Estimation of Extreme Ship Response

2012 ◽  
Vol 56 (01) ◽  
pp. 23-34
Author(s):  
Wengang Mao ◽  
Igor Rychlik

In practice the severity of ship response is measured by high quantiles of long-term distribution of the response. The distribution is estimated by combining the short-term distribution of the response with a long-term probability distribution of encountered sea states. The paper describes an alternative approach, the so-called Rice's method, based on estimation of expected number of upcrossings of high levels by stress during 1 year. The method requires description of long-term variability of the standard deviation, skewness, kurtosis, and zero upcrossing frequency of ship response. It is assumed that the parameters are functions of encountered significant wave height, heading angle, and ship speed. The relation can be estimated from the measured stresses or computed by dedicated software assuming rigid ship hull model. Then Winterstein's transformed Gaussian model is used to estimate the upcrossing rates of response during a sea state. The proposed method is validated using the full-scale measurements of a 2,800 TEU container ship during the first 6 months of 2008. Numerical estimation of 4,400 TEU container ship extreme of the extreme response for a 4400 TEU container ship illustrates the approach when no measurements are available.

Author(s):  
Feng Wang ◽  
Roger Burke ◽  
Anil Sablok ◽  
Kristoffer H. Aronsen ◽  
Oddgeir Dalane

Strength performance of a steel catenary riser tied back to a Spar is presented based on long term and short term analysis methodologies. The focus of the study is on response in the riser touch down zone, which is found to be the critical region based on short term analysis results. Short term riser response in design storms is computed based on multiple realizations of computed vessel motions with various return periods. Long term riser response is based on vessel motions for a set of 45,000 sea states, each lasting three hours. The metocean criteria for each sea state is computed based on fifty six years of hindcast wind and wave data. A randomly selected current profile is used in the long term riser analysis for each sea state. Weibull fitting is used to compute the extreme riser response from the response of the 45,000 sea states. Long term analysis results in the touch down zone, including maximum bending moment, minimum effective tension, and maximum utilization using DNV-OS-F201, are compared against those from the short term analysis. The comparison indicates that the short term analysis methodology normally followed in riser design is conservative compared to the more accurate, but computationally more expensive, long term analysis methods. The study also investigates the important role that current plays in the strength performance of the riser in the touch down zone.


Author(s):  
Federico Barranco Cicilia ◽  
Edison Castro Prates de Lima ◽  
Lui´s Volnei Sudati Sagrilo

This paper presents a methodology for reliability analysis of Tension Leg Platform (TLP) tendons subjected to extraordinary sea state conditions like hurricanes or winter storms. A coupled approach in time domain is used to carry out TLP random nonlinear dynamic analysis including wind, current and first and second order wave forces. The tendons Ultimate Limit State (ULS) condition is evaluated by an Interaction Ratio (IR) taking into account dynamic combination among tension, bending and hydrostatic pressure. Expected long-term extreme IR is obtained through the integration of cumulative probability functions (CPFs) fitted to response maxima associated to individual short term sea states. The reliability analysis is performed using a time-integrated scheme including uncertainties in loads, tendon strength, and analytical models. Failure probabilities for the most loaded tendon of a TLP in Campeche Bay, Mexico, considering a 100-yr design sea state and the 100-yr extreme response generated by long-term observed storms are compared.


Author(s):  
Wengang Mao ◽  
Jonas W. Ringsberg ◽  
Igor Rychlik

Wave-induced vibrations, also known as whipping and springing, are defined as the high frequency response of ship structures. In this paper, the fatigue damage caused by whipping and springing is presented by investigating the amidships section of a 2800 TEU container ship that operates in the North Atlantic Ocean. A simplified fatigue model, originally from the generalized narrow-band approximation for Gaussian load, is employed to include the damage contribution from wave-induced vibrations. In this model, the significant response range hs and the mean stress up-crossing frequency fz are simplified using only the wave-induced loading and encountered wave frequency, respectively. The capacity and accuracy of the model is illustrated by application on the measurements of the 2800 TEU container ship for different voyages during 2008. The whipping-induced contribution to the extreme response is investigated by means of the level crossing approach. It shows that the level crossing model for Gaussian load cannot be used for the prediction of extreme responses, such as the 100-year stress, based on a half-year full-scale measurement. It is found that a more complicated non-Gaussian model is required to consider the contribution from whipping.


Author(s):  
HyeongUk Lim ◽  
Lance Manuel ◽  
Ying Min Low

This study investigates the use of efficient surrogate model development with the help of polynomial chaos expansion (PCE) for the prediction of the long-term extreme surge motion of a simple moored offshore structure. The structure is subjected to first-order and second-order (difference-frequency) wave loading. Uncertainty in the long-term response results from the contrasting sea state conditions, characterized by significant wave height, Hs, and spectral peak period, Tp, and their relative likelihood of occurrence; these two variables are explicitly included in the PCE-based uncertainty quantification (UQ). In a given sea state, however, response simulations must be run for any sampled Hs and Tp; in such simulations, typically, a set of random phases (and deterministic amplitudes) define a wave train consistent with the defined sea state. These random phases for all the frequency components in the wave train introduce additional uncertainty in the simulated waves and in the response. The UQ framework treats these two sources of uncertainty — from Hs and Tp on the one hand, and the phase vector on the other — in a nested manner that is shown to efficiently yield long-term surge motion extreme predictions consistent with more expensive Monte Carlo simulations, which serve as the truth system. Success with the method suggests that similar inexpensive surrogate models may be developed for assessing the long-term response of various offshore structures.


Author(s):  
Tone M. Vestbo̸stad ◽  
Sverre Haver ◽  
Odd Jan Andersen ◽  
Arne Albert

This paper presents a method for predicting extreme roll motion on an FPSO using long-term statistics. The method consists of a long-term simulation where a database of consecutive short-term sea states with combined weather conditions, including direction and magnitude of wind, wind waves and swell waves, is used. The vessel heading in given weather conditions is simulated. For each combined sea state, the short-term roll motion maxima are calculated to form a long-term probability distribution, and the extreme roll motion, e.g. the 100-year value, can be estimated from the distribution. For an example FPSO, the results from the long-term analysis have been compared with full-scale measurements, giving a validation of the method. This paper is a shortened version of [1].


Author(s):  
Gro Sagli Baarholm ◽  
Sverre Haver ◽  
Carl M. Larsen

This paper is concerned with estimating the response value corresponding to given annual exceedance probability. In principle, this requires that a full long term analysis is executed. For a linear response this can easily be done. For a non-linear response quantity however, where time domain simulations are required in order to obtain the short term stochastic structure a full long term analysis will be time consuming. An approximate method to determine the long-term extremes by considering only a few short term sea states is outlined. All sea states corresponding to a certain probability of occurrence and are given by a contour line of Hs, Tp for each wave direction. The advantage of the method is that a proper estimate of the long term extreme can be obtained by considering the most unfavourable sea state along the contour line. This will make possible practical estimation of the extreme loads the structure is exposed to. The purpose of the present paper is to illustrate how to apply directional contour lines in order to obtain a characteristic design value according to requirements regarding the marginal exceedance probability.


Author(s):  
Wengang Mao ◽  
Zhiyuan Li ◽  
Thomas Galtier ◽  
Jonas W. Ringsberg ◽  
Igor Rychlik

The hydrodynamic analysis of a 4400 TEU container ship with constant forward speed is carried out by the nonlinear numerical code WASIM in the time domain under severe sea states. Straightforward fatigue estimation is performed using the rainflow counting approach based on simulated time series of stresses. The narrow-band approximation, which has been validated in previous work with good accuracy by full-scale measurement of a 2800 TEU container ship, is implemented to estimate the fatigue damage based on the same responses. It is concluded that a slight deviation from the Gaussian process does not influence the fatigue estimation by narrow-band approximation. In addition, extreme response is defined by the level up-crossing approach. The Gaussian crossing model using Rice’s formula is employed to predict the extreme response based on the responses from above numerical analysis. It shows that the Gaussian model is not suitable for this prediction. A more complicated level crossing model is proposed which is based on the Laplace Moving Average method. Its accuracy in prediction of extreme responses is analyzed and presented with good agreement by means of numerical simulations.


Author(s):  
Gunnar Lian ◽  
Sverre K. Haver

Characteristic loads for design are defined in terms of their annual exceedance probability, q. For ultimate limit state (ULS) q = 10−2, while q = 10−4 for accidental limit state (ALS). In principle a full long term analysis is required in order to obtain consistent estimates. This is straight forward for linear response problems, while it is a challenge for non-linear problems in particular if they additionally are of an on-off nature. The latter will typically be the case for loads due to breaking wave impacts. The Contour line approach is an alternative convenient method to estimate the long term extreme response, based on short term statistics from an appropriate sea state. The consequence of very large short term variability (large coefficient of variation for 3-hour extreme value) on the application of the contour method will be discussed. The long term integral is carried out over all sea state combinations. The lowest sea states will of course not affect the extremes. However, for the impact problem the short term variability is much larger than for most response cases. The coefficient of variation of the 3-hour maximum impact pressure is often between 0.5 and 1, while for a typical response process it is between 0.1 and 0.2. Due to the large variability, lower sea states than normal will contribute to the long term response. In this paper the irregularity of the response surface, and the uncertainties related to the number of seeds used in each sea state is looked into. The focus is on slamming loads from breaking waves, and some results from a model test are presented. The uncertainties in long term response from slamming loads are compared to a more common response process. The effect on the long term response when integrating over a reduced area of sea states in the scatter diagram is discussed.


Author(s):  
Finn-Idar G. Giske ◽  
Bernt Johan Leira ◽  
Ole Øiseth

In this paper the first order reliability method (FORM) found in connection with structural reliability analysis is first used in an inverse manner to efficiently obtain an approximate solution of the full long-term extreme response of marine structures. A new method is then proposed where the second order reliability method (SORM) is used to improve the accuracy of the approximation. This method is compared with exact results obtained using full numerical integration. The new method is seen to achieve improved accuracy for large return periods, yet keep the number of required short-term response analyses within acceptable levels.


Author(s):  
Timothe´e Perdrizet ◽  
Daniel Averbuch

A time efficient methodology is described to evaluate the non linear extreme response of a riser connected to a FPSO subjected to wave induced loads in a stationary sea state. It is extended to cover all sea states and thus to assess the long term failure probability of the riser. The short term procedure is based on a classic time variant reliability method. It uses an approximation of the mean outcrossing rate, which is computed with the time invariant reliability method FORM (First Order Reliability Method).


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document