Computational simulation of the relaxation of local stresses due to foreign object damage under cyclic loading

Author(s):  
T Davis ◽  
J Ding ◽  
W Sun ◽  
S B Leen

In this study, the phenomenon of residual stress relaxation from foreign object damage (FOD) is numerically simulated using a hybrid explicit—implicit finite-element method. The effects of cycle fatigue loadings on stress relaxation were studied. FOD is first simulated by firing a 3mm cube impacting onto a plate made of titanium alloy Ti-6Al-4V at 200m/s. The FOD impact produces two distinct stress concentrations: one is compressive directly beneath the impact site; the other is tensile around the outer edge of the impact. The plate was then assumed to be subjected to a cyclic fatigue loading. The stress relaxation was investigated under a range of stress ratios and maximum applied stresses. Two different material models were considered for the simulations, namely an elastic—perfectly plastic model and a non-linear kinematic hardening model.

Author(s):  
Pierangelo Duo´ ◽  
Christian Pianka ◽  
Andrej Golowin ◽  
Matthias Fueller ◽  
Roger Schaefer ◽  
...  

During operating service, gas turbine aero-engines can ingest small hard particles which typically produce damage to the aerofoils. If the damage found is a tear or a perforation at the leading edge, it is known as a Foreign Object Damage or FOD and this leads to a reduction of the subsequent High-Cycle-Fatigue (HCF) strength. The objective of research work in this area is to assess the effect of FOD on the residual fatigue strength of compressor blades and to provide predictive tools for engineering judgment. The methodology followed is normally to carry out experimental simulation of FOD, followed by fatigue tests to assess subsequent performance. To date, research related to fatigue following FOD events has concentrated on HCF loading and the impact geometry is frequently that of a sphere against a flat surface or the edge of a blade-like specimen. Both of these aspects do not correspond to the worst cases of real FOD. Here it is intended to investigate the effect of a V-notch geometry, which is more representative of severe FOD found in service. Alongside this, numerical models can be used to simulate the damage and to evaluate the residual stress field. In addition analytical model are used to predict the residual fatigue strength. The current work explains the development of a new rig impact test and discusses the improvements necessary to obtain a sufficient repeatability of the impacts. From the experience gained with a gas gun, an alternative method using a pistol and a barrel, capable of achieving the necessary velocity of simulated FOD, was developed. The applied velocity was in the range of 250m/s to 300m/s and a technique to describe the impact is here discussed. Furthermore the introduction of a high speed camera has allowed to have a complete description of the impact scene and to better understand the impact. The impacted blades were measured and HCF tested. As a result, this has produced a large scatter in the residual fatigue strength. The current method to describe a notch using a 2D approach, which was applied to several geometries of notches, is here critically reviewed. The proposed method would incorporate a more sophisticated method, which reconstruct the real geometry using optical measurement. This latter measurement can fully describe the 3D geometry, showing particularly zones inside the notch where compressive residual might appears. Tears and shear of the material can also be described by applying this technique. The findings are compared with the residual HCF strength and the results are compared to special cases of HCF to justify the results out of theoretical prediction.


Author(s):  
Benjamin Hanschke ◽  
Thomas Klauke ◽  
Arnold Kühhorn

For a considerable amount of time blade integrated disks (blisks) are established as a standard component of high pressure compressors (HPCs) in aero engines. Due to the steady requirement to increase the efficiency of modern HPCs, blade profiles get thinned out and aerodynamic stage loading increases. Ever since, aerofoil design has to balance structural and aerodynamic requirements. One particularity of aero engines is the possibility to ingest different kinds of debris during operation and some of those particles are hard enough to seriously damage the aerofoil. Lately, a growing number of blisk-equipped aero engines entered service and the question of foreign object damage (FOD) sensitivity relating to compressor blade high cycle fatigue (HCF) has emerged. Correct prediction of fatigue strength drop due to a FOD provides a huge chance for cost cutting in the service sector as on-wing repairs (e.g. borescope blending) are much more convenient than the replacement of whole blisks and corresponding engine strips. The aim of this paper is to identify critical FOD-areas of a modern HPC stage and to analyze the effects of stress concentrations — caused by FOD — on the fatigue strength. A process chain has been developed, that automatically creates damaged geometries, meshes the parts and analyses the fatigue strength. Amplitude frequency strength (af-strength) has been chosen as fatigue strength indicator owing to the fact, that amplitudes and frequencies of blade vibrations are commonly measured either by blade tip timing or strain gauges. Furthermore, static and dynamic stress concentrations in damaged geometries compared to the reference design were computed. A random variation of input parameters was performed, such as the radial damage position at blade leading edge and damage diameter. Based on results of the different samples, correlations of input parameters and the fatigue strength drop have been investigated. Evaluation shows a significant mode dependence of critical blade areas with a large scatter between drops in fatigue strength visible for mode to mode comparison. Keeping in mind the necessity of fast response times in the in-service sector, FOD sensitivity computations could be performed for all blade rows of the HPC — including the analysis of possible borescope blending geometries — in the design stage. Finally, the actual amplitude frequency levels (af-levels) of the modes excited during operation have to be appropriately taken into consideration. For example, a pronounced af-strength drop due to a FOD may not be critical for safe engine operations because the observed mode is excited by small af-levels during operation. Hence, the endurance ratio — a quotient of af-level and af-strength — is used as assessment criterion.


Author(s):  
Nesredin Kedir ◽  
D. Calvin Faucett ◽  
Luis Sanchez ◽  
Sung R. Choi

The response of a SiC fibrous ceramic composite to foreign object damage was determined at ambient temperature and velocities ranging from 40 to 150 m/s. Target specimens were impacted, at a normal incidence angle and in a partially supported configuration, using 1.59 mm-diameter hardened steel ball projectiles. Qualitative analysis of the damage morphologies of targets and projectiles were made via scanning electron microscopy (SEM). In addition, the extent of impact damage was characterized by determining the post-impact strength of each target specimen as a function of impact velocity. Relative to the as-received strength, the fibrous composite showed limited strength degradation due to impact with the maximum reduction of 17 % occurring at 150 m/s. A quasi-static analysis of the impact force prediction was also made based on the principle of energy conservation and the results were verified via experimental data.


Author(s):  
Nesredin Kedir ◽  
David Faucett ◽  
Luis Sanchez ◽  
Sung R. Choi

Foreign object damage (FOD) behavior of an N720/alumina oxide/oxide ceramic matrix composite (CMC) was characterized at ambient temperature by using spherical projectiles impacted at velocities ranging from 100 to 350 m/s. The CMC targets were subject to ballistic impact at a normal incidence angle while being loaded under different levels of tensile loading in order to simulate conditions of rotating aeroengine airfoils. The impact damage of frontal and back surfaces was assessed with respect to impact velocity and load factor. Subsequent post-impact residual strength was also estimated to determine quantitatively the severity of impact damage. Impact force was predicted based on the principles of energy conservation.


2018 ◽  
Vol 141 (4) ◽  
Author(s):  
Nesredin Kedir ◽  
D. Calvin Faucett ◽  
Luis Sanchez ◽  
Sung R. Choi

The response of a silicon carbide (SiC) fibrous ceramic composite to foreign object damage (FOD) was determined at ambient temperature and velocities ranging from 40 to 150 m/s. Target specimens were impacted, at a normal incidence angle and in a partially supported configuration, using 1.59 mm diameter hardened steel ball projectiles. Qualitative analysis of the damage morphologies of targets and projectiles was made via scanning electron microscopy (SEM). In addition, the extent of impact damage was characterized by determining the post-impact strength of each target specimen as a function of impact velocity. Relative to the as-received (As-R) strength, the fibrous composite showed limited strength degradation due to impact with the maximum reduction of 17% occurring at 150 m/s. A quasi-static analysis of the impact force prediction was also made based on the principle of energy conservation and the results were verified via experimental data.


2011 ◽  
Vol 148-149 ◽  
pp. 958-962
Author(s):  
Dong Mei Yin ◽  
Zhen Xiao Li

The influence of centrifugal prestress on the foreign object damage of engine blades was analyzed by numerical simulation. A nonlinear dynamic model for foreign object damage of blade with centrifugal prestress was established. And the dynamic relaxation method was used to obtain the initial stress and displacement field of blade in the beginning of the dynamic analysis of impact. Numerical simulations of foreign objects impacting on the leading edges of the blades under different centrifugal preloads were carried out. The results indicate that the local plastic deformation on the impact location of blade with centrifugal preload, which is produced at the moment of impact, is decreasing with the increase of the preload. The growth of crack produced on the lead edge of blade is accelerated with the preload increasing.


Author(s):  
Nesredin Kedir ◽  
David Faucett ◽  
Luis Sanchez ◽  
Sung R. Choi

Foreign object damage (FOD) behavior of an N720/alumina oxide/oxide ceramic matrix composite (CMC) was characterized at ambient temperature by using spherical projectiles impacted at velocities ranging from 100 to 350 m/s. The CMC targets were subject to ballistic impact at a normal incidence angle while being loaded under different levels of tensile loading in order to simulate conditions of rotating aeroengine airfoils. The impact damage of frontal and back surfaces was assessed with respect to impact velocity and load factor. Subsequent postimpact residual strength was also estimated to determine quantitatively the severity of impact damage. Impact force was predicted based on the principles of energy conservation.


Author(s):  
Sung R. Choi ◽  
J. Michael Pereira ◽  
Lesley A. Janosik ◽  
Ramakrishna T. Bhatt

Foreign object damage (FOD) behavior of two commercial gas-turbine grade silicon nitrides, AS800 and SN282, was determined at ambient temperature through post-impact strength testing for thin disks impacted by steel-ball projectiles with a diameter of 1.59 mm in a velocity range from 115 to 440 m/s. AS800 silicon nitride exhibited a greater FOD resistance than SN282, primarily due to its greater value of fracture toughness (KIC). The critical impact velocity in which the corresponding post-impact strength yielded the lowest value was Vc ≈ 440 and 300 m/s for AS800 and SN282, respectively. A unique lower-strength regime was typified for both silicon nitrides depending on impact velocity, attributed to significant radial cracking. The damages generated by projectile impact were typically in the forms of ring, radial, and cone cracks with their severity and combination being dependent on impact velocity. Unlike thick (3 mm) flexure bar specimens used in the previous studies, thin (2 mm) disk target specimens exhibited a unique backside radial cracking occurring on the reverse side just beneath the impact sites at and above impact velocity of 160 and 220 m/s for SN282 and AS800, respectively.


Materials ◽  
2019 ◽  
Vol 12 (9) ◽  
pp. 1488 ◽  
Author(s):  
Przemysław Golewski ◽  
Tomasz Sadowski

While a plane is maneuvering before take-off and landing, some solid particles (e.g. sand, dust, soil) may get into the engine with air. A vast majority of them are stopped by the compressor blades, but the smaller ones can get into a hot part of the engine and cause erosion. A pneumatic laboratory work station was built in order to investigate the impact of foreign object damage (FOD) particles with a diameter of 4 mm. Cylindrical samples with a diameter of 30 mm were used, each having a thermal barrier coating (TBC) deposited by the air plasma spray (APS) method with the application of yttria-stabilized zirconia (YSZ). Sample aging was performed for four ranges: 48, 89, 185, and 353 h at the temperature of 1000 °C. After aging, samples were subjected to impacts made with different energies. Various damage images were captured depending on the aging time and impact velocity. Numerical studies led to the determination of how the incidence angle of a foreign object and the blade temperature affected the number of elements that became damaged during impact. It was found that impacts perpendicular to the surface were the most dangerous, while heating the blade to the operating temperature resulted in a 27% decrease in the number of elements damaged during impact when compared to the cold blade.


Materials ◽  
2019 ◽  
Vol 12 (7) ◽  
pp. 1153 ◽  
Author(s):  
Just ◽  
Koch ◽  
Brod ◽  
Jansen ◽  
Gude ◽  
...  

Microcrack formation and delamination growth are the main damage mechanisms in thefatigue of composites. They lead to significant stiffness loss, introduce stress concentrations andcan be the origin of subsequent damage events like buckling or fibre breakage, especially in case ofshear and compression stresses during load reversal. Fatigue experiments of carbon fibre reinforcedlaminates were conducted at several stress ratios and analysed in terms of crack and delaminationgrowth. These investigations were accompanied by microscopic imaging, digital image correlationand finite element modelling to take into account the effects of residual stresses and crack closure.It was found that residual stresses significantly change the local stress ratio in off-axis layers andlead to residual crack opening of inter fibre cracks. These cracks remain open and close under highcompression loadings only. Furthermore, crack formation under pulsating compression loadingturned out to be driven by residual stresses leading to perpendicular cracks as observed underpure tension loading. The experimental findings further confirm the severe detrimental effect oftension-compression loading on crack formation and delamination growth compared to pulsatingtension-tension or compression-compression loads.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document