Investigation on the Reduction of Trailing Edge Shock Losses for a Highly Loaded Transonic Turbine

Author(s):  
Wei Zhao ◽  
Weiwei Luo ◽  
Qingjun Zhao ◽  
Jianzhong Xu

A shock loss reduction method for highly loaded transonic turbine blades with convergent passages is presented. The method is illustrated with an improved blade profile that employs a negative curvature curve on its uncovered suction side. The improved profile and a conventional baseline profile are applied to two cascades with the same solidity, chord and aspect ratio respectively. The numerical simulation results for the two cascades show that a reduction of 4.58% in the total pressure loss coefficient is obtained for the improved profile at the design condition. The effects of back pressures on the performance of both cascades are also presented, and the improved blade profile shows a much better part-load performance. The paper compares the flow fields of the baseline and the improved blade profiles to understand loss reduction mechanism especially by analyzing the shock interactions downstream of the trailing edge. It is found that, for the improved profile, the reflected shock of pressure side leg of the trailing-edge shock rotates forward and the suction side leg of the trailing-edge shock rotates backward. Therefore, the two shocks delay their intersection points where they merge into a relatively strong shock, and consequently produce less shock losses than those of the baseline profile.

Author(s):  
D. Corriveau ◽  
S. A. Sjolander

Experimental results concerning the performance of three high-pressure (HP) transonic turbine blades having fore-, aft- and mid-loadings have been presented previously by Corriveau and Sjolander [1]. Results from that study indicated that by shifting the loading towards the rear of the airfoil, improvements in loss performance of the order of 20% could be obtained near the design Mach number. In order to gain a better understanding of the underlying reasons for the improved loss performance of the aft-loaded blade, additional measurements were performed on the three cascades. Furthermore, 2-D numerical simulations of the cascade flow were performed in order to help in the interpretation of the experimental results. Based on the analysis of additional wake traverse data and base pressure measurements combined with the numerical results, it was found that the poorer loss performance of the baseline mid-loaded profile compared to the aft-loaded blade could be traced back to the former’s higher rear suction side curvature. The presence of higher rear suction surface curvature resulted in higher flow velocity in that region. Higher flow velocity at the trailing edge in turn contributed to reducing the base pressure. The lower base pressure at the trailing edge resulted in a stronger trailing edge shock system for the mid-loaded blade. This shock system increased the losses for the mid-loaded baseline profile when compared to the aft-loaded profile.


Author(s):  
Marion Mack ◽  
Roland Brachmanski ◽  
Reinhard Niehuis

The performance of the low pressure turbine (LPT) can vary appreciably, because this component operates under a wide range of Reynolds numbers. At higher Reynolds numbers, mid and aft loaded profiles have the advantage that transition of suction side boundary layer happens further downstream than at front loaded profiles, resulting in lower profile loss. At lower Reynolds numbers, aft loading of the blade can mean that if a suction side separation exists, it may remain open up to the trailing edge. This is especially the case when blade lift is increased via increased pitch to chord ratio. There is a trend in research towards exploring the effect of coupling boundary layer control with highly loaded turbine blades, in order to maximize performance over the full relevant Reynolds number range. In an earlier work, pulsed blowing with fluidic oscillators was shown to be effective in reducing the extent of the separated flow region and to significantly decrease the profile losses caused by separation over a wide range of Reynolds numbers. These experiments were carried out in the High-Speed Cascade Wind Tunnel of the German Federal Armed Forces University Munich, Germany, which allows to capture the effects of pulsed blowing at engine relevant conditions. The assumed control mechanism was the triggering of boundary layer transition by excitation of the Tollmien-Schlichting waves. The current work aims to gain further insight into the effects of pulsed blowing. It investigates the effect of a highly efficient configuration of pulsed blowing at a frequency of 9.5 kHz on the boundary layer at a Reynolds number of 70000 and exit Mach number of 0.6. The boundary layer profiles were measured at five positions between peak Mach number and the trailing edge with hot wire anemometry and pneumatic probes. Experiments were conducted with and without actuation under steady as well as periodically unsteady inflow conditions. The results show the development of the boundary layer and its interaction with incoming wakes. It is shown that pulsed blowing accelerates transition over the separation bubble and drastically reduces the boundary layer thickness.


Author(s):  
Mathias Deckers ◽  
John D. Denton

A theoretical and computational study into the aerodynamics of trailing-edge-cooled transonic turbine blades is described in this part of the paper. The theoretical study shows that, for unstaggered blades with coolant ejection, the base pressure and overall loss can be determined exactly by a simple control volume analysis. This theory suggests that a thick, cooled trailing edge with a wide slot can be more efficient than a thin, solid trailing edge. An existing time-marching finite volume method is adapted to calculate the transonic flow with trailing edge coolant ejection on a structured, quasi-orthogonal mesh. Good overall agreement between the present method, inviscid and viscous, and experimental evidence is obtained.


Author(s):  
Sarwesh Parbat ◽  
Li Yang ◽  
Minking Chyu ◽  
Sin Chien Siw ◽  
Ching-Pang Lee

Abstract The strive to achieve increasingly higher efficiencies in gas turbine power generation has led to a continued rise in the turbine inlet temperature. As a result, novel cooling approaches for gas turbine blades are necessary to maintain them within the material’s thermal mechanical performance envelope. Various internal and external cooling technologies are used in different parts of the blade airfoil to provide the desired levels of cooling. Among the different regions of the blade profile, the trailing edge (TE) presents additional cooling challenges due to the thin cross section and high thermal loads. In this study, a new wavy geometry for the TE has been proposed and analyzed using steady state numerical simulations. The wavy TE structure resembled a sinusoidal wave running along the span of the blade. The troughs on both pressure side and suction side contained the coolant exit slots. As a result, consecutive coolant exit slots provided an alternating discharge between the suction side and the pressure side of the blade. Steady state conjugate heat transfer simulations were carried out using CFX solver for four coolant to mainstream mass flow ratios of 0.45%, 1%, 1.5% and 3%. The temperature distribution and film cooling effectiveness in the TE region were compared to two conventional geometries, pressure side cutback and centerline ejection which are widely used in vanes and blades for both land-based and aviation gas turbine engines. Unstructured mesh was generated for both fluid and solid domains and interfaces were defined between the two domains. For turbulence closer, SST-kω model was used. The wall y+ was maintained < 1 by using inflation layers at all the solid fluid interfaces. The numerical results depicted that the alternating discharge from the wavy TE was able to form protective film coverage on both the pressure and suction side of the blade. As a result, significant reduction in the TE metal was observed which was up to 14% lower in volume averaged temperature in the TE region when compared to the two baseline conventional configurations.


Author(s):  
D. J. Mee

Experimental techniques associated with the measurement of loss of transonic turbine blades with trailing-edge region coolant ejection are considered. Results from experiments with different coolant to free stream gas density ratios indicate that it is not always adequate to simulate only the coolant blowing rate. However, for the measurement of loss, the present experimental results indicate that it may be adequate to simulate the momentum flux ratio. In loss calculations the value used for the total pressure of the coolant gas is discussed and shown to influence a comparison of different cooling geometries.


1990 ◽  
Vol 112 (2) ◽  
pp. 277-285 ◽  
Author(s):  
J. D. Denton ◽  
L. Xu

Trailing edge loss is one of the main sources of loss for transonic turbine blades, contributing typically 1/3 of their total loss. Transonic trailing edge flow is extremely complex, the basic flow pattern is understood but methods of predicting the loss are currently based on empirical correlations for the base pressure. These correlations are of limited accuracy. Recent findings that the base pressure and loss can be reasonably well predicted by inviscid Euler calculations are justified and explained in this paper. For unstaggered choked blading, it is shown that there is a unique relationship between the back pressure and the base pressure and any calculation that conserves mass, energy and momentum should predict this relationship and the associated loss exactly. For realistic staggered blading, which operates choked but with subsonic axial velocity, there is also a unique relationship between the back pressure and the base pressure (and hence loss) but the relationship cannot be quantified without knowing a further relationship between the base pressure and the average suction surface pressure downstream of the throat. Any calculation that conserves mass, energy and momentum and also predicts this average suction surface pressure correctly will again predict the base pressure and loss. Two-dimensional Euler solutions do not predict the suction surface pressure exactly because of shock smearing but nevertheless seem to give reasonably accurate results. The effects of boundary layer thickness and trailing edge coolant ejection are considered briefly. Coolant ejection acts to reduce the mainstream loss. It is shown that suction surface curvature downstream of the throat may be highly beneficial in reducing the loss of blades with thick trailing edges operating at high subsonic or low supersonic outlet Mach numbers.


Author(s):  
Jorge Parra ◽  
David Cadrecha ◽  
Ezequiel González ◽  
Benigno Lázaro

The losses breakdown of modern highly loaded low pressure turbines profiles shows that the trailing edge thickness can account for up to 20% of the overall profile loss depending on the thickness to pitch ratio highly affecting to the LPT overall performance. Additionally, this feature is of significant practical interest as the aerofoil mechanical behaviour and manufacturing costs are largely determined by the size of the trailing edge. Current trailing edge loss models are based on correlations derived from measurements on aerofoils very different with respect to the current state-of-the-art, they do not consider any effect of Reynolds number or lift coefficient, so it is questionable whether they are accurate enough for current applications and therefore an experimental validation campaign is required. The aim of the present experimental investigation is to examine the influence of that geometrical parameter on the unsteady Reynolds lapse characterization by means of four different low speed linear cascades varying the thickness from 50% to 200% of a nominal case. Cascades A, B and C (with small, nominal and large thickness) meet the same lift coefficient reducing the back surface diffusion factor due to the different velocity at the trailing edge because of the blockage generated by the trailing edge thickness. Cascade B2, with nominal thickness, is modified to meet the same diffusion factor as Cascade A to decouple the effect of the diffusion factor from the effect of the trailing edge thickness. Total pressure probes, Laser-Doppler and hot wire anemometry are used to characterize the suction side boundary layer just upstream from the trailing edge as well as the near wake developing close to the trailing edge. Additional characterisations are conducted at half chord downstream from the cascade trailing edge to evaluate its loss coefficient. Upstream located moving bars are used to simulate the incoming wakes shed by one upstream blade row. The hot wire measurements performed slightly upstream from the profile trailing edge are post-processed locked to the passage of the moving bars. The resulting data are analysed to characterise the temporal modulation of the suction side boundary layer momentum thickness by the incoming wakes. The measurements indicate that both the time-mean value and the phase-averaged distribution of the boundary layer integral parameters are largely determined by the diffusion rate of the profile. On the other hand, a negligible effect of the trailing edge thickness is observed for the same diffusion rate. The measurements conducted downstream from the profile, both close to its trailing edge and half chord downstream, illustrate the role of the trailing edge thickness on the initial wake development. The data is recorded for 60s with a sampling rate of 25kHz obtaining between 150 and 650 phase-locked datasets depending on the Reynolds No. Finally, the characterisation of the profile mix-out losses at the downstream plane is presented. The experimental results show that a significant reduction of losses can be achieved with thinner trailing edge, but, an increase in the number of aerofoils need to be allowed in order to get the full potential benefit of this strategy.


Author(s):  
Reinaldo A. Gomes ◽  
Reinhard Niehuis

Film cooling experiments were run at the High-Speed Cascade Wind Tunnel of the University of the Federal Armed Forces Munich. The investigations were carried out on a linear cascade of highly loaded turbine blades. The main targets of the tests were to assess the film cooling effectiveness and the heat transfer in zones with main flow separation. The previous cascade was designed to have a large zone with flow separation on the pressure side starting at the leading edge and reaching up to approximately half of the axial chord. This cascade was changed for a new design with a larger pitch to chord ratio in order to set the focus on flow separation on the suction side. This increased pitch forces a massive separation on the suction side due to strong shocks. The flow separation is controlled with aid of vortex generating jets in order to reduce the total pressure loss caused by it. Film cooling is provided on the suction side upstream of the vortex generating jets. The measurements comprise of blade loading, profile loss, adiabatic film cooling effectiveness and heat transfer coefficient under two Mach numbers at a Reynolds number of 390,000. In a previous publication detailed results with homogeneous inflow where shown. Now, the focus is set on the effects of periodic unsteady wakes resulting from bars moving upstream of the cascade. These moving bars create a periodic unsteady inflow similar to the interaction between stator and rotor in the machine. It is shown how these wakes have significant influence on the heat transfer in the acceleration region of the suction side and affect the adiabatic film cooling effectiveness upstream of the shock.


Author(s):  
Mathias Deckers ◽  
John D. Denton

The research presented in this part of the paper involved a detailed experimental study of the flow through transonic turbine blading with trailing edge coolant ejection. The tests were carried out on (nearly) flat plate models representing the region of uncovered turning downstream of the throat. The investigation focused on the aerodynamic aspects associated with trailing edge ejection in steady two-dimensional flow over a range of exit Mach numbers, coolant pressure ratios and temperature ratios. The experiments showed that the simple existence of the coolant cavity leads to a substantial change of the flow field in the near wake. Consequently, the slotted unblown base was found to have considerably less loss than the solid one. The effect of coolant ejection is shown to cause a substantial increase in base pressure and reduction in overall loss. The surface static pressure distribution and boundary layers were affected by the coolant in two ways: directly from downstream, via the base pressure, and indirectly through a changed trailing edge shock system. However, the coolant stagnation temperature ratio was found to have no discernible effect on the base pressure and loss.


Author(s):  
C. H. Sieverding

This paper summarizes the results of base pressure studies on transonic turbine blades in presence of an ejection of coolant flow from a slot in the trailing edge. The first part of the paper reports on tests carried out on a enlarged model of the overhang section of a typical transonic cascade. This model provides valuable information about the detailed trailing edge pressure distribution and points to an asymmetric evolution of the base pressure on both sides of the slot in presence of a bleed. The second part of the paper presents experimental results from cascade tests covering an outlet Mach number range from M2, is = 0.5 to 1.35. These experiments underline the importance of the coolant flow impact on the base pressure and confirm the asymmetry of the base pressure with respect to the cooling slot. Tests with different coolant flow gases point to the significance of a proper simulation of the density ratio between coolant flow and main flow.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document