferior frontal gyrus (Ke = 86; t = −4.3937) had a decrease in connectivity. An increase was seen in other regions, including, among others, the middle frontal and temporal gyri (respectively, Ke = 85; t = 4.4256 and Ke = 85; t = 5.6851), the inferior frontal (with the left ACC: Ke = 165; t = 4.4998) and the superior frontal gyrus (with the right ACC; Ke = 281; t = 4.5992), and the post/precentral gyrus (with the right ACC, respectively, Ke = 102; t = 6.0582 and Ke = 105; t = 4.0776). Conclusions: On fMRIs in healthy volunteers, the ingestion of paracetamol affects connections with the ACC. This suggests a central effect of paracetamol in cerebral areas known to be associated with pain. Further studies are needed to demonstrate the same effects in acute and chronic pain states.

Download Full-text

Neural functional correlates of empathic face processing: An activation likelihood estimation (ALE) meta-analysis of fMRI studies

European Psychiatry ◽

10.1016/j.eurpsy.2017.02.313 ◽

2017 ◽

Vol 41 (S1) ◽

pp. S345-S345

Author(s):

A. Del Casale ◽

D. Janiri ◽

G. Kotzalidis ◽

G. Giuseppin ◽

E. Spinazzola ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Face Processing ◽

Perspective Taking ◽

Brain Area ◽

Meta Analysis ◽

Mirror Neuron ◽

Cingulate Cortex ◽

Posterior Cingulate Cortex ◽

Anterior Cingulate ◽

Precentral Gyrus ◽

Brain Areas

IntroductionEmpathy is evolutionary preserved in social organisms and emotional face processing is one of its measures. Systems possibly active during empathic processing include perspective-taking, basic emotional contagion “mirroring” and “theory of mind” systems.ObjectivesfMRI studies help clarifying neural correlates of empathic face processing; ALE meta-analysing fMRI studies allows identification of brain area activation/deactivation during empathy.AimsTo identify brain areas most consistently involved in empathy.MethodsWe carried ALE meta-analysis of original studies focusing on cerebral activations during empathic face processing tasks and reporting data on Talairach or MNI space coordinates, converting the former in the latter. An 11-April-2016 PubMed search, using as keywords terms like empathy combined with functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), produced 124 records of which 23 were finally included (568 participants, 247 males and 321 females; mean age 32.2 years). We followed the PRISMA statement. Whole-brain data were meta-analysed; significance was set at P = 0.0001, uncorrected.ResultsALE meta-analysis of data from 21 experiments (totalling 527 foci) on empathic face processing during experimental task conditions showed that emotional vs. neutral/control conditions significantly correlated with activations of left anterior cingulate cortex (BA 32), right precentral gyrus (BA 6), left amygdala, right superior frontal gyrus (BA 9), left middle occipital gyrus (BA 37), right insula (BA 13), left putamen, and left posterior cingulate cortex (BA 31).ConclusionsEmpathy is a complex process correlating with activation of different brain areas, which have been involved in emotional cue processing, self-other/same-different discrimination, perspective-taking, mirror neuron activation, emotional arousal and decision-making.Disclosure of interestThe authors have not supplied their declaration of competing interest.

Download Full-text

Core Network Contributions to Remembering the Past, Imagining the Future, and Thinking Creatively

Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience ◽

10.1162/jocn_a_01327 ◽

2018 ◽

Vol 30 (12) ◽

pp. 1939-1951 ◽

Cited By ~ 17

Author(s):

Roger E. Beaty ◽

Preston P. Thakral ◽

Kevin P. Madore ◽

Mathias Benedek ◽

Daniel L. Schacter

Keyword(s):

Episodic Memory ◽

Memory Retrieval ◽

Divergent Thinking ◽

Brain Activity ◽

Inferior Frontal Gyrus ◽

Parahippocampal Gyrus ◽

Episodic Retrieval ◽

Core Network ◽

Creative Cognition ◽

The Core

The core network refers to a set of neural regions that have been consistently associated with episodic memory retrieval and episodic future simulation. This network is thought to support the constructive thought processes that allow the retrieval and flexible combination of stored information to reconstruct past and construct novel future experiences. Recent behavioral research points to an overlap between these constructive processes and those also engaged during divergent thinking—the ability to think creatively and generate novel ideas—but the extent to which they involve common neural correlates remains unclear. Using fMRI, we sought to address this question by assessing brain activity as participants recalled past experiences, simulated future experiences, or engaged in divergent thinking. Consistent with past work, we found that episodic retrieval and future simulation activated the core network compared with a semantic control condition. Critically, a triple conjunction of episodic retrieval, future simulation, and divergent thinking revealed common engagement of core network regions, including the bilateral hippocampus and parahippocampal gyrus, as well as other regions involved in memory retrieval (inferior frontal gyrus) and mental imagery (middle occipital gyrus). The results provide further insight into the roles of the hippocampus and the core network in episodic memory retrieval, future simulation, and divergent thinking and extend recent work highlighting the involvement of constructive episodic processes in creative cognition.

Download Full-text

Common and distinct patterns of intrinsic brain activity alterations in major depression and bipolar disorder: voxel-based meta-analysis

Translational Psychiatry ◽

10.1038/s41398-020-01036-5 ◽

2020 ◽

Vol 10 (1) ◽

Author(s):

Jiaying Gong ◽

Junjing Wang ◽

Shaojuan Qiu ◽

Pan Chen ◽

Zhenye Luo ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Bipolar Disorder ◽

Major Depression ◽

Brain Activity ◽

Meta Analysis ◽

Inferior Frontal Gyrus ◽

Superior Temporal Gyrus ◽

Occipital Cortex ◽

Anterior Cingulate ◽

The Right ◽

Intrinsic Brain Activity

Abstract Identification of intrinsic brain activity differences and similarities between major depression (MDD) and bipolar disorder (BD) is necessary. However, results have not yet yielded consistent conclusions. A meta-analysis of whole-brain resting-state functional MRI (rs-fMRI) studies that explored differences in the amplitude of low-frequency fluctuation (ALFF) between patients (including MDD and BD) and healthy controls (HCs) was conducted using seed-based d mapping software. Systematic literature search identified 50 studies comparing 1399 MDD patients and 1332 HCs, and 15 studies comparing 494 BD patients and 593 HCs. MDD patients displayed increased ALFF in the right superior frontal gyrus (SFG) (including the medial orbitofrontal cortex, medial prefrontal cortex [mPFC], anterior cingulate cortex [ACC]), bilateral insula extending into the striatum and left supramarginal gyrus and decreased ALFF in the bilateral cerebellum, bilateral precuneus, and left occipital cortex compared with HCs. BD showed increased ALFF in the bilateral inferior frontal gyrus, bilateral insula extending into the striatum, right SFG, and right superior temporal gyrus (STG) and decreased ALFF in the bilateral precuneus, left cerebellum (extending to the occipital cortex), left ACC, and left STG. In addition, MDD displayed increased ALFF in the left lingual gyrus, left ACC, bilateral precuneus/posterior cingulate gyrus, and left STG and decreased ALFF in the right insula, right mPFC, right fusiform gyrus, and bilateral striatum relative to BD patients. Conjunction analysis showed increased ALFF in the bilateral insula, mPFC, and decreased ALFF in the left cerebellum in both disorders. Our comprehensive meta-analysis suggests that MDD and BD show a common pattern of aberrant regional intrinsic brain activity which predominantly includes the insula, mPFC, and cerebellum, while the limbic system and occipital cortex may be associated with spatially distinct patterns of brain function, which provide useful insights for understanding the underlying pathophysiology of brain dysfunction in affective disorders, and developing more targeted and efficacious treatment and intervention strategies.

Download Full-text

Parsing variability in borderline personality disorder: a meta-analysis of neuroimaging studies

Translational Psychiatry ◽

10.1038/s41398-021-01446-z ◽

2021 ◽

Vol 11 (1) ◽

Author(s):

Giorgia Degasperi ◽

Ioana Alina Cristea ◽

Elisa Di Rosa ◽

Cristiano Costa ◽

Claudio Gentili

Keyword(s):

Borderline Personality Disorder ◽

Personality Disorder ◽

Emotional Processing ◽

Brain Activity ◽

Meta Analysis ◽

Inferior Frontal Gyrus ◽

Emotion Processing ◽

Borderline Personality ◽

Anterior Cingulate ◽

Pathophysiological Mechanism

AbstractThough a plethora of functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies explored the neurobiological underpinnings of borderline personality disorder (BPD), findings across different tasks were divergent. We conducted a systematic review and activation likelihood estimation (ALE) meta-analysis on the fMRI studies conducted in BPD patients compared to healthy controls (HC). We systematically searched PubMed and PsychINFO from inception until July 9th 2020 using combinations of database-specific terms like ‘fMRI’, ‘Neuroimaging’, ‘borderline’. Eligible studies employed task-based fMRI of the brain in participants of any age diagnosed with BPD compared to HC, during any behavioral task and providing a direct contrast between the groups. From 762 entries, we inspected 92 reports full-texts and included 52 studies (describing 54 experiments). Across all experiments, the HC > BPD and BPD > HC meta-analyses did not yield any cluster of significant convergence of differences. Analyses restricted to studies of emotion processing revealed two significant clusters of activation in the bilateral hippocampal/amygdala complex and anterior cingulate for the BPD > HC meta-analysis. Fail-safe N and single study sensitivity analysis suggested significant findings were not robust. For the subgroup of emotional processing experiments, on a restricted number of experiments providing results for each group separately, another meta-analysis method (difference of convergence) showed a significant cluster in the insula/inferior frontal gyrus for the HC > BPD contrast. No consistent pattern of alteration in brain activity for BPD was evidenced suggesting substantial heterogeneity of processes and populations studied. A pattern of amygdala dysfunction emerged across emotion processing tasks, indicating a potential pathophysiological mechanism that could be transdiagnostic.

Download Full-text