A Novel Approach to Drill Stem Selection for Drilling in Sour Fields
Abstract For years the drilling industry has used sour service drill pipe within a narrow set of specifications and industry guidelines. That left room for original equipment manufacturers (OEM) to have customization on an iterative basis, which resulted in a wide product offering to fulfill operator needs. While this method worked, it did not lead to building the product in the most efficient and economical manner. As a result of this product diversity, drilling engineers could specify the best product to deliver their projects when running drilling models, only to have to redesign it around what is effectively available on rigs or for rental. This disconnect puts pressure on the industry players and is the result of a lack of standardization. We wiped the board to provide a simple solution that is more suited to allow alignment between operators, contractors, and rental companies. The new philosophy is based on the National Association of Corrosion Engineers (NACE) MR0175-2015 severity diagram, where environmental severity is defined in regions (1, 2, and 3), which have been used by oil companies’ engineers for their oil country tubular goods (OCTG) product selection. Even though the drill string will not be exposed to the well fluid for the same extended time and is surrounded by a more forgiving medium, the drilling fluid, the diagram allows a segmentation of customer's needs. This framework helped define targeted product properties. A research and development (R&D) and industrialization test campaign could then be started to confirm that sound product configurations could be offered with targeted properties. The study also explored the limitations imposed on connection make-up torque in a sour gas environment relative to the NACE severity diagram. Emphasis was given on methods to increase the make-up torque, which is needed to deliver the most extended reach wells that are now commonplace. The result of this two-year development campaign is a short list of grades with an optimized balance between pipe subcomponents strength and sulfide stress cracking (SSC) resistance. Region 1 (mild severity) products will offer as much tension and torque as possible, matching or exceeding these of API products, including excellent resistance to SSC, thus making drilling operation safer. Region 2 (medium severity) will offer products with medium to high strength and enhanced SSC resistance. Finally, region 3 (high severity) products will be aligned with the industry specifications for maximized SSC resistance and lower strength. This paper discusses a proactive approach that contrasts with a historical, more reactive one. As the drill stem technology leader, we saw an opportunity to drive this initiative that will benefit the drilling industry by offering a more natural way to select drill stem products. For the first time a sour service product range aligns with the needs of drilling engineers and the inventory of their selected service companies.