On the Effect of Clearance on the Leakage and Cavity Pressures in an Interlocking Labyrinth Seal Operating With and Without Swirl Brakes: Experiments and Predictions

Author(s):  
Luis San Andrés ◽  
Jing Yang ◽  
Rimpei Kawashita

Abstract Gas labyrinth seals (LSs) improve turbomachinery operational efficiency and mechanical reliability by reducing secondary leakage. As interlocking labyrinth seals (ILSs) restrict more leakage than conventional see-through LSs, attention is due to their performance. An earlier paper [1] details the performance of a particular ILS in an ad-hoc test rig via measurements of mass flow (leakage) and cavity pressures while supplied with pressurized air at ambient temperature and operating with a rotor speed to a maximum of 10 krpm (surface speed 79 m/s). The test seal comprises of two teeth on the rotor and three teeth on the stator to make a four cavity seal with radial clearance Cr = 0.2 mm. The experimental and numerical leakages for the ILS produce a modified flow factor (Φ¯) that is independent of the seal operating conditions, namely inlet pressure, discharge pressure and rotor speed. The finding leads to an orifice-like loss coefficient cd = 0.36 and an effective clearance (cd × Cr) for the test seal, thus evidencing its effectiveness in reducing leakage. To complement the former research, this paper reports measurements of the leakage and cavity pressures for the same geometry interlocking labyrinth seals configured with two other clearances Cr = 0.3 mm and 0.13 mm. For the ILS with Cr = 0.3 mm, a first configuration is without a swirl brake (baseline), the second is with a swirl brake with 0° teeth pitch (axial ribs), and the third configuration is with a swirl brake with teeth angled at 40° in the direction of shaft rotation. For tests conducted without shaft rotation and with rotor spinning at 7.5 krpm (surface speed = 59 m/s), the inlet air pressure (Pin) ranges from 0.29 MPa to 0.98 MPa, while the exit pressure (Pout) is set to pressure ratios PR = (Pout/Pin) = 0.3, 0.5, 0.8. As to the ILS with Cr = 0.13 mm, it operates with an upstream swirl brake with axial ribs (0° teeth pitch) and w/o rotor speed. The supply pressure (Pin) varies from 0.59 MPa to 1.4 MPa and PR = 0.3, 0.5. The measurements and bulk-flow model predictions show that the seal mass leakage is proportional to the inlet pressure (Pin), increases as PR decreases, and is not affected by either shaft speed or the swirl brake configuration. Seal cavity static pressures drop linearly for all inlet pressures (Pin) and PR = 0.5 and above; except under a choked flow condition at PR = 0.3. Processing of the test data to consolidate the numerous leakage measurements delivers a nearly invariant flow factor Φ¯ for each seal clearance, and from this follows a unique orifice-like loss coefficient cd = 0.36 for the ILS with Cr = 0.3 mm, and cd = 0.33 for the ILS with Cr = 0.13 mm. This finding is remarkable as the test results obtained for the ILS with Cr = 0.2 mm also deliver a similar loss coefficient (cd = 0.36). Finally, predictions of ILS leakage and cavity pressures are within 5% of the measurements for all test conditions. The test data and predictions are of significant value to better the selection and design of gas labyrinth seals in turbomachinery.

Author(s):  
Luis San Andres ◽  
Jing Yang ◽  
Rimpei Kawashita

Abstract Gas labyrinth seals (LSs) improve turbomachinery operational efficiency and mechanical reliability by reducing secondary leakage. As interlocking labyrinth seals (ILSs) restrict more leakage than see-through LSs, attention is due to their performance.The paper reports measurements of the leakage and cavity pressures for a five teeth ILS configured with two clearances Cr = 0.3 mm and 0.13 mm. For the ILS with Cr = 0.3 mm, a first configuration is without a swirl brake, the second is with a swirl brake with 0° teeth pitch, and the third is with a swirl brake with teeth angled at 40° in the rotation direction. As to the ILS with Cr = 0.13 mm, it operates with a swirl brake with 0° teeth pitch and w/o rotor speed. The measurements and predictions show that the seal leakage is proportional to the inlet pressure, and is not affected by either shaft speed or the swirl brake configuration. Processing of the test data to consolidate the numerous leakage measurements delivers a nearly invariant flow factor for each clearance, and from this follows a unique orifice-like loss coefficient cd = 0.36 for Cr = 0.3 mm, and cd = 0.33 for Cr = 0.13 mm. This finding is remarkable as the earlier measurements obtained for the ILS with Cr = 0.2 mm also deliver a similar loss coefficient (cd = 0.36). The test data and predictions are of significant value to better the selection and design of gas labyrinth seals in turbomachinery.


Author(s):  
Luis San Andrés ◽  
Tingcheng Wu ◽  
Jose Barajas-Rivera ◽  
Jiaxin Zhang ◽  
Rimpei Kawashita

Abstract Gas labyrinth seals (LS) restrict secondary flows (leakage) in turbomachinery and their impact on the efficiency and rotordynamic stability of high-pressure compressors and steam turbines can hardly be overstated. Amongst seal types, the interlocking labyrinth seal (ILS), having teeth on both the rotor and on the stator, is able to reduce leakage up to 30% compared to other LSs with either all teeth on the rotor or all teeth on the stator. This paper introduces a revamped facility to test gas seals for their rotordynamic performance and presents measurements of the leakage and cavity pressures in a five teeth ILS. The seal with overall length/diameter L/D = 0.3 and small tip clearance Cr/D = 0.00133 is supplied with air at T = 298 K and increasing inlet pressure Pin = 0.3 MPa ∼ 1.3 MPa, while the exit pressure/inlet pressure ratio PR = Pout/Pin is set to range from 0.3 to 0.8. The rotor speed varies from null to 10 krpm (79 m/s max. surface speed). During the tests, instrumentation records the seal mass flow (ṁ) and static pressure in each cavity. In parallel, a bulk-flow model (BFM) and a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis predict the flow field and deliver the same performance characteristics, namely leakage and cavity pressures. Both measurements and predictions agree closely (within 5%) and demonstrate the seal mass flow rate is independent of rotor speed. A modified flow factor Φ¯=m.T/PinD1-PR2 characterizes best the seal mass flow with a unique magnitude for all pressure conditions, Pin and PR.


Author(s):  
Chris Holt ◽  
Luis San Andre´s ◽  
Sunil Sahay ◽  
Peter Tang ◽  
Gerry La Rue ◽  
...  

Measurements of casing acceleration on an automotive turbocharger running to a top speed of 115 krpm and driven by ambient temperature pressurized air are reported. Waterfall acceleration spectra versus rotor speed show the effects of increasing lubricant inlet pressure and temperature on the turbocharger rotordynamic response. A comprehensive analysis of the test data forwards regimes of speed operation with two subsynchronous whirl motions (rotordynamic instabilities). Increasing the lubricant feed pressure delays the onset speed of instability for the most severe subsynchronous motion. However, increasing the lubricant feed pressure also produces larger synchronous displacements. The effect of lubricant feed temperature is minimal on the onset and end speeds of rotordynamic instability. Nevertheless, operation with a cold lubricant exhibits lower amplitudes of motion, synchronous and subsynchronous. The experimental results show the subsynchronous frequencies of motion do not lock (whip) at system natural frequencies but continuously track the rotor speed. No instabilities (subsynchronous whirl) remain for operating speeds above 90 krpm. Bearings greatly influence turbocharger (TC) rotordynamic performance.


Author(s):  
Stephen P. Arthur ◽  
Dara W. Childs

Rotordynamic and leakage data are presented for a see-through tooth-on-rotor (TOR) labyrinth seal with comparisons to a see-through tooth-on-stator (TOS) labyrinth seal. Measurements for both seals are also compared to predictions from XLLaby. Both seals have identical diameter and can be considered as relatively long labyrinth seals. The TOR seal has a length-to-diameter ratio of 0.62, whereas the TOS seal is longer and has a length-to-diameter ratio of 0.75. Both seals also differ by number of teeth, tooth height, and tooth cavity length. TOR labyrinth tests were carried out at an inlet pressure of 70 bar-a (1,015 psia), pressure ratios of 0.4, 0.5, and 0.6, rotor speeds up to 20,200 rpm, a radial clearance of 0.1 mm (4 mils), and three preswirl ratios. For comparison, TOS labyrinth tests were run at identical conditions as the TOR tests but for only one positive preswirl ratio. TOR labyrinth measurements show a pronounced dependence of rotordynamic coefficients on rotor speed, especially when compared to prior documented TOS labyrinth seal tests run at a radial clearance of 0.2 mm (8mils). The TOR labyrinth cross-coupled stiffness is higher in magnitude and increases at a higher rate than that of the TOS labyrinth across all test speeds. However, the TOR labyrinth effective damping was determined to be greater due to higher measurements of direct damping. Measured leakage rates for the TOR labyrinth were approximately 5–10% less than the TOS labyrinth. XLLaby underpredicted the rotordynamic coefficients for both seals. However, as with measurements, it predicted the TOR labyrinth to have higher effective damping than the TOS labyrinth.


Author(s):  
Tingcheng Wu ◽  
Luis San Andrés

Abstract Though simple and fast, bulk-flow models (BFMs) for gas labyrinth seals (LSs) often predict the mass flow inaccurately. The BFM models rely on classical Neumann’s equation model to characterize the flow through a labyrinth tooth. Presently, a CFD analysis quantifies the effects of tip clearance (Cr) and operating conditions on the prediction of LS mass flow, and then derives an updated kinetic energy carry-over coefficient (μ1i) to improve the accuracy of Neumann’s leakage equation. μ1i is a function of the seal tip clearance (Cr), the tooth pitch, and the total teeth number; but it does not depend on the seal supply or discharge pressures. The analysis selects a fourteen teeth on stator LS (Length/Diameter = L/D = 0.29) with clearance Cr = (1/733)D and operating at nominal supply (Pin) and discharge (Pout) pressures equal to 73 bar and 51 bar, respectively, and at a rotor speed of 12 krpm (surface speed = 138 m/s.). The CFD produces flow fields for LSs with a clearance varying from 80% to 200% of the nominal Cr, a gas supply pressure from 60 bar to 100 bar, and with various discharge pressures giving a pressure ratio (PR = Pout/Pin) ranging from 0.40 to 0.85. The numerous predictions deliver the mass flow as well as the bulk-flow velocities and cavity pressures within the seals. The kinetic energy carry-over coefficient (μ1i) increases with respect to the seal radial clearance (Cr). μ1i shows a parabolic correlation with PR; at first μ1i increases with a rise in PR from a low value; and then a further increase in PR leads to a decrease in μ1i. The coefficient μ1i is only sensitive to the pressure ratio and not to the magnitude of either the supply or discharge pressures. Lastly, for use with Neumann’s leakage model, the CFD predictions produce an updated μ1i, a function of the seal geometry and the PR condition. Integration of the new μ1i correlation into a BFM code improves its accuracy to predict LS mass flow rate, a 19% difference against test data reduces to within 6%. A TOS LS tested by Ertas et al. (2012) serves to further validate the accuracy of the modified leakage model.


2020 ◽  
Vol 142 (12) ◽  
Author(s):  
Tingcheng Wu ◽  
Luis San Andrés

Abstract Though simple and fast, bulk-flow models (BFMs) for gas labyrinth seals (LSs) often predict the mass flow inaccurately. The BFM models rely on classical Neumann's equation model to characterize the flow through a labyrinth tooth. Presently, a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis quantifies the effects of tip clearance (Cr) and operating conditions on the prediction of LS mass flow, and then derives an updated kinetic energy carry-over coefficient (μ1i) to improve the accuracy of Neumann's leakage equation. μ1i is a function of the seal tip clearance (Cr), the tooth pitch, and the total teeth number; but it does not depend on the seal supply or discharge pressures. The analysis selects a 14-teeth on stator LS (length/diameter = L/D = 0.29) with clearance Cr = (1/733)D and operating at nominal supply (Pin) and discharge (Pout) pressures equal to 73 bar and 51 bar, respectively, and at a rotor speed of 12 krpm (surface speed = 138 m/s). The CFD produces flow fields for LSs with a clearance varying from 80% to 200% of the nominal Cr, a gas supply pressure from 60 bar to 100 bar, and with various discharge pressures giving a pressure ratio (PR = Pout/Pin) ranging from 0.40 to 0.85. The numerous predictions deliver the mass flow as well as the bulk-flow velocities and cavity pressures within the seals. The kinetic energy carry-over coefficient (μ1i) increases with respect to the seal radial clearance (Cr). μ1i shows a parabolic correlation with PR; at first, μ1i increases with a rise in PR from a low value; and then, a further increase in PR leads to a decrease in μ1i. The coefficient μ1i is only sensitive to the PR and not to the magnitude of either the supply or discharge pressures. Lastly, for use with Neumann's leakage model, the CFD predictions produce an updated μ1i, a function of the seal geometry and the PR condition. Integration of the new μ1i correlation into a BFM code improves its accuracy to predict LS mass flow rate, a 19% difference against test data reduces to within 6%. A TOS LS tested by Ertas et al. (2012, Rotordynamic Force Coefficients for Three Types of Annular Gas Seals With Inlet Preswirl and High Differential Pressure Ratio,” ASME J. Eng. Gas Turbine Power, 134(4), p. 4250301) serves to further validate the accuracy of the modified leakage model.


2019 ◽  
Vol 141 (10) ◽  
Author(s):  
Luis San Andrés ◽  
Tingcheng Wu ◽  
Jose Barajas-Rivera ◽  
Jiaxin Zhang ◽  
Rimpei Kawashita

Gas labyrinth seals (LS) restrict secondary flows (leakage) in turbomachinery and their impact on the efficiency and rotordynamic stability of high-pressure compressors and steam turbines can hardly be overstated. Among seal types, the interlocking labyrinth seal (ILS), having teeth on both the rotor and the stator, is able to reduce leakage up to 30% compared to other LSs with either all teeth on the rotor (TOR) or all teeth on the stator. This paper introduces a revamped facility to test gas seals for their rotordynamic performance and presents measurements of the leakage and cavity pressures in a five teeth ILS. The seal with overall length/diameter L/D = 0.3 and small tip clearance Cr/D = 0.00133 is supplied with air at T = 298 K and increasing inlet pressure Pin = 0.3–1.3 MPa, while the exit pressure/inlet pressure ratio PR = Pout/Pin is set to range from 0.3 to 0.8. The rotor speed varies from null to 10 krpm (79 m/s max. surface speed). During the tests, instrumentation records the seal mass flow (m˙) and static pressure in each cavity. In parallel, a bulk-flow model (BFM) and a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis predict the flow field and deliver the same performance characteristics, namely leakage and cavity pressures. Both measurements and predictions agree closely (within 5%) and demonstrate that the seal mass flow rate is independent of rotor speed. A modified flow factor Φ¯=m˙T/(PinD1−PR2) characterizes best the seal mass flow with a unique magnitude for all pressure conditions, Pin and PR.


Author(s):  
Manuel Gaszner ◽  
Alexander O. Pugachev ◽  
Christos Georgakis ◽  
Paul Cooper

A brush-labyrinth sealing configuration consisting of two labyrinth fins upstream and one brush seal downstream is studied experimentally and theoretically. Two slightly different brush seal designs with zero cold radial clearance are considered. The sealing configurations are tested on the no-whirl and dynamic test rigs to obtain leakage performance and rotordynamic stiffness and damping coefficients. The no-whirl tests allow identification of the local rotordynamic direct and cross-coupled stiffness coefficients for a wide range of operating conditions, while the dynamic test rig is used to obtain both global stiffness and damping coefficients, but for a narrower operating range limited by the capabilities of a magnetic actuator. Modeling of the brush-labyrinth seals is performed using computational fluid dynamics. The experimental global rotordynamic coefficients consist of an aerodynamic component due to the gas flow and a mechanical component due to the contact between the bristle tips and rotor surface. The CFD-based calculations of rotordynamic coefficients provide however only the aerodynamic component. A simple mechanical model is used to estimate the theoretical value of the mechanical stiffness of the bristle pack during the contact. The results obtained for the sealing configurations with zero cold radial clearance brush seals are compared with available data on three-tooth-on-stator labyrinth seals and a brush seal with positive cold radial clearance. Results show that the sealing arrangement with a line-on-line welded brush seal has the best performance overall with the lowest leakage and cross-coupled stiffness. The predictions are generally in agreement with the measurements for leakage and stiffness coefficients. The seal damping capability is noticeably underpredicted.


2020 ◽  
Vol 26 (3) ◽  
pp. 126-130
Author(s):  
Krasimir Kalev

AbstractA schematic diagram of a hydraulic drive system is provided to stabilize the speed of the working body by compensating for volumetric losses in the hydraulic motor. The diagram shows the inclusion of an originally developed self-adjusting choke whose flow rate in the inlet pressure change range tends to reverse - with increasing pressure the flow through it decreases. Dependent on the hydraulic characteristics of the hydraulic motor and the specific operating conditions.


2019 ◽  
Vol 80 (12) ◽  
pp. 2310-2319 ◽  
Author(s):  
Prashant Dhanke ◽  
Sameer Wagh ◽  
Abhijeet Patil

Abstract Water generated from the fish processing industry is contaminated with organic matter. This organic matter present in wastewater increases the biochemical oxygen demand (BOD) and chemical oxygen demand (COD). A new technology, hydrodynamic cavitation (HC) is used to deal with this wastewater produced in fish processing plants. The orifice plate is used in the HC reactor to generate a cavitation effect. The intensification of this technique was carried out with the help of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) and TiO2. The treatment of this wastewater is reported in terms of percent degradation in BOD and COD and in biodegradability index (BI). Operating parameters like inlet pressure, pH, operating temperature and H2O2 doses were used to find the optimum condition. 15 g/L of H2O2 gave 69.5% reduction of COD in the 120 min of treatment that also increases BI value to 0.93 at inlet pressure 8 bar, Plate-5, temperature (30 °C), and pH 4. In the ultrasonic cavitation (UC) reactor, COD reduction is 68.7% without TiO2 and with TiO2 it is 71.2%. Also, this HC and UC reactor reduced CFU count to a great extent at the same operating conditions.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document