Debris cover and the thinning of Kennicott Glacier, Alaska, Part C: feedbacks between melt, ice dynamics, and surface processes

Abstract. The mass balance of many valley glaciers is enhanced by the presence of melt hotspots within otherwise continuous debris cover. We assess the effect of debris, melt hotspots, and ice dynamics on the thinning of Kennicott Glacier in three companion papers. In Part A we report in situ measurements from the debris-covered tongue. In Part B, we develop a method to delineate ice cliffs using high-resolution imagery and produce distributed mass balance estimates. Here in Part C we describe feedbacks controlling rapid thinning under thick debris. Despite the extreme abundance of ice cliffs on Kennicott Glacier, average melt rates are strongly suppressed downglacier due to thick debris. The estimated melt pattern therefore appears to reflect Østrem’s curve (the debris thickness-melt relationship). As Kennicott Glacier has thinned over the last century Østrem’s curve has manifested itself in two process domains on the glacier surface. The portion of the glacier affected by the upper-limb of Østrem’s curve corresponds to high melt, melt gradients, and ice dynamics, as well as high ice cliff and stream occurrence. The portion of the glacier affected by the lower-limb of Østrem’s curve corresponds to low melt, melt gradients, and ice dynamics, as well as high ice cliff and stream occurrence. The upglacier end of the zone of maximum thinning on Kennicott Glacier occurs at the boundary between these process domains and the bend in Østrem’s curve. The expansion of debris upglacier appears to be linked to changes in the surface velocity pattern through time. In response to climate warming, debris itself may therefore control where rapid thinning occurs on debris-covered glaciers. Ice cliffs are most abundant at the upglacier end of the zone of maximum thinning.

Download Full-text

Debris cover and the thinning of Kennicott Glacier, Alaska, Part A:in situ mass balance measurements

10.5194/tc-2019-174 ◽

2019 ◽

Author(s):

Leif S. Anderson ◽

Robert S. Anderson ◽

Pascal Buri ◽

William H. Armstrong

Keyword(s):

Mass Balance ◽

High Mountain ◽

Glacier Surface ◽

Ice Dynamics ◽

Air Temperatures ◽

High Resolution Imagery ◽

Debris Cover ◽

The Alps

Abstract. The mass balance of many Alaskan glaciers is perturbed by debris cover. Yet the effect of debris on glacier response to climate change in Alaska has largely been overlooked. In three companion papers we assess the role of debris, ice dynamics, and surface processes in thinning Kennicott Glacier. In Part A, we report in situ measurements from the glacier surface. In Part B, we develop a method to delineate ice cliffs using high-resolution imagery and produce distributed mass balance estimates. In Part C we explore feedbacks that contribute to glacier thinning. Here in Part A, we describe data collected in the summer of 2011. We measured debris thickness (109 locations), sub-debris melt (74), and ice cliff backwasting (60) data from the debris-covered tongue. We also measured air-temperature (3 locations) and internal-debris temperature (10). The mean debris thermal conductivity was 1.06 W (m C)−1, increasing non-linearly with debris thickness. Mean debris thicknesses increase toward the terminus and margin where surface velocities are low. Despite the relatively high air temperatures above thick debris, the melt-insulating effect of debris dominates. Sub-debris melt rates ranged from 6.5 cm d−1 where debris is thin to 1.25 cm d−1 where debris is thick near the terminus. Ice cliff backwasting rates varied from 3 to 14 cm d−1 with a mean of 7.1 cm d−1 and tended to increase as elevation declined and debris thickness increased. Ice cliff backwasting rates are similar to those measured on debris-covered glaciers in High Mountain Asia and the Alps.

Download Full-text

Debris cover and the thinning of Kennicott Glacier, Alaska, Part B: ice cliff delineation and distributed melt estimates

10.5194/tc-2019-177 ◽

2019 ◽

Author(s):

Leif S. Anderson ◽

William H. Armstrong ◽

Robert S. Anderson ◽

Pascal Buri

Keyword(s):

High Resolution ◽

Mass Balance ◽

In Situ Measurements ◽

Empirical Relationships ◽

Full Extent ◽

Part C ◽

Important Contributor ◽

High Resolution Imagery ◽

Debris Cover

Abstract. The mass balance of many valley glaciers is enhanced by the presence of ice cliffs within otherwise continuous debris cover. We assess the effect of debris and ice cliffs on the thinning of Kennicott Glacier in three companion papers. In Part A we report in situ measurements from the debris-covered tongue. Here, in Part B, we develop a method to delineate ice cliffs using high-resolution imagery and use empirical relationships from Part A to produce distributed mass balance estimates. In Part C we describe feedbacks that contribute to rapid thinning under thick debris. Ice cliffs cover 11.7 % of the debris-covered tongue, the most of any glacier studied to date, and they contribute 19 % of total melt. Ice cliffs contribute an increasing percentage of melt the thicker the debris cover. In the lowest 4 km of the glacier, where debris thicknesses are greater than 20 cm, ice cliffs contribute 40 % of total melt. Surface lake coverage doubled between 1957 and 2009, but lakes do not occur across the full extent of the zone of maximum glacier thinning. Despite abundant ice cliffs and expanding surface lakes, average melt rates are suppressed by debris, the pattern of which appears to reflect the debris thickness-melt relationship (or Østrem’s curve). This suggests that, in addition to melt hotspots, the decline in ice discharge from upglacier is an important contributor to the thinning of Kennicott glacier under thick debris.

Download Full-text

Early 21st-century glacier surface mass balance across High Mountain Asia derived from remote sensing

10.5194/egusphere-egu2020-9330 ◽

2020 ◽

Author(s):

Evan Miles ◽

Michael McCarthy ◽

Amaury Dehecq ◽

Marin Kneib ◽

Stefan Fugger ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Remote Sensing ◽

Mass Balance ◽

Surface Velocity ◽

High Mountain ◽

Surface Mass Balance ◽

Equilibrium Line Altitude ◽

Glacier Surface ◽

Surface Mass ◽

Early 21St Century ◽

Debris Cover

Glaciers in High Mountain Asia have experienced intense scientific scrutiny in the past decade due to their hydrological and societal importance. The explosion of freely-available satellite observations has greatly advanced our understanding of their thinning, motion, and overall mass losses, and it has become clear that they exhibit both local and regional variations due to debris cover, surging and climatic regime. However, our understanding of glacier accumulation and ablation rates is limited to a few individual sites, and altitudinal surface mass balance is essentially unknown across the vast region.Here we combine recent assessments of ice thickness and surface velocity to correct observed glacier thinning rates for mass redistribution in a flowband framework to derive the first estimates of altitudinal glacier surface mass balance across the region. We first evaluate our results at the glacier scale with all available glaciological field measurements (27 glaciers), then analyze 4665 glaciers (we exclude surging and other anomalous glaciers) comprising 43% of area and 36% of mass for glaciers larger than 2 km2 in the region. The surface mass balance results allow us to determine the equilibrium line altitude for each glacier for the period 2000-2016.&#160; We then aggregate our altitudinal and hypsometric surface mass balance results to produce idealised profiles for distinct subregions, enabling us to consider the subregional heterogeneity of mass balance and the importance of debris-covered ice for the region&#8217;s overall ablation.We find clear patterns of ELA variability across the region. &#160;9% of glaciers accumulate mass over less than 10% of their area on average for the study period. These doomed&#160; glaciers are concentrated in Nyainqentanglha, which also has the most negative mass balance of the subregions, whereas accumulation area ratios of 0.7-0.9 are common for glaciers in the neutral-balance Karakoram and Kunlun Shan. We find that surface debris extent is negatively correlated with ELA, explaining up to 1000 m of variability across the region and reflecting the importance of avalanching as a mass input for debris-covered glaciers at lower elevations. However, in contrast with studies of thinning rates alone, we find a clear melt reduction for low-elevation debris-covered glacier areas, consistent across regions, largely resolving the &#8216;debris cover anomaly&#8217;.&#160;&#160;Our results provide a comprehensive baseline for the health of the High Asian ice reservoirs in the early 21st Century. The estimates of altitudinal surface mass balance and ELAs will additionally enable novel strategies for the calibration of glacier and hydrological models. Finally, our results emphasize the potential of combined remote-sensing observations to understand the environmental factors and physical processes responsible for High Asia&#8217;s heterogeneous patterns of recent glacier evolution.

Download Full-text

Evolution of the debris-covered Miage Glacier

10.5194/egusphere-egu21-14842 ◽

2021 ◽

Author(s):

Anne Stefaniak ◽

Ben Robson ◽

Simon Cook ◽

Ben Clutterbuck ◽

Nicholas Midgley ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Mass Balance ◽

Substantial Reduction ◽

Temporal Analysis ◽

Surface Velocity ◽

High Mountain ◽

Glacier Mass Balance ◽

Glacier Surface ◽

Debris Cover ◽

Geomorphological Changes ◽

Miage Glacier

Glaciers in high-mountain regions typically exhibit a debris cover that moderates their response to climatic change. Here we present an integrated study that integrates long-term observations of debris-covered glacier mass balance, velocity, surface debris evolution and geomorphological changes (such as ponds and ice cliffs) of Miage Glacier, Italian Alps over the period 1952 &#8211; 2018. Analysis of the evolution of Miage Glacier highlighted a reduction in glacier activity associated with a period of sustained negative mass balance (-0.86 &#177; 0.27 metres&#160;per year water equivalent [m&#160;w.e.&#160;a-1]) and a substantial reduction in surface velocity (-46%). Ice mass loss of Miage Glacier was quantified using satellite imagery and derived digital elevation models (DEMs) applying the geodetic approach over a 28-year time period, 1990 &#8211; 2018. Temporal analysis highlighted an increase in surface lowering rates from 2012 &#8211; 2018. Further, the increase in debris-cover extent, supraglacial ponds and ice cliffs was evident since the 1990s. Supraglacial ponds and ice cliffs accounted for up to 8 times the magnitude of the average glacier surface lowering, whilst only covering 1.2 &#8211; 1.5% of the glacier area.Ground-based photogrammetry and bathymetry surveys undertaken in 2017 and 2018 indicated the total volume of water storage at Miage Glacier increased by 46%, however, intermittent drainage events suggest this is highly variable over both seasonal and annual timescales. All ice cliffs underwent substantial vertical retreat upto a maximum rate of -8.15&#160;ma-1 resulting in ice loss of 39,569&#160;m3. Thus, ice loss from supraglacial ponds and ice cliffs are important to account for and have the potential to substantially impact future glacier evolution.

Download Full-text

The Causes of Debris-Covered Glacier Thinning: Evidence for the Importance of Ice Dynamics From Kennicott Glacier, Alaska

Frontiers in Earth Science ◽

10.3389/feart.2021.680995 ◽

2021 ◽

Vol 9 ◽

Author(s):

Leif S. Anderson ◽

William H. Armstrong ◽

Robert S. Anderson ◽

Dirk Scherler ◽

Eric Petersen

Keyword(s):

Mass Balance ◽

Flow Direction ◽

Surface Velocity ◽

Glacier Surface ◽

Ice Dynamics ◽

Ice Flow ◽

Thickness Change ◽

Air Temperatures ◽

Compressive Flow ◽

Wide Range

The cause of debris-covered glacier thinning remains controversial. One hypothesis asserts that melt hotspots (ice cliffs, ponds, or thin debris) increase thinning, while the other posits that declining ice flow leads to dynamic thinning under thick debris. Alaska’s Kennicott Glacier is ideal for testing these hypotheses, as ice cliffs within the debris-covered tongue are abundant and surface velocities decline rapidly downglacier. To explore the cause of patterns in melt hotspots, ice flow, and thinning, we consider their evolution over several decades. We compile a wide range of ice dynamical and mass balance datasets which we cross-correlate and analyze in a step-by-step fashion. We show that an undulating bed that deepens upglacier controls ice flow in the lower 8.5 km of Kennicott Glacier. The imposed velocity pattern strongly affects debris thickness, which in turn leads to annual melt rates that decline towards the terminus. Ice cliff abundance correlates highly with the rate of surface compression, while pond occurrence is strongly negatively correlated with driving stress. A new positive feedback is identified between ice cliffs, streams and surface topography that leads to chaotic topography. As the glacier thinned between 1991 and 2015, surface melt in the study area decreased, despite generally rising air temperatures. Four additional feedbacks relating glacier thinning to melt changes are evident: the debris feedback (negative), the ice cliff feedback (negative), the pond feedback (positive), and the relief feedback (positive). The debris and ice cliff feedbacks, which are tied to the change in surface velocity in time, likely reduced melt rates in time. We show this using a new method to invert for debris thickness change and englacial debris content (∼0.017% by volume) while also revealing that declining speeds and compressive flow led to debris thickening. The expansion of debris on the glacier surface follows changes in flow direction. Ultimately, glacier thinning upvalley from the continuously debris-covered portion of Kennicott Glacier, caused by mass balance changes, led to the reduction of flow into the study area. This caused ice emergence rates to decline rapidly leading to the occurrence of maximum, glacier-wide thinning under thick, insulating debris.

Download Full-text

Application of an improved surface energy balance model to two large valley glaciers in the St. Elias Mountains, Yukon

Journal of Glaciology ◽

10.1017/jog.2020.106 ◽

2020 ◽

pp. 1-16

Author(s):

Tim Hill ◽

Christine F. Dow ◽

Eleanor A. Bash ◽

Luke Copland

Keyword(s):

Energy Balance ◽

Surface Energy ◽

Surface Energy Balance ◽

Shortwave Radiation ◽

Balance Model ◽

Landsat 8 ◽

Glacier Surface ◽

Ice Dynamics ◽

Surface Melt

Abstract Glacier surficial melt rates are commonly modelled using surface energy balance (SEB) models, with outputs applied to extend point-based mass-balance measurements to regional scales, assess water resource availability, examine supraglacial hydrology and to investigate the relationship between surface melt and ice dynamics. We present an improved SEB model that addresses the primary limitations of existing models by: (1) deriving high-resolution (30 m) surface albedo from Landsat 8 imagery, (2) calculating shadows cast onto the glacier surface by high-relief topography to model incident shortwave radiation, (3) developing an algorithm to map debris sufficiently thick to insulate the glacier surface and (4) presenting a formulation of the SEB model coupled to a subsurface heat conduction model. We drive the model with 6 years of in situ meteorological data from Kaskawulsh Glacier and Nàłùdäy (Lowell) Glacier in the St. Elias Mountains, Yukon, Canada, and validate outputs against in situ measurements. Modelled seasonal melt agrees with observations within 9% across a range of elevations on both glaciers in years with high-quality in situ observations. We recommend applying the model to investigate the impacts of surface melt for individual glaciers when sufficient input data are available.

Download Full-text

Glacier Surface Mass Balance in the Suntar-Khayata Mountains, Northeastern Siberia

Water ◽

10.3390/w11091949 ◽

2019 ◽

Vol 11 (9) ◽

pp. 1949 ◽

Cited By ~ 1

Author(s):

Yong Zhang ◽

Xin Wang ◽

Zongli Jiang ◽

Junfeng Wei ◽

Hiroyuki Enomoto ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Mass Loss ◽

Mass Balance ◽

Surface Mass Balance ◽

Negative Mass ◽

Glacier Surface ◽

Surface Mass ◽

Northeastern Siberia ◽

Response To Temperature ◽

Rapid Mass

Arctic glaciers comprise a small fraction of the world’s land ice area, but their ongoing mass loss currently represents a large cryospheric contribution to the sea level rise. In the Suntar-Khayata Mountains (SKMs) of northeastern Siberia, in situ measurements of glacier surface mass balance (SMB) are relatively sparse, limiting our understanding of the spatiotemporal patterns of regional mass loss. Here, we present SMB time series for all glaciers in the SKMs, estimated through a glacier SMB model. Our results yielded an average SMB of −0.22 m water equivalents (w.e.) year−1 for the whole region during 1951–2011. We found that 77.4% of these glaciers had a negative mass balance and detected slightly negative mass balance prior to 1991 and significantly rapid mass loss since 1991. The analysis suggests that the rapidly accelerating mass loss was dominated by increased surface melting, while the importance of refreezing in the SMB progressively decreased over time. Projections under two future climate scenarios confirmed the sustained rapid shrinkage of these glaciers. In response to temperature rise, the total present glacier area is likely to decrease by around 50% during the period 2071–2100 under representative concentration pathway 8.5 (RCP8.5).

Download Full-text

Variations in the surface velocity of an alpine cirque glacier

Journal of Glaciology ◽

10.1017/jog.2018.85 ◽

2018 ◽

Vol 64 (248) ◽

pp. 969-976 ◽

Cited By ~ 1

Author(s):

J. W. SANDERS ◽

K. M. CUFFEY ◽

K. R. MACGREGOR ◽

J. L. KAVANAUGH ◽

C. F. DOW

Keyword(s):

Water System ◽

Heavy Rain ◽

Temporal Variations ◽

Surface Velocity ◽

Channel Network ◽

Glacier Surface ◽

Ice Dynamics ◽

Speed Up ◽

Water Volumes ◽

One Year

ABSTRACTFollowing pioneering work in Norway, cirque glaciers have widely been viewed as rigidly rotating bodies. This model is incorrect for basin-filling cirque glaciers, as we have demonstrated at West Washmawapta Glacier, a small glacier in the Canadian Rocky Mountains. Here we report observations at the same glacier that assess whether complex temporal variations of flow also occur. For parts of three summers, we measured daily displacements of the glacier surface. In one year, four short-duration speed-up events were recorded. Three of the events occurred during the intervals of warmest weather, when melt was most rapid; the fourth event occurred immediately following heavy rain. We interpret the speed-up events as manifestations of enhanced water inputs to the glacier bed and associated slip lubrication by increased water volumes and pressures. No further speed-ups occurred in the final month of the melt season, despite warm temperatures and several rainstorms; the dominant subglacial water system likely transformed from one of poorly connected cavities to one with an efficient channel network. The seasonal evolution of hydrology and flow resembles behaviors documented at other, larger temperate glaciers and indicates that analyses of cirque erosion cannot rely on simple assumptions about ice dynamics.

Download Full-text

Present dynamics and future prognosis of a slowly surging glacier

The Cryosphere ◽

10.5194/tc-5-299-2011 ◽

2011 ◽

Vol 5 (1) ◽

pp. 299-313 ◽

Cited By ~ 49

Author(s):

G. E. Flowers ◽

N. Roux ◽

S. Pimentel ◽

C. G. Schoof

Keyword(s):

Mass Balance ◽

Force Balance ◽

Surface Velocity ◽

Internal Dynamic ◽

Ice Dynamics ◽

Surface Mass ◽

Ice Surface ◽

Glacier Ice ◽

Glacier Flow ◽

Negative Balance

Abstract. Glacier surges are a well-known example of an internal dynamic oscillation whose occurrence is not a direct response to the external climate forcing, but whose character (i.e. period, amplitude, mechanism) may depend on the glacier's environmental or climate setting. We examine the dynamics of a small (∼5 km2) valley glacier in Yukon, Canada, where two previous surges have been photographically documented and an unusually slow surge is currently underway. To characterize the dynamics of the present surge, and to speculate on the future of this glacier, we employ a higher-order flowband model of ice dynamics with a regularized Coulomb-friction sliding law in both diagnostic and prognostic simulations. Diagnostic (force balance) calculations capture the measured ice-surface velocity profile only when non-zero basal water pressures are prescribed over the central region of the glacier, coincident with where evidence of the surge has been identified. This leads to sliding accounting for 50–100% of the total surface motion in this region. Prognostic simulations, where the glacier geometry evolves in response to a prescribed surface mass balance, reveal a significant role played by a bedrock ridge beneath the current equilibrium line of the glacier. Ice thickening occurs above the ridge in our simulations, until the net mass balance reaches sufficiently negative values. We suggest that the bedrock ridge may contribute to the propensity for surges in this glacier by promoting the development of the reservoir area during quiescence, and may permit surges to occur under more negative balance conditions than would otherwise be possible. Collectively, these results corroborate our interpretation of the current glacier flow regime as indicative of a slow surge that has been ongoing for some time, and support a relationship between surge incidence or character and the net mass balance. Our results also highlight the importance of glacier bed topography in controlling ice dynamics, as observed in many other glacier systems.

Download Full-text

Debris cover and the thinning of Kennicott Glacier, Alaska

10.5194/egusphere-egu21-15674 ◽

2021 ◽

Author(s):

Leif S. Anderson ◽

William H. Armstrong ◽

Robert S. Anderson ◽

Dirk Scherler

Keyword(s):

Satellite Imagery ◽

Hot Spots ◽

High Mountain ◽

Threshold Method ◽

Ice Dynamics ◽

Ice Flow ◽

Debris Cover ◽

A Chain ◽

The Relationship

Many glaciers in High Mountain Asia are experiencing the debris-cover anomaly. The Kennicott Glacier, a large Alaskan Glacier, is also thinning most rapidly under debris cover. This contradiction has been explained by melt hotspots, such as ice cliffs, streams, or ponds scattered within the debris cover or by declining ice flow in time. We collected abundant in situ measurements of debris thickness, sub-debris melt, and ice cliff backwasting, allowing for extrapolation across the debris-covered tongue. A newly developed automatic ice cliff delineation method is the first to use only optical satellite imagery. The adaptive binary threshold method accurately estimates ice cliff coverage even where ice cliffs are small and debris color varies. We also develop additional remotely-sensed datasets of ice dynamical variables, other melt hot spots, and glacier thinning.Kennicott Glacier exhibits the highest fractional area of ice cliffs (11.7 %) documented to date. Ice cliffs contribute 26 % of total melt across the glacier tongue. Although the relative importance of ice cliffs to area-average melt is significant, the absolute area-averaged melt is dominated by debris. At Kennicott Glacier, glacier-wide melt rates are not maximized in the zone of maximum thinning. Declining ice discharge through time therefore explains the rapid thinning. Through this study, Kennicott Glacier is the first glacier in Alaska, and the largest glacier globally, where melt across its debris-covered tongue has been rigorously quantified.We also carefully explore the relationship between debris, melt hotspots, ice dynamics, and thinning across the debris-covered tongue. In doing so we reveal a chain of linked processes that can explain the striking patterns expressed on the debris-covered tongue of Kennicott Glacier.

Download Full-text