Comment on “Rethinking the Lower Bound on Aerosol Radiative Forcing”

2017 ◽  
Vol 30 (16) ◽  
pp. 6579-6584 ◽  
Author(s):  
Jan Kretzschmar ◽  
Marc Salzmann ◽  
Johannes Mülmenstädt ◽  
Olivier Boucher ◽  
Johannes Quaas
Keyword(s):  
Radiative Forcing ◽  
Climate Models ◽  
Coupled Model ◽  
Warming Trend ◽  
Anthropogenic Aerosols ◽  
Aerosol Radiative Forcing ◽  
Aerosol Forcing ◽  
Interesting Study ◽  
Log Linear ◽  
Negative Formula

In an influential and interesting study, Stevens (2015) suggested that the global and also Northern Hemispheric warming during the early industrial period implies that the effective radiative forcing [Formula: see text] by anthropogenic aerosols in the year 2000 compared to 1850 cannot be more negative than −1.0 W m−2. Here results from phase 5 of the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project are analyzed and it is shown that there is little relationship between [Formula: see text] and the warming trend in the early industrial period in comprehensive climate models. In particular, some models simulate a warming in the early industrial period despite a strong (very negative) [Formula: see text]. The reason for this difference in results is that the global-mean log-linear scaling of [Formula: see text] with anthropogenic sulfur dioxide emissions introduced and used by Stevens tends to produce a substantially larger aerosol forcing compared to climate models in the first half of the twentieth century, when SO2 emissions were concentrated over smaller regions. In turn, it shows smaller (less negative) [Formula: see text] in the recent period with comparatively more widespread SO2 emissions.

scholarly journals Reply to “Comment on ‘Rethinking the Lower Bound on Aerosol Radiative Forcing’”

2017 ◽  
Vol 30 (16) ◽  
pp. 6585-6589 ◽  
Author(s):  
Bjorn Stevens ◽  
Stephanie Fiedler
Keyword(s):  
Twentieth Century ◽  
Lower Bound ◽  
Radiative Forcing ◽  
Climate Models ◽  
Anthropogenic Aerosols ◽  
Anthropogenic Aerosol ◽  
Aerosol Radiative Forcing ◽  
Clear Sky ◽  
The North ◽  
Aerosol Forcing

Kretzschmar et al., in a comment in 2017, use the spread in the output of aerosol–climate models to argue that the models refute the hypothesis (presented in a paper by Stevens in 2015) that for the mid-twentieth-century warming to be consistent with observations, then the present-day aerosol forcing, [Formula: see text] must be less negative than −1 W m−2. The main point of contention is the nature of the relationship between global SO2 emissions and [Formula: see text] In contrast to the concave (log-linear) relationship used by Stevens and in earlier studies, whereby [Formula: see text] becomes progressively less sensitive to SO2 emissions, some models suggest a convex relationship, which would imply a less negative lower bound. The model that best exemplifies this difference, and that is most clearly in conflict with the hypothesis of Stevens, does so because of an implausible aerosol response to the initial rise in anthropogenic aerosol precursor emissions in East and South Asia—already in 1975 this model’s clear-sky reflectance from anthropogenic aerosol over the North Pacific exceeds present-day estimates of the clear-sky reflectance by the total aerosol. The authors perform experiments using a new (observationally constrained) climatology of anthropogenic aerosols to further show that the effects of changing patterns of aerosol and aerosol precursor emissions during the late twentieth century have, for the same global emissions, relatively little effect on [Formula: see text] These findings suggest that the behavior Kretzschmar et al. identify as being in conflict with the lower bound in Stevens arises from an implausible relationship between SO2 emissions and [Formula: see text] and thus provides little basis for revising this lower bound.

scholarly journals Effective radiative forcing and adjustments in CMIP6 models

2020 ◽  
Vol 20 (16) ◽  
pp. 9591-9618 ◽  
Author(s):  
Christopher J. Smith ◽  
Ryan J. Kramer ◽  
Gunnar Myhre ◽  
Kari Alterskjær ◽  
William Collins ◽  
...  
Keyword(s):  
Climate Sensitivity ◽  
Radiative Forcing ◽  
Climate Models ◽  
Coupled Model ◽  
Internal Variability ◽  
Cmip5 Models ◽  
Model Intercomparison ◽  
Aerosol Forcing ◽  
Intercomparison Project ◽  
Effective Radiative Forcing

Abstract. The effective radiative forcing, which includes the instantaneous forcing plus adjustments from the atmosphere and surface, has emerged as the key metric of evaluating human and natural influence on the climate. We evaluate effective radiative forcing and adjustments in 17 contemporary climate models that are participating in the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP6) and have contributed to the Radiative Forcing Model Intercomparison Project (RFMIP). Present-day (2014) global-mean anthropogenic forcing relative to pre-industrial (1850) levels from climate models stands at 2.00 (±0.23) W m−2, comprised of 1.81 (±0.09) W m−2 from CO2, 1.08 (± 0.21) W m−2 from other well-mixed greenhouse gases, −1.01 (± 0.23) W m−2 from aerosols and −0.09 (±0.13) W m−2 from land use change. Quoted uncertainties are 1 standard deviation across model best estimates, and 90 % confidence in the reported forcings, due to internal variability, is typically within 0.1 W m−2. The majority of the remaining 0.21 W m−2 is likely to be from ozone. In most cases, the largest contributors to the spread in effective radiative forcing (ERF) is from the instantaneous radiative forcing (IRF) and from cloud responses, particularly aerosol–cloud interactions to aerosol forcing. As determined in previous studies, cancellation of tropospheric and surface adjustments means that the stratospherically adjusted radiative forcing is approximately equal to ERF for greenhouse gas forcing but not for aerosols, and consequentially, not for the anthropogenic total. The spread of aerosol forcing ranges from −0.63 to −1.37 W m−2, exhibiting a less negative mean and narrower range compared to 10 CMIP5 models. The spread in 4×CO2 forcing has also narrowed in CMIP6 compared to 13 CMIP5 models. Aerosol forcing is uncorrelated with climate sensitivity. Therefore, there is no evidence to suggest that the increasing spread in climate sensitivity in CMIP6 models, particularly related to high-sensitivity models, is a consequence of a stronger negative present-day aerosol forcing and little evidence that modelling groups are systematically tuning climate sensitivity or aerosol forcing to recreate observed historical warming.

scholarly journals Anthropogenic aerosol forcing under the Shared Socioeconomic Pathways

2019 ◽  
Author(s):  
Marianne T. Lund ◽  
Gunnar Myhre ◽  
Bjørn H. Samset
Keyword(s):  
Air Pollution ◽  
Radiative Forcing ◽  
Global Climate ◽  
Radiative Transfer Model ◽  
Transfer Model ◽  
Air Pollution Control ◽  
Anthropogenic Aerosols ◽  
Anthropogenic Aerosol ◽  
Aerosol Radiative Forcing ◽  
Aerosol Forcing

Abstract. Emissions of anthropogenic aerosols are expected to change drastically over the coming decades, with potentially significant climate implications. Using the most recent generation of harmonized emission scenarios, the Shared Socioeconomic Pathways (SSPs) as input to a global chemistry transport and radiative transfer model, we provide estimates of the projected future global and regional burdens and radiative forcing of anthropogenic aerosols under three different levels of air pollution control: strong (SSP1), medium (SSP2) and weak (SSP3). We find that the broader range of future air pollution emission trajectories spanned by the SSPs compared to previous scenarios translates into total aerosol forcing estimates in 2100 relative to 1750 ranging from −0.04 W m−2 in SSP1-1.9 to −0.51 W m−2 in SSP3-7.0. Compared to our 1750–2015 estimate of −0.61 W m−2, this shows that depending on the success of air pollution policies over the coming decades, aerosol radiative forcing may weaken by nearly 95 % or remain close to the pre-industrial to present-day level. In all three scenarios there is a positive forcing in 2100 relative to 2015, from 0.51 W m−2 in SSP1-1.9 to 0.04 W m−2 in SSP3-7.0. Results also demonstrate significant differences across regions and scenarios, especially in South Asia and Africa. While rapid weakening of the negative aerosol forcing following effective air quality policies will unmask more of the greenhouse gas-induced global warming, slow progress on mitigating air pollution will significantly enhance the atmospheric aerosol levels and risk to human health. In either case, the resulting impacts on regional and global climate can be significant.

scholarly journals Anthropogenic aerosol forcing – insights from multiple estimates from aerosol-climate models with reduced complexity

2019 ◽  
Vol 19 (10) ◽  
pp. 6821-6841 ◽  
Author(s):  
Stephanie Fiedler ◽  
Stefan Kinne ◽  
Wan Ting Katty Huang ◽  
Petri Räisänen ◽  
Declan O'Donnell ◽  
...  
Keyword(s):  
Radiative Forcing ◽  
Climate Models ◽  
Coupled Model ◽  
Cloud Droplet ◽  
Internal Variability ◽  
Anthropogenic Aerosol ◽  
Aerosol Forcing ◽  
Effective Radiative Forcing ◽  
Absolute Magnitudes ◽  
Natural Aerosols

Abstract. This study assesses the change in anthropogenic aerosol forcing from the mid-1970s to the mid-2000s. Both decades had similar global-mean anthropogenic aerosol optical depths but substantially different global distributions. For both years, we quantify (i) the forcing spread due to model-internal variability and (ii) the forcing spread among models. Our assessment is based on new ensembles of atmosphere-only simulations with five state-of-the-art Earth system models. Four of these models will be used in the sixth Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP6; Eyring et al., 2016). Here, the complexity of the anthropogenic aerosol has been reduced in the participating models. In all our simulations, we prescribe the same patterns of the anthropogenic aerosol optical properties and associated effects on the cloud droplet number concentration. We calculate the instantaneous radiative forcing (RF) and the effective radiative forcing (ERF). Their difference defines the net contribution from rapid adjustments. Our simulations show a model spread in ERF from −0.4 to −0.9 W m−2. The standard deviation in annual ERF is 0.3 W m−2, based on 180 individual estimates from each participating model. This result implies that identifying the model spread in ERF due to systematic differences requires averaging over a sufficiently large number of years. Moreover, we find almost identical ERFs for the mid-1970s and mid-2000s for individual models, although there are major model differences in natural aerosols and clouds. The model-ensemble mean ERF is −0.54 W m−2 for the pre-industrial era to the mid-1970s and −0.59 W m−2 for the pre-industrial era to the mid-2000s. Our result suggests that comparing ERF changes between two observable periods rather than absolute magnitudes relative to a poorly constrained pre-industrial state might provide a better test for a model's ability to represent transient climate changes.

scholarly journals Declining Aerosols in CMIP5 Projections: Effects on Atmospheric Temperature Structure and Midlatitude Jets

2014 ◽  
Vol 27 (18) ◽  
pp. 6960-6977 ◽  
Author(s):  
Leon D. Rotstayn ◽  
Emily L. Plymin ◽  
Mark A. Collier ◽  
Olivier Boucher ◽  
Jean-Louis Dufresne ◽  
...  
Keyword(s):  
Radiative Forcing ◽  
Temperature Response ◽  
Coupled Model ◽  
Atmospheric Temperature ◽  
Temperature Structure ◽  
Tropospheric Temperature ◽  
Anthropogenic Aerosols ◽  
Aerosol Radiative Forcing ◽  
The Tropics ◽  
Aerosol Radiative

Abstract The effects of declining anthropogenic aerosols in representative concentration pathway 4.5 (RCP4.5) are assessed in four models from phase 5 the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP5), with a focus on annual, zonal-mean atmospheric temperature structure and zonal winds. For each model, the effect of declining aerosols is diagnosed from the difference between a projection forced by RCP4.5 for 2006–2100 and another that has identical forcing, except that anthropogenic aerosols are fixed at early twenty-first-century levels. The response to declining aerosols is interpreted in terms of the meridional structure of aerosol radiative forcing, which peaks near 40°N and vanishes at the South Pole. Increasing greenhouse gases cause amplified warming in the tropical upper troposphere and strengthening midlatitude jets in both hemispheres. However, for declining aerosols the vertically averaged tropospheric temperature response peaks near 40°N, rather than in the tropics. This implies that for declining aerosols the tropospheric meridional temperature gradient generally increases in the Southern Hemisphere (SH), but in the Northern Hemisphere (NH) it decreases in the tropics and subtropics. Consistent with thermal wind balance, the NH jet then strengthens on its poleward side and weakens on its equatorward side, whereas the SH jet strengthens more than the NH jet. The asymmetric response of the jets is thus consistent with the meridional structure of aerosol radiative forcing and the associated tropospheric warming: in the NH the latitude of maximum warming is roughly collocated with the jet, whereas in the SH warming is strongest in the tropics and weakest at high latitudes.

scholarly journals Projected changes in persistent extreme summer weather events: The role of quasi-resonant amplification

2018 ◽  
Vol 4 (10) ◽  
pp. eaat3272 ◽  
Author(s):  
Michael E. Mann ◽  
Stefan Rahmstorf ◽  
Kai Kornhuber ◽  
Byron A. Steinman ◽  
Sonya K. Miller ◽  
...  
Keyword(s):  
Radiative Forcing ◽  
Climate Models ◽  
Climate Model ◽  
Coupled Model ◽  
High Amplitude ◽  
Extreme Weather ◽  
Extreme Weather Events ◽  
Anthropogenic Aerosols ◽  
Pronounced Increase ◽  
Weather Events

Persistent episodes of extreme weather in the Northern Hemisphere summer have been associated with high-amplitude quasi-stationary atmospheric Rossby waves, with zonal wave numbers 6 to 8 resulting from the phenomenon of quasi-resonant amplification (QRA). A fingerprint for the occurrence of QRA can be defined in terms of the zonally averaged surface temperature field. Examining state-of-the-art [Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 5 (CMIP5)] climate model projections, we find that QRA events are likely to increase by ~50% this century under business-as-usual carbon emissions, but there is considerable variation among climate models. Some predict a near tripling of QRA events by the end of the century, while others predict a potential decrease. Models with amplified Arctic warming yield the most pronounced increase in QRA events. The projections are strongly dependent on assumptions regarding the nature of changes in radiative forcing associated with anthropogenic aerosols over the next century. One implication of our findings is that a reduction in midlatitude aerosol loading could actually lead to Arctic de-amplification this century, ameliorating potential increases in persistent extreme weather events.

scholarly journals Anthropogenic aerosol forcing – insights from multi-estimates from aerosol-climate models with reduced complexity

2018 ◽  
Author(s):  
Stephanie Fiedler ◽  
Stefan Kinne ◽  
W. T. Katty Huang ◽  
Petri Räisänen ◽  
Declan O'Donnell ◽  
...  
Keyword(s):  
Radiative Forcing ◽  
Climate Models ◽  
Coupled Model ◽  
Internal Variability ◽  
Anthropogenic Aerosol ◽  
Aerosol Forcing ◽  
Aerosol Distribution ◽  
Absolute Magnitudes ◽  
Small Change ◽  
Natural Aerosol

Abstract. The radiative forcing of anthropogenic aerosol remains a key uncertainty in the understanding of climate change. This study quantifies the model spread in aerosol forcing associated with (i) variability internal to the atmosphere and (ii) differences in the model representation of weather. We do so by performing ensembles of atmosphere-only simulations with four state-of-the-art Earth system models, three of which will be used in the sixth coupled model inter-comparison project (CMIP6, Eyring et al., 2016). In those models we reduce the complexity of the anthropogenic aerosol by prescribing the same annually-repeating patterns of the anthropogenic aerosol optical properties and associated effects on the cloud reflectivity. We quantify a comparably small model spread in the long-term averaged ERF compared to the overall possible range in annual ERF estimates associated with model-internal variability. This implies that identifying the true model spread in ERF associated with differences in the representation of meteorological processes and natural aerosol requires averaging over a sufficiently large number of annual estimates. We characterize the model diversity in clouds and use satellite products as benchmarks. Despite major inter-model differences in natural aerosol and clouds, all models show only a small change in the global-mean ERF due to the substantial change in the global anthropogenic aerosol distribution between the mid-1970s and mid-2000s, the ensemble mean ERF being −0.47 Wm−2 for the mid-1970s and −0.51 Wm−2 for the mid-2000s. This result suggests that inter-comparing ERF changes between two periods rather than absolute magnitudes relative to pre-industrial might provide a more stringent test for a model's ability for representing climate evolutions.

scholarly journals Global direct aerosol radiative forcing, as constrained by comprehensive observations

2016 ◽  
Author(s):  
Chul E. Chung ◽  
Jung-Eun Chu ◽  
Yunha Lee ◽  
Twan van Noije ◽  
Hwayoung Jeoung ◽  
...  
Keyword(s):  
Radiative Forcing ◽  
Anthropogenic Aerosols ◽  
Radiative Balance ◽  
Aerosol Radiative Forcing ◽  
Aerosol Forcing ◽  
The Earth ◽  
Fine Mode ◽  
Natural Aerosols ◽  
The Vertical Distribution ◽  
Aerosol Radiative

Abstract. Aerosols directly affect the radiative balance of the Earth through absorption and scattering of solar radiation. Although the contributions of absorption (heating) and scattering (cooling) of sunlight have proved difficult to quantify, the consensus is that anthropogenic aerosols cool the climate, partially offsetting the warming by rising greenhouse gas concentrations. Recent estimates of global direct aerosol radiative forcing are −0.35 ± 0.5 Wm−2, and these estimates depend either entirely or heavily on aerosol simulation. Here, we integrate a comprehensive suite of satellite and ground-based observations to constrain total AOD, its fine-mode fraction, the vertical distribution of aerosols and clouds, and the co-location of clouds and overlying aerosols. We find that fine-mode forcing is −0.46 Wm−2 (−0.54 ~ −0.39 Wm−2). Fine-mode aerosols include sea salt and dust aerosols, and we find that these natural aerosols pose a very large cooling (−0.44 ~ −0.26 Wm−2) when constrained by observations. When the contribution of these natural aerosols is subtracted from the fine-mode forcing, the net becomes −0.10 (−0.28 ~ +0.05) Wm−2. The net forcing arises from carbonaceous, sulfate and nitrate aerosols. Despite uncertainties in the anthropogenic fraction of these aerosols, this −0.28 ~ +0.05 Wm−2 range compels the direct aerosol forcing to be near zero.

scholarly journals The Large-Scale Dynamical Response of Clouds to Aerosol Forcing

2017 ◽  
Vol 30 (21) ◽  
pp. 8783-8794 ◽  
Author(s):  
Brian Soden ◽  
Eui-Seok Chung
Keyword(s):  
Atmospheric Circulation ◽  
Radiative Forcing ◽  
Large Scale ◽  
Energy Transport ◽  
Hadley Cell ◽  
Dynamical Response ◽  
Aerosol Radiative Forcing ◽  
Aerosol Forcing ◽  
Meridional Displacement ◽  
Cloud Response

Radiative kernels are used to quantify the instantaneous radiative forcing of aerosols and the aerosol-mediated cloud response in coupled ocean–atmosphere model simulations under both historical and future emission scenarios. The method is evaluated using matching pairs of historical climate change experiments with and without aerosol forcing and accurately captures the spatial pattern and global-mean effects of aerosol forcing. It is shown that aerosol-driven changes in the atmospheric circulation induce additional cloud changes. Thus, the total aerosol-mediated cloud response consists of both local microphysical changes and nonlocal dynamical changes that are driven by hemispheric asymmetries in aerosol forcing. By comparing coupled and fixed sea surface temperature (SST) simulations with identical aerosol forcing, the relative contributions of these two components are isolated, exploiting the ability of prescribed SSTs to also suppress changes in the atmospheric circulation. The radiative impact of the dynamical cloud changes is found to be comparable in magnitude to that of the microphysical cloud changes and acts to further amplify the interhemispheric asymmetry of the aerosol radiative forcing. The dynamical cloud response is closely linked to the meridional displacement of the Hadley cell, which, in turn, is driven by changes in the cross-equatorial energy transport. In this way, the dynamical cloud changes act as a positive feedback on the meridional displacement of the Hadley cell, roughly doubling the projected changes in cross-equatorial energy transport compared to that from the microphysical changes alone.

scholarly journals Observational Constraint on Greenhouse Gas and Aerosol Contributions to Global Ocean Heat Content Changes

2020 ◽  
Vol 33 (24) ◽  
pp. 10579-10591
Author(s):  
Elodie Charles ◽  
Benoit Meyssignac ◽  
Aurélien Ribes
Keyword(s):  
Greenhouse Gas ◽  
Radiative Forcing ◽  
Climate Models ◽  
Ghg Emissions ◽  
Heat Content ◽  
Ocean Heat Content ◽  
Global Ocean ◽  
Detection And Attribution ◽  
Aerosol Forcing ◽  
Bivariate Method

AbstractObservations and climate models are combined to identify an anthropogenic warming signature in the upper ocean heat content (OHC) changes since 1971. We apply a new detection and attribution analysis developed by Ribes et al. that uses a symmetric treatment of the magnitude and the pattern of the climate response to each radiative forcing. A first estimate of the OHC response to natural, anthropogenic, greenhouse gas, and other forcings is derived from a large ensemble of CMIP5 simulations. Observational datasets from historical reconstructions are then used to constrain this estimate. A spatiotemporal observational mask is applied to compare simulations with actual observations and to overcome reconstruction biases. Results on the 0–700-m layer from 1971 to 2005 show that the global OHC would have increased since 1971 by 2.12 ± 0.21 × 107 J m−2 yr−1 in response to GHG emissions alone. But this has been compensated for by other anthropogenic influences (mainly aerosol), which induced an OHC decrease of 0.84 ± 0.18 × 107 J m−2 yr−1. The natural forcing has induced a slight global OHC decrease since 1971 of 0.13 ± 0.09 × 107 J m−2 yr−1. Compared to previous studies we have separated the effect of the GHG forcing from the effect of the other anthropogenic forcing on OHC changes. This has been possible by using a new detection and attribution (D&A) method and by analyzing simultaneously the global OHC trends over 1957–80 and over 1971–2005. This bivariate method takes advantage of the different time variation of the GHG forcing and the aerosol forcing since 1957 to separate both effects and reduce the uncertainty in their estimates.

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document