Variation of White Spruce Carbon Content with Age, Height, Social Classes and Silvicultural Management

The accuracy and precision with which carbon amounts have been accounted for in forests have been questioned. As countries seek to comply with agreements to reduce global warming and industries seek to maximize bioenergy potential, this matter has increased international concern. White spruce (Picea glauca (Moench) Voss) stand density management trials in the Petawawa Research Forest, Ontario, Canada, were sampled to evaluate carbon concentration variation within trees and plots of differing stand density. Sample-drying methodologies were also tested to compare freeze-dried carbon (FDC) and oven-dried carbon (ODC) measurements. The average FDC was 51.80 ± 1.19%, and the corrected freeze-dried carbon content (FDCCOR) was 51.76 ± 1.33%. The average ODC was 49.10 ± 0.92%, and the average volatile carbon fraction (Cvol) was 2.67 ± 1.71%. FDC was higher than ODC (mean of the differences = 2.52) and generally more variable. ODC significantly decreased radially and longitudinally. FDC was significantly affected by thinning, where heavy treatments resulted in the highest FDC amounts compared to medium, light, and control treatments. In addition to reducing carbon content (CC), drying influences wood CC in many ways that are still to be elucidated. The results of this study suggest that ODC should continue to be used within the bioenergy industry, while FDC must become the preferred standard for carbon accounting protocols.

Statistical Evidence for Managing Forest Density in Consideration of Natural Volatile Organic Compounds

Rapid deforestation, coupled with the growing population seeking forest therapy, urges the necessity for research on how to maximize forests’ therapeutic functions when cultivating damaged or unmanaged forests. This study was formulated to provide a basis for forest stand density management to maximize the therapeutic effects of forests with a focus on natural volatile organic compounds (NVOCs), a representative component of forest therapy through analysis of variance and regression analyses. The results of this study revealed all studied stand densities yield the highest total NVOC (TNVOC) emissions in summer, especially in the study site which has a forest density of 700/ha. In addition, treeless areas (0/ha) were found to have the most significant difference in average NVOC emissions when cultivated at a density of 700/ha. When managing forests with a density of 900/ha to 1000/ha, it has been shown that it is most desirable, in terms of therapeutic function efficiency, to control a density of 500/ha to 700/ha. Finally, regression equations for the five experimental sites with significant explanatory power were derived. Based on the results of the conducted analyses, 700/ha of forest density is recommended to maximize the therapeutic effects of forests, compared to other ranges of forest density.

Croplanner: A Stand Density Management Decision-Support Software Suite for Addressing Volumetric Yield, End-Product and Ecosystem Service Objectives When Managing Boreal Conifers

The objectives of this study were to develop a stand density management decision-support software suite for boreal conifers and demonstrate its potential utility in crop planning using practical deployment exemplifications. Denoted CPDSS (CroPlanner Decision-support Software Suite), the program was developed by transcribing algorithmic analogues of structural stand density management diagrams previously developed for even-aged black spruce (Picea mariana (Mill) BSP.) and jack pine (Pinus banksiana Lamb.) stand-types into an integrated software platform with shared commonalities with respect to computational structure, input requirements and generated numerical and graphical outputs. The suite included 6 stand-type-specific model variants (natural-origin monospecific upland black spruce and jack pine stands, mixed upland black spruce and jack pine stands, and monospecific lowland black spruce stands, and plantation-origin monospecific upland black spruce and jack pine stands), and 4 climate-sensitive stand-type-specific model variants (monospecific upland black spruce and jack pine natural-origin and planted stands). The underlying models which were equivalent in terms of their modular structure, parameterization analytics and geographic applicability, were enabled to address a diversity of crop planning scenarios when integrated within the software suite (e.g., basic, extensive, intensive and elite silvicultural regimes). Algorithmically, the Windows® (Microsoft Corporation, Redmond, WA, USA) based suite was developed by recoding the Fortran-based algorithmic model variants into a collection of VisualBasic.Net® (Microsoft Corporation, Redmond, WA, USA) equivalents and augmenting them with intuitive graphical user interfaces (GUIs), optional computer-intensive optimization applications for automated crop plan selection, and interactive tabular and charting reporting tools inclusive of static and dynamic stand visualization capabilities. In order to address a wide range of requirements from the end-user community and facilitate potential deployment within provincially regulated forest management planning systems, a participatory approach was used to guide software design. As exemplified, the resultant CPDSS can be used as an (1) automated crop planning searching tool in which computer-intensive methods are used to find the most appropriate precommercial thinning, commercial thinning and (or) initial espacement (spacing) regime, according to a weighted multivariate scoring metric reflective of attained mean tree size, operability status, volumetric productivity, and economic viability, and a set of treatment-related constraints (e.g., thresholds regarding intensity and timing of thinning events, and residual stocking levels), as specified by the end-user, or (2) iterative gaming-like crop planning tool where end-users simultaneously contrast density management regimes using detailed annual and rotational volumetric yield, end-product and ecological output measures, and (or) an abbreviate set of rotational-based performance metrics, from which they determine the most applicable crop plan required for attaining their specified stand-level objective(s). The participatory approach, modular computational structure and software platform used in the formulation of the CPDSS along with its exemplified utility, collectively provides the prerequisite foundation for its potential deployment in boreal crop planning.

Stand density management diagrams: modelling approaches, variants, and exemplification of their potential utility in crop planning

The evolving shift in forest management objectives towards the collective consideration of volumetric yield, end-product quality and value, and ecosystem service outcomes, while accounting for the impacts of anthropogenic climate change, has resulted in innovative advancements in decision-support models used in stand density management. This review provides a synopsis of these efforts with respect to static, dynamic, and structural stand density management diagrams (SDMDs). More precisely, the scope of this review includes an ecology-based perspective of stand density management, summarization of the foundational quantitative relationships along with their utilization within the analytical structure of the SDMD, examination of SDMD compliance with underlying ecological constructs and empirical prediction expectations, exemplification of a climate-sensitive structural SDMD variant in boreal crop planning, and identification of outstanding analytical challenges and plausible future research directions for advancing the SDMD modelling approach and its utility in stand-level management planning. Collectively, this account of the conceptual basis, historical analytical evolution, ecological integrity, predictive ability, application diversity, and demonstrated utility of the various SDMD variants solidifies the prerequisite evidentiary foundation for the continued development and deployment of SDMD-based crop planning decision-support models.

Climate-sensitive self-thinning trajectories of Chinese fir plantations in south China

The self-thinning rule is fundamental in regulating maximum stocking and constructing stand density management diagrams. Chinese fir (Cunninghamia lanceolata (Lamb.) Hook.) is the most important tree species and widely distributed across subtropical China. Yet, our understanding of how the self-thinning line of Chinese fir relates to climate is limited. Longitudinal data from 48 plots distributed in Fujian, Jiangxi, Guangxi, and Sichuan provinces were used to describe self-thinning for Chinese fir in relation to climate through first-order autoregressive (AR(1)) and nonlinear mixed effects (NLME) models. Results showed that self-thinning lines had steeper slopes for Chinese fir growing in areas with larger annual precipitation and summer mean maximum temperature but flatter slopes with higher mean annual temperature, degree-days below 0 °C, and winter mean minimum temperature. Winter mean minimum temperature was the dominant climatic factor in shaping self-thinning lines, which suggests that temperature was the key climate driver that affects self-thinning of Chinese fir. In addition, differences of slopes for any two of the four sites were significant, except between the Guangxi and Sichuan sites. Our results will be useful for both the silvicultural practices and mitigation strategies of Chinese fir under climate change in south China.