Comparative profiling of stress granule clearance reveals differential contributions of the ubiquitin system

Stress granules (SGs) are cytoplasmic condensates containing untranslated mRNP complexes. They are induced by various proteotoxic conditions such as heat, oxidative, and osmotic stress. SGs are believed to protect mRNPs from degradation and to enable cells to rapidly resume translation when stress conditions subside. SG dynamics are controlled by various posttranslational modifications, but the role of the ubiquitin system has remained controversial. Here, we present a comparative analysis addressing the involvement of the ubiquitin system in SG clearance. Using high-resolution immunofluorescence microscopy, we found that ubiquitin associated to varying extent with SGs induced by heat, arsenite, H2O2, sorbitol, or combined puromycin and Hsp70 inhibitor treatment. SG-associated ubiquitin species included K48- and K63-linked conjugates, whereas free ubiquitin was not significantly enriched. Inhibition of the ubiquitin activating enzyme, deubiquitylating enzymes, the 26S proteasome and p97/VCP impaired the clearance of arsenite- and heat-induced SGs, whereas SGs induced by other stress conditions were little affected. Our data underline the differential involvement of the ubiquitin system in SG clearance, a process important to prevent the formation of disease-linked aberrant SGs.

Isoleucine 44 Hydrophobic Patch Controls Toxicity of Unanchored, Linear Ubiquitin Chains through NF-κB Signaling

Ubiquitination is a post-translational modification that regulates cellular processes by altering the interactions of proteins to which ubiquitin, a small protein adduct, is conjugated. Ubiquitination yields various products, including mono- and poly-ubiquitinated substrates, as well as unanchored poly-ubiquitin chains whose accumulation is considered toxic. We previously showed that transgenic, unanchored poly-ubiquitin is not problematic in Drosophila melanogaster. In the fruit fly, free chains exist in various lengths and topologies and are degraded by the proteasome; they are also conjugated onto other proteins as one unit, eliminating them from the free ubiquitin chain pool. Here, to further explore the notion of unanchored chain toxicity, we examined when free poly-ubiquitin might become problematic. We found that unanchored chains can be highly toxic if they resemble linear poly-ubiquitin that cannot be modified into other topologies. These species upregulate NF-κB signaling, and modulation of the levels of NF-κB components reduces toxicity. In additional studies, we show that toxicity from untethered, linear chains is regulated by isoleucine 44, which anchors a key interaction site for ubiquitin. We conclude that free ubiquitin chains can be toxic, but only in uncommon circumstances, such as when the ability of cells to modify and regulate them is markedly restricted.

Rub1/NEDD8, a ubiquitin-like modifier, is also a ubiquitin modifier

ABSTRACTOf all ubiquitin-like small protein modifiers, Rub1/NEDD8 is the closest kin of ubiquitin in sequence and in structure. Despite their profound similarities, prevalence of ubiquitin and of Rub1 is starkly different: targets of ubiquitin modification reach into the thousands, whereas unique targets of Rub1/NEDD8 appear limited to one family of proteins, Cullins. This distinction is likely due to dedicated E1 activating enzymes that select either one or the other and relay the modifier until it is covalently attached to a target. To convert typical neddylation targets for modification by ubiquitin, and vice versa, we designed reciprocal substitutions at position 72 of Rub1 and of ubiquitin to render them substrates for activation by their non-cognate E1 activating enzymes. We found that this single amino acid is sufficient to distinguish between Ub and Rub1 in living cells, and determine their targets. Thus, modification of Cullins by UbR72T could compensate for loss of Rub1, even as it maintained its ability to polymerize and direct conjugates for degradation. Conversely, Rub1T72R activated by ubiquitin-activating enzyme entered into the ubiquitination cascade, however was not efficiently polymerized, essentially capping polyubiquitin chains. Upon shortage of free ubiquitin under stress, even native Rub1 spilled-over into the ubiquitinome suppressing polyubiquitination. By contrast, the need to maintain monomeric modifications on unique targets is a likely explanation for why the Rub1-activating enzyme strictly discriminates against ubiquitin. Swapping Rub1 and ubiquitin signals uncovered a reason for maintaining two separate pathways across eukaryotic kingdom.

Ubiquitin Substrates Dramatically Increase Ataxin3 Deubiquitinating Activity: Allosteric crosstalk connects three distinct sites

Ataxin3 is the founding member of the MJD family of deubiquitinating enzymes, and plays important roles in maintaining protein homeostasis and promoting DNA repair. The enzyme also contains a polyglutamine tract of variable length, and in its expanded form the protein becomes the causative agent of a neurodegenerative disorder known as Machado-Joseph disease. In vitro, ataxin3 displays low catalytic activity, prompting questions about how the enzyme is regulated and what signals might lead to its activation. Recently, it has been demonstrated that ataxin3 activity can be stimulated by either mono-ubiquitination or high concentrations of free ubiquitin. Here, we show that ubiquitin conjugates with cleavable bonds can stimulate ataxin3 activity much more strongly than free ubiquitin, with physiological levels of these conjugates increasing activity up to 60-fold over basal levels. Our data are consistent with a model in which ubiquitin conjugates activate the enzyme allosterically by binding in a site adjacent to the catalytic center, known as Site 1. We further show that two additional ubiquitin-binding sites in the enzyme work in concert to modulate enzyme activation, and we propose a model in which ubiquitin conjugates bridge these two sites to drive the enzyme into a high-activity conformation.SignificanceUbiquitin signaling networks modulate almost all aspects of eukaryotic biology, and their outputs reflect the dynamic balance between ubiquitin attachment and removal. The latter process is catalyzed by deubiquitinating enzymes (DUBs), which must be carefully regulated to ensure that their activities are applied appropriately. Ataxin3 is a DUB that participates in quality-control pathways that support cellular health; however, the regulation of its activity has remained poorly understood. Here, we show that ataxin3 can be dramatically activated by naturally occurring ubiquitin species, and that this activation involves a previously uncharacterized interplay between three distinct sites on the enzyme. Our improved understanding of ataxin3 regulation provides insights into allosteric mechanisms that may prove applicable to other enzymes in the ubiquitin universe.

The Degradation-promoting Roles of Deubiquitinases Ubp6 and Ubp3 in Cytosolic and ER Protein Quality Control

The quality control of intracellular proteins is achieved by degrading misfolded proteins which cannot be refolded by molecular chaperones. In eukaryotes, such degradation is handled primarily by the ubiquitin-proteasome system. However, it remains unclear whether and how protein quality control deploys various deubiquitinases. To address this question, we screened deletions or mutation of the 20 deubiquitinase genes in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and discovered that almost half of the mutations slowed the removal of misfolded proteins whereas none of the remaining mutations accelerated this process significantly. Further characterization revealed that Ubp6 maintains the level of free ubiquitin to promote the elimination of misfolded cytosolic proteins, while Ubp3 supports the degradation of misfolded cytosolic and ER luminal proteins by different mechanisms.

Proteomics of broad deubiquitylase inhibition unmasks redundant enzyme function to reveal substrates

Deubiquitylating enzymes (DUBs) counteract ubiquitylation to control stability or activity of substrates. Identification of DUB substrates is challenging because multiple DUBs act on the same substrates, thwarting genetic approaches. Here, we circumvented redundancy by broadly inhibiting DUBs in Xenopus egg extract. DUB inhibition increases ubiquitylation of hundreds of proteins, depleting free ubiquitin without inducing widespread degradation. Restoring available ubiquitin led to proteasomal degradation of over thirty proteins, indicating that deubiquitylation is essential to maintain their stability. We confirmed their DUB-dependent stability with recombinant human proteins, demonstrating evolutionary conservation. We profiled the ability of DUBs to rescue protein stability, and found that USP7 has a unique ability to broadly antagonize proteasomal degradation. Together, we provide a comprehensive characterization of ubiquitin dynamics in the Xenopus system, identify new DUB substrates, and present a new approach to characterize physiological DUB specificity that overcomes challenges posed by DUB redundancy

High-affinity free ubiquitin sensors as quantitative probes of ubiquitin homeostasis and deubiquitination

Ubiquitin (Ub) conjugation is an essential post-translational modification that affects nearly all proteins in eukaryotes. The functions and mechanisms of ubiquitination are areas of extensive and ongoing study, and yet the dynamics and regulation of even free (i.e., unconjugated) Ub are poorly understood. A major impediment has been the lack of simple and robust techniques to quantify Ub levels in cells and to monitor Ub release from conjugates. Here we describe the development of avidity-based fluorescent sensors that address this need. The sensors bind specifically to free Ub, have Kd values down to 60 pM, and, in concert with a newly developed workflow, allow us to distinguish and quantify the pools of free, protein-conjugated, and thioesterified forms of Ub from cell lysates. Alternatively, free Ub in fixed cells can be visualized microscopically by staining with a sensor. Real-time assays using the sensors afford unprecedented flexibility and precision to measure deubiquitination of virtually any (poly)Ub conjugate.