On: “Effects of porosity and clay content on wave velocities in sandstones” by D. Han, A. Nur, and D. Morgan (GEOPHYSICS, 51, 2093–2107, November 1986”.
Keyword(s):
At the outset, we must declare our philosophical bias: we believe that, if at all possible, equations relating one physical property to another should be based on some physical model. If there are two equations that can be said to relate one property to another equally well, within statistical bounds, then the equation that is based on physical principles is preferable. We acknowledge that the relationships among in this case, porosity, clay content, and seismic velocity are not always clear or easily tested, and we appreciate the efforts of Han et al. However, we have a comment and a related question regarding the statistical significance of their results.