Investigation of Different Surge Handling Strategies and its Impact on the Cogeneration Performance for a Single-Shaft Gas Turbine Operating on Syngas

Author(s):  
Javier Beltran Montemayor ◽  
Lars-Uno Axelsson

The increasing demand for decentralized power has led to a growing interest in smaller gas turbines for cogeneration applications. One benefit of decentralized power generation is the possibility to utilize fuels that are locally available. One example is syngas, which has gained increasing interest during the recent years. Compared to natural gas the syngas fuels have a large amount of dilutants, such as nitrogen and carbon dioxide, which results in a very low energy density. Hence, significant larger fuel flow is required. However, the added fuel flow will decrease the compressor surge margin and eventually drive the compressor towards surge. Several methods exist to address this issue including variable inlet guide vanes, increased turbine throat area, compressor bleeding and decreased combustor outlet temperature. This paper examines the operability of a generic all-radial single-shaft gas turbine in the 2 MW power range when running on syngas with different heating values. The above methods to combat the decreased surge margin will be analyzed using detailed cycle simulations and their advantages and disadvantages will be discussed. It was found that the increased throat area is the most beneficial of the four methods. The net power output is nearly the same as for natural gas operation and the heat rate is the lowest of the four methods.

Author(s):  
Sy A. Ali ◽  
William P. Parks

An increasing demand for efficient and environmentally clean use of biomass and wood waste byproducts as fuel requires major developments in gas turbines. Gas turbines are designed primarily to handle either natural gas or in some cases diesel fuels. Introducing low BTU, contaminants containing biofuels into a gas turbine would require proper understanding of fuel characteristics, combustor capability to burn these fuels, compressor surge margins, and ability of the turbine section to withstand deposition, erosion and corrosion. Allison Engine Company (Allison), in cooperation with the U.S. Department of Energy and other partners, has initiated a bioturbine development project which would lead to commercialization of a bioturbine to operate on major categories of biofuels. The project will address six key issues: • Quantify chemical, physical and combustion characteristics of biofuels, gasifiers, and the mass volume • Conduct emission modeling of existing combustor with low BTU fuels • Conduct rig tests • Modify current design of the combustor to handle low BTU fuels • Evaluate compressor surge margins to handle increased mass flows • Conduct full scale engine field test The total cost of this two and a half years project is approximately $8 million. The DOE will contribute over $3 million. Allison and partners will contribute the remaining $5 million. There is an additional vital task which must be performed, but is not a part of the current project. The capability of the turbine to withstand deposition, erosion and corrosion must also be evaluated in order to protect the turbine, and provide long term, uninterrupted operation of the gas turbine on biofuels. An important first step is to obtain quantitative data on gasified biofuels, including the contaminants. This information will be used in combustor modeling and to develop rig tests. The combustor will then be modified and made capable of handling these fuels. Allison will use the 601-K engine combustor (similar to the RB211 DLE combustor), and modify its hardware and software as required. The combustor modification will involve modeling, rig test, hardware and software modifications, and final engine test The entire project is expected to be complete during the second half of 1999. Concurrent with these tasks, Allison will evaluate the options available to increase the capability of engine mass flow due to low BTU fuels. A parallel task of “ruggedizing” the turbine section is also planned. The resulting turbine is expected to be comparable to natural gas fired commercial gas turbines in performance, durability, reliability and major overhaul cycles.


1992 ◽  
Vol 114 (2) ◽  
pp. 380-385 ◽  
Author(s):  
M. S. Johnson

This paper describes a procedure used to model the performance of gas turbines designed to fire natural gas (or distillate oil) when fired on medium-Btu fuel, such as coal-derived syngas. Results from such performance studies can be used in the design or analysis of Gasification Combined Cycle (GCC) power plants. The primary difficulty when firing syngas in a gas turbine designed for natural gas is the tendency to drive the compressor toward surge. If the gas turbine has sufficient surge margin and mechanical durability, Gas Turbine Evaluation code (GATE) simulations indicate that net output power can be increased on the order of 15 percent when firing syngas due to the advantageous increase in the ratio of the expander-to-compressor mass flow rates. Three classes of single-spool utility gas turbines are investigated spanning firing temperatures from 1985°F-2500°F (1358 K-1644 K). Performance simulations at a variety of part-load and ambient temperature conditions are described; the resulting performance curves are useful in GCC power plant studies.


Author(s):  
Mark S. Johnson

This paper describes a procedure used to model the performance of gas turbines designed to fire natural gas (or distillate oil) when fired on medium-BTU fuel, such as coal-derived syngas. Results from such performance studies can be used in the design or analysis of Gasification Combined-Cycle (GCC) power plants. The primary difficulty when firing syngas in a gas turbine designed for natural gas is the tendency to drive the compressor toward surge. If the gas turbine has sufficient surge margin and mechanical durability, Gas Turbine Evaluation code (GATE) simulations indicate that net output power can be increased on the order of 15% when firing syngas due to the advantageous increase in the ratio of the expander-to-compressor mass flow rates. Three classes of single-spool utility gas turbines are investigated spanning firing temperatures from 1985 F to 2500 F (1358 K to 1644 K). Performance simulations at a variety of part-load and ambient temperature conditions are described; the resulting performance curves are useful in GCC power plant studies.


2013 ◽  
Author(s):  
Do Won Kang ◽  
Hyuck Jun Jang ◽  
Tong Seop Kim

Gas turbines are widely used for cogeneration systems. In general, electricity and heat demands are not constant throughout the year. In cooling seasons, generally, heat demand decreases but electricity demand increases. In small gas turbine cogeneration systems, steam injection is a good way to respond to the demand variation. However, steam injection causes compressor discharge pressure to rise. This means a reduction in compressor surge margin, which is a critical operational parameter. Hence, even though thermal energy demand decreases considerably as is the case in cooling seasons, the surplus exhaust heat cannot be utilized for the steam injection in the conventional operation. In this study, a modified steam injected operation is suggested, which uprates electric power output without damaging a minimum allowable surge margin. This can be realized by extracting some of compressor discharge air and supplying it to the turbine exhaust side. The modified operation allows more steam to be injected into the combustor in comparison to the conventional steam injected operation while it guarantees the same compressor surge margin. The modified operation concept provides another merit of modulating the heat to power generation ratio by controlling both the amount of air bypass and the steam injection rate. In particular, pure power generating operation, where full amount of generated steam is injected and thus no heat output is available, is possible without decreasing the surge margin below a desired minimum value.


Energies ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 14 (2) ◽  
pp. 389
Author(s):  
Jinfu Liu ◽  
Zhenhua Long ◽  
Mingliang Bai ◽  
Linhai Zhu ◽  
Daren Yu

As one of the core components of gas turbines, the combustion system operates in a high-temperature and high-pressure adverse environment, which makes it extremely prone to faults and catastrophic accidents. Therefore, it is necessary to monitor the combustion system to detect in a timely way whether its performance has deteriorated, to improve the safety and economy of gas turbine operation. However, the combustor outlet temperature is so high that conventional sensors cannot work in such a harsh environment for a long time. In practical application, temperature thermocouples distributed at the turbine outlet are used to monitor the exhaust gas temperature (EGT) to indirectly monitor the performance of the combustion system, but, the EGT is not only affected by faults but also influenced by many interference factors, such as ambient conditions, operating conditions, rotation and mixing of uneven hot gas, performance degradation of compressor, etc., which will reduce the sensitivity and reliability of fault detection. For this reason, many scholars have devoted themselves to the research of combustion system fault detection and proposed many excellent methods. However, few studies have compared these methods. This paper will introduce the main methods of combustion system fault detection and select current mainstream methods for analysis. And a circumferential temperature distribution model of gas turbine is established to simulate the EGT profile when a fault is coupled with interference factors, then use the simulation data to compare the detection results of selected methods. Besides, the comparison results are verified by the actual operation data of a gas turbine. Finally, through comparative research and mechanism analysis, the study points out a more suitable method for gas turbine combustion system fault detection and proposes possible development directions.


Author(s):  
Edson Batista da Silva ◽  
Marcelo Assato ◽  
Rosiane Cristina de Lima

Usually, the turbogenerators are designed to fire a specific fuel, depending on the project of these engines may be allowed the operation with other kinds of fuel compositions. However, it is necessary a careful evaluation of the operational behavior and performance of them due to conversion, for example, from natural gas to different low heating value fuels. Thus, this work describes strategies used to simulate the performance of a single shaft industrial gas turbine designed to operate with natural gas when firing low heating value fuel, such as biomass fuel from gasification process or blast furnace gas (BFG). Air bled from the compressor and variable compressor geometry have been used as key strategies by this paper. Off-design performance simulations at a variety of ambient temperature conditions are described. It was observed the necessity for recovering the surge margin; both techniques showed good solutions to achieve the same level of safe operation in relation to the original engine. Finally, a flammability limit analysis in terms of the equivalence ratio was done. This analysis has the objective of verifying if the combustor will operate using the low heating value fuel. For the most engine operation cases investigated, the values were inside from minimum and maximum equivalence ratio range.


Author(s):  
Elliot Sullivan-Lewis ◽  
Vincent McDonell

Lean-premixed gas turbines are now common devices for low emissions stationary power generation. By creating a homogeneous mixture of fuel and air upstream of the combustion chamber, temperature variations are reduced within the combustor, which reduces emissions of nitrogen oxides. However, by premixing fuel and air, a potentially flammable mixture is established in a part of the engine not designed to contain a flame. If the flame propagates upstream from the combustor (flashback), significant engine damage can result. While significant effort has been put into developing flashback resistant combustors, these combustors are only capable of preventing flashback during steady operation of the engine. Transient events (e.g., auto-ignition within the premixer and pressure spikes during ignition) can trigger flashback that cannot be prevented with even the best combustor design. In these cases, preventing engine damage requires designing premixers that will not allow a flame to be sustained. Experimental studies were conducted to determine under what conditions premixed flames of hydrogen and natural gas can be anchored in a simulated gas turbine premixer. Tests have been conducted at pressures up to 9 atm, temperatures up to 750 K, and freestream velocities between 20 and 100 m/s. Flames were anchored in the wakes of features typical of premixer passageways, including cylinders, steps, and airfoils. The results of this study have been used to develop an engineering tool that predicts under what conditions a flame will anchor, and can be used for development of flame anchoring resistant gas turbine premixers.


Author(s):  
Jose Rodriguez ◽  
Stephan Klumpp ◽  
Thomas Biesinger ◽  
James O’Brien ◽  
Tobias Danninger

This paper presents a new design for a Compressor Inlet Manifold (CIM) for a land-based power generation Gas Turbine (turbine). The CIM is the component of the Inlet System (IS) that is directly connected to the turbine via the Compressor Inlet Case (CIC). The design philosophy is to use low fidelity but fast and automated CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamics) for design iterations and then confirm the design with detailed higher accuracy CFD before proceeding to engine tests. New design features include contouring the wall to minimize areas of flow separation and associated unsteadiness and losses, and improvement of the flow quality into the compressor. The CIM in a land-based turbine acts as a nozzle whereas the inlet of an aircraft acts as a diffuser. The flow also enters the CIM at 90 deg to the engine axis. This leads to a pair of counter rotating vortices at the compressor inlet. Three main sources of flow distortions at the face of the compressor are identified: flow separations at outer walls of the IS and CIM struts and the counter rotating vortices. The higher accuracy CFD analysis including the complete IS, CIM and the first compressor stage, simulates the effect of these distortions on the compressor front stage at design conditions. A range of inlet distortion parameters are used to evaluate the inlet design. The well known DC60 based criterion derived from aircraft engines and other less known but published parameters are able to give an indication of how the compressor surge margin of stationary gas turbines is affected.


Author(s):  
John Hartranft ◽  
Bruce Thompson ◽  
Dan Groghan

Following the successful development of aircraft jet engines during World War II (WWII), the United States Navy began exploring the advantages of gas turbine engines for ship and boat propulsion. Early development soon focused on aircraft derivative (aero derivative) gas turbines for use in the United States Navy (USN) Fleet rather than engines developed specifically for marine and industrial applications due to poor results from a few of the early marine and industrial developments. Some of the new commercial jet engine powered aircraft that had emerged at the time were the Boeing 707 and the Douglas DC-8. It was from these early aircraft engine successes (both commercial and military) that engine cores such as the JT4-FT4 and others became available for USN ship and boat programs. The task of adapting the jet engine to the marine environment turned out to be a substantial task because USN ships were operated in a completely different environment than that of aircraft which caused different forms of turbine corrosion than that seen in aircraft jet engines. Furthermore, shipboard engines were expected to perform tens of thousands of hours before overhaul compared with a few thousand hours mean time between overhaul usually experienced in aircraft applications. To address the concerns of shipboard applications, standards were created for marine gas turbine shipboard qualification and installation. One of those standards was the development of a USN Standard Day for gas turbines. This paper addresses the topic of a Navy Standard Day as it relates to the introduction of marine gas turbines into the United States Navy Fleet and why it differs from other rating approaches. Lastly, this paper will address examples of issues encountered with early requirements and whether current requirements for the Navy Standard Day should be changed. Concerning other rating approaches, the paper will also address the issue of using an International Organization for Standardization, that is, an International Standard Day. It is important to address an ISO STD DAY because many original equipment manufacturers and commercial operators prefer to rate their aero derivative gas turbines based on an ISO STD DAY with no losses. The argument is that the ISO approach fully utilizes the power capability of the engine. This paper will discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the ISO STD DAY approach and how the USN STD DAY approach has benefitted the USN. For the future, with the advance of engine controllers and electronics, utilizing some of the features of an ISO STD DAY approach may be possible while maintaining the advantages of the USN STD DAY.


Author(s):  
Keishaly Cabrera Cruz ◽  
Paolo Pezzini ◽  
Lawrence Shadle ◽  
Kenneth M. Bryden

Abstract Compressor dynamics were studied in a gas turbine – fuel cell hybrid power system having a larger compressor volume than traditionally found in gas turbine systems. This larger compressor volume adversely affects the surge margin of the gas turbine. Industrial acoustic sensors were placed near the compressor to identify when the equipment was getting close to the surge line. Fast Fourier transform (FFT) mathematical analysis was used to obtain spectra representing the probability density across the frequency range (0–5000 Hz). Comparison between FFT spectra for nominal and transient operations revealed that higher amplitude spikes were observed during incipient stall at three different frequencies, 900, 1020, and 1800 Hz. These frequencies were compared to the natural frequencies of the equipment and the frequency for the rotating turbomachinery to identify more general nature of the acoustic signal typical of the onset of compressor surge. The primary goal of this acoustic analysis was to establish an online methodology to monitor compressor stability that can be anticipated and avoided.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document