scholarly journals Ex Vivo Models Simulating the Bone Marrow Environment and Predicting Response to Therapy in Multiple Myeloma

Cancers ◽  
2020 ◽  
Vol 12 (8) ◽  
pp. 2006
Author(s):  
Konstantinos Papadimitriou ◽  
Ioannis V. Kostopoulos ◽  
Anastasia Tsopanidou ◽  
Nikolaos Orologas-Stavrou ◽  
Efstathios Kastritis ◽  
...  

Multiple myeloma (MM) remains incurable despite the abundance of novel drugs. As it has been previously shown, preclinical 2D models fail to predict disease progression due to their inability to simulate the microenvironment of the bone marrow. In this review, we focus on 3D models and present all currently available ex vivo MM models that fulfil certain criteria, such as development of complex 3D environments using patients’ cells and ability to test different drugs in order to assess personalized MM treatment efficacy of various regimens and combinations. We selected models representing the top-notch ex vivo platforms and evaluated them in terms of cost, time-span, and feasibility of the method. Finally, we propose where such a model can be more informative in a patient’s treatment timeline. Overall, advanced 3D preclinical models are very promising as they may eventually offer the opportunity to precisely select the optimal personalized treatment for each MM patient.

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Marina Ferrarini ◽  
Magda Marcatti ◽  
Fabio Ciceri ◽  
Elisabetta Ferrero

Multiple Myeloma (MM) develops almost exclusively within the Bone Marrow (BM), highlighting the critical role of the microenvironment in conditioning disease progression and resistance to drugs. Indeed, while the therapeutic armamentarium for MM has significantly improved over the past 20 years, the disease remains ultimately incurable. This failure may depend on the high phenotypic and genetic heterogeneity of MM, but also on the paucity and inadequacy of two-dimensional (2D) conventional preclinical models in reproducing MM within the BM. In the present paper, we provide a brief updated overview on MM BM microenvironment. We then discuss newly developed preclinical models mimicking MM/microenvironment interactions, including three-dimensional (3D), gel-based, in vitro models and a novel ex vivo system of isolated tumor and stromal cells cultured in bioreactor. Potential applications of each model, relative to investigation of MM pathogenic mechanisms and prediction of the best drug/combination for each individual patient will be also evaluated.


2021 ◽  
Vol 11 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Kinan Alhallak ◽  
Amanda Jeske ◽  
Pilar de la Puente ◽  
Jennifer Sun ◽  
Mark Fiala ◽  
...  

AbstractCancer patients undergo detrimental toxicities and ineffective treatments especially in the relapsed setting, due to failed treatment attempts. The development of a tool that predicts the clinical response of individual patients to therapy is greatly desired. We have developed a novel patient-derived 3D tissue engineered bone marrow (3DTEBM) technology that closely recapitulate the pathophysiological conditions in the bone marrow and allows ex vivo proliferation of tumor cells of hematologic malignancies. In this study, we used the 3DTEBM to predict the clinical response of individual multiple myeloma (MM) patients to different therapeutic regimens. We found that while no correlation was observed between in vitro efficacy in classic 2D culture systems of drugs used for MM with their clinical efficacious concentration, the efficacious concentration in the 3DTEBM were directly correlated. Furthermore, the 3DTEBM model retrospectively predicted the clinical response to different treatment regimens in 89% of the MM patient cohort. These results demonstrated that the 3DTEBM is a feasible platform which can predict MM clinical responses with high accuracy and within a clinically actionable time frame. Utilization of this technology to predict drug efficacy and the likelihood of treatment failure could significantly improve patient care and treatment in many ways, particularly in the relapsed and refractory setting. Future studies are needed to validate the 3DTEBM model as a tool for predicting clinical efficacy.


Leukemia ◽  
2016 ◽  
Vol 31 (8) ◽  
pp. 1743-1751 ◽  
Author(s):  
S Hipp ◽  
Y-T Tai ◽  
D Blanset ◽  
P Deegen ◽  
J Wahl ◽  
...  

Abstract B-cell maturation antigen (BCMA) is a highly plasma cell-selective protein that is expressed on malignant plasma cells of multiple myeloma (MM) patients and therefore is an ideal target for T-cell redirecting therapies. We developed a bispecific T-cell engager (BiTE) targeting BCMA and CD3ɛ (BI 836909) and studied its therapeutic impacts on MM. BI 836909 induced selective lysis of BCMA-positive MM cells, activation of T cells, release of cytokines and T-cell proliferation; whereas BCMA-negative cells were not affected. Activity of BI 836909 was not influenced by the presence of bone marrow stromal cells, soluble BCMA or a proliferation-inducing ligand (APRIL). In ex vivo assays, BI 836909 induced potent autologous MM cell lysis in both, newly diagnosed and relapsed/refractory patient samples. In mouse xenograft studies, BI 836909 induced tumor cell depletion in a subcutaneous NCI-H929 xenograft model and prolonged survival in an orthotopic L-363 xenograft model. In a cynomolgus monkey study, administration of BI 836909 led to depletion of BCMA-positive plasma cells in the bone marrow. Taken together, these results show that BI 836909 is a highly potent and efficacious approach to selectively deplete BCMA-positive MM cells and represents a novel immunotherapeutic for the treatment of MM.


2020 ◽  
Vol 4 (8) ◽  
pp. 1628-1639
Author(s):  
Zachary J. Walker ◽  
Michael J. VanWyngarden ◽  
Brett M. Stevens ◽  
Diana Abbott ◽  
Andrew Hammes ◽  
...  

Abstract The oncogenic drivers and progression factors in multiple myeloma (MM) are heterogeneous and difficult to target therapeutically. Many different MM drugs have emerged, however, that attack various phenotypic aspects of malignant plasma cells. These drugs are administered in numerous, seemingly interchangeable combinations. Although the availability of many treatment options is useful, no clinical test capable of optimizing and sequencing the treatment regimens for an individual patient is currently available. To overcome this problem, we developed a functional ex vivo approach to measure patients’ inherent and acquired drug resistance. This method, which we termed myeloma drug sensitivity testing (My-DST), uses unselected bone marrow mononuclear cells with a panel of drugs in clinical use, followed by flow cytometry to measure myeloma-specific cytotoxicity. We found that using whole bone marrow cultures helped preserve primary MM cell viability. My-DST was used to profile 55 primary samples at diagnosis or at relapse. Sensitivity or resistance to each drug was determined from the change in MM viability relative to untreated control samples. My-DST identified progressive loss of sensitivity to immunomodulatory drugs, proteasome inhibitors, and daratumumab through the disease course, mirroring the clinical development of resistance. Prospectively, patients’ ex vivo drug sensitivity to the drugs subsequently received was sensitive and specific for clinical response. In addition, treatment with <2 drugs identified as sensitive by My-DST led to inferior depth and duration of clinical response. In summary, ex vivo drug sensitivity is prognostically impactful and, with further validation, may facilitate more personalized and effective therapeutic regimens.


Blood ◽  
2004 ◽  
Vol 104 (11) ◽  
pp. 3347-3347
Author(s):  
Catherine Pellat-Deceunynck ◽  
Nelly Robillard ◽  
Regis Bataille

Abstract To identify new potential therapeutical targets in multiple myeloma (MM), we have defined the phenotype of the subset of proliferative myeloma cells (n=66) in comparison with that of normal PC (n=25). Proliferation was evaluated by ex vivo incorporation of BrdU (labeling index, LI). Surface PC phenotype was performed in a four-color assay with CD38, CD45, CD138 and the mAb indicated. For intracellular BrdU staining, cells were first labeled with CD38, CD45 and CD138, fixed and permeabilized before BdrU staining. At least 1000 normal PC and 10000 myeloma cells were analyzed. We show that all bone marrow PC, either malignant or normal, always included a subset of proliferative PC (BrdU+) that was always located within the CD45++subpopulation. Indeed, CD45++ myeloma cells (median 12%) had a labeling index 7.5-fold higher of that of CD45+/− myeloma cells (7.1% versus 0.94%). Actually, in all cases of MM, CD45++ myeloma cells were always the most proliferative myeloma cells. As observed for myeloma cells, LI of normal PC was heterogeneous i.e., higher in the CD45++ population of PC: CD45++ PC (median 65%) had a LI 5.7-fold higher of that of CD45+/− PC. Compared to myeloma cells, LI of PC were higher in both subsets, of 20.5% and 3.6% for CD45++ and CD45+/−, respectively. Non-malignant PC from blood or tonsil were homogeneously CD45++ and did proliferate (LI> 10% and up to 45% for reactive PC). In all PC (normal, reactive, malignant), we found an inverse correlation between CD45 and Bcl-2, confirming a known inverse correlation between proliferation and Bcl-2 expression. Our data suggest that a minor cycling Bcl2lowCD45++ population of myeloma cells differentiate into a no more cycling major Bcl2high CD45+/− population of myelom a cells that accumulates. We further characterized the phenotype of the CD45++ myeloma cells population: we found that CD11a and to a less extend HLA-DR were expressed by CD45++ myeloma cells only in contrast to CD40 and CXCR4 that were expressed by all myeloma cells. Moreover, all CD45++ myeloma cells coexpressed CD11a. Thus, the-to-be-killed population of myeloma cells could be targeted through CD45 or CD11a.


Blood ◽  
2004 ◽  
Vol 104 (11) ◽  
pp. 4863-4863
Author(s):  
Albert Oriol ◽  
Daniel Valverde ◽  
Jaume Capellades ◽  
Miquel Cabañas ◽  
Carles Arús ◽  
...  

Abstract Introduction. Bone marrow magnetic resonance (MR) imaging provides important information i<SPACER size="24">n the evaluation of patients with multiple myeloma (MM) but MR assessment of response to therapy is highly subjective. Proton nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (1H MRS) may be able to measure the ratio of lipid to water resonance signal intensities (LWR) and thus reflect the relative percentages of cellular and fatty bone marrow within a defined three-dimensional volume (voxel). These measurements could be used to quantify the degree of cytoreduction in MM patients. Patients and Methods. Twenty-one consecutive patients (10 male; median age 65 years, range 44–82) with newly diagnosed multiple myeloma underwent a MR exploration of the fifth lumbar vertebral body before the initiation of treatment. Patients completing therapy were reevaluated. Dorso-lumbar imaging studies were carried out in a 1.5T system with a saggital spin-echo T1-weighted sequence (TR 437 ms / TE 15 ms). A 2-cm-thick transverse center section of the L5 lumbar vertebral body was sampled to place the voxel. Spectroscopic data were acquired with a stimulated echo acquisition mode (STEAM) sequence without water suppression with repetition time 5 s and echo time 40 ms. To calculate the area of the water signal, the peak was fit to a single Lorenzian curve centered at 4.75 ppm. The area of the lipid resonances was fit to 3 Lorenzian curves centered at 0.89 (-CH3), 1.34 and 2.2 (-CH2) ppm. The areas obtained were used to calculate the LWR for each voxel. The LWR was defined as the sum of the area of the 3 lipid fitted resonances divided by the area of the fitted water resonance. Results. The spectra showed a water peak and a compounded lipid peak separated by approximately 3.1 ppm. LWRs ranged from 0 to 15 (mean 1.748, SD 3.741). Seven patients were treated with melphalan and prednisone (MP) and 14 received 3 cycles of vincristine, BCNU, cyclophosphamide, melphalan and prednisone alternating with 3 cyles of vincristine, BCNU, doxorrubicin and dexametasone (VBCMP/VBAD). Therapy was interrupted for at least 4 weeks before the MR evaluation. Two patients under MP could not be reevaluated. One patient under VBCMP/VBAD suffered extensive L5 collapse that invalidated a second MR study. Four patients progressed under treatment and only 1 of them could be re-submitted to MR. A patient who achieved a partial response after VBCMP/VBAD refused to undergo a MR re-evaluation. Pre and post treatment MR studies were available in 14 patients (progression 1, no response 3, partial response 3, complete response 7). LWR increased in 11/14 patients (78%) (p=0.034). However, 7/7 (100%) complete responders presented a LWR increase (p=0.018) while only 4/7 (57%) non-responders did. No significant differences were observed among partial responders or patients non-responding or progressing. Conclusions. Changes i LWR as assessed by 1H NMR correlated with response to chemotherapy in patients with multiple myeloma, thus this technique may be used to measure noninvasively the response to treatment in these patients.


Blood ◽  
2005 ◽  
Vol 106 (11) ◽  
pp. 3395-3395
Author(s):  
Marcin Majka ◽  
Artur Jurczyszyn ◽  
Anna Zebzda ◽  
Wojciech Czogala ◽  
Ewa Lesko ◽  
...  

Abstract Despite progress in the treatment of Multiple Myeloma (MM), it is still an incurable disease with average survival of 3–4 years. Because MM is often resistant to conventional therapies, new treatment strategies are necessary. The presence of elevated HGF (Hepatocytic Grow Factor) expression has been well documented in multiple myeloma. The c-met oncogene has been shown to be present in MM cell lines at the mRNA and protein level. Some data suggested that this axis could be responsible for proliferation and inhibition of apoptosis in MM cells. In this study we have analyzed c-met expression in 15 patients with (MM) before and after treatment. Seven of these pts responded well and eight pts responded poorly to the employed therapy. All 15 pts were c-met positive before therapy. Bone marrow cellularity of patients who responded well was 76% before (range: 10% – 100%) and 46% after treatment (range: 40% – 60%). In this group plasmocyte infiltration of bone marrow consisted of 59% before (range: 10% – 80%) and 9% after chemotherapy (range: 0% – 20%). Five of them had undetectable c-met positive cells among bone marrow cells after treatment. In the group of poor responders cellularity of bone marrow was 40% (range: 20% – 70%) before treatment and 46% (range: 20% – 70%) after therapy. Plasmocytes consisted of 20% (range: 10% – 50%) of bone marrow cells before and 44% (range: 10% – 90%) after treatment. All patients in this group had cells positive for c-met receptor after therapeutic regiment. This results suggested that c-met-HGF axis might be a good target for alternative therapy in MM. We looked for potential therapeutics that interferes with this axis and we found that geldanamycin (GA) has been shown to decrease expression of c-met at the protein level in several different cell types. Using inhibitors that belongs to geldanamycin family (GA, 17AAG and 17DMAG) we treated MM cell lines and primary sample. We found that these molecules strongly inhibited expression of c-met in both MM cell lines and patients sample as assessed by western blot analysis. We also tested the influence of these inhibitors on proliferation of MM cells. We found that 100nM dose of GA and 17DMAG inhibited growth of MM cell lines by 80% and 100nM dose of 17AAG inhibited growth of these cells by 20%. Primary cells were more resistant to treatment but we still obtained 30% inhibition with GA and 17DMAG. 17AAG was ineffective and proliferation decreased by less than 10%. Grow inhibition was probably not only due to c-met-HGF axis blockade because these molecules also inhibit other proteins (AKT, RAF). In our experiments we have shown that the level of c-met expression correlates with response to therapy. Patients who respond well had substantially decreased number of c-met positive plasmocytes after chemotherapy in comparison to poor responders. We have also showed that drugs that block c-met-HGF axis could be used in treatment of MM. These drugs could potentially inhibit cells proliferation, increase apoptosis and disrupt MM cells interaction with bone marrow environment. Based on these data we postulate that the c-met receptor is a potential target for MM therapy especially in patients who do not respond to the first line of treatment.


Blood ◽  
2013 ◽  
Vol 122 (21) ◽  
pp. 1910-1910 ◽  
Author(s):  
Chrystal Landry ◽  
Dory Londono ◽  
Sean M. Devlin ◽  
Alex Lesokhin ◽  
Nikoletta Lendvai ◽  
...  

Abstract Background Multiple myeloma (MM) is a heterogeneous condition with variable disease course, response to therapy, and survival outcome. Cytogenetics and fluorescent in-situ hybridization (FISH) have identified several recurrent chromosomal aberrations in MM and play important and independent roles in risk stratification (Munshi et al. Blood 2011). However, the pathogenesis of the disorder remains poorly understood. Next-generation sequencing has recently identified that MM involves mutations of genes with roles in protein translation, histone methylation, and blood coagulation (Chapman et al. Nature 2011). Based on the observation that extra copies of MLL, a histone methyltransferase known to regulate the homeotic transcription factor HOXA9 that is highly expressed in MM, is frequently detected in MM, we sought to define the incidence and prognostic significance of excess MLL in MM patients. Methods We identified 188 patients with newly diagnosed MM who had cytogenetics and/or FISH performed on initial, pre-treatment bone marrow specimens at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center between January 2009 and December 2012. Standard karyotype and FISH were performed as previously described (Cigudosa et al. Blood 1998, Gerritsen et al. Blood 1992). Probes included LSI IgH/FGF3, LSI IgH/CCND1, LSI IgH/MAF, LSI MLL, LSI p53/cep17, LSI13q14.3/13q34, LSI ETV6, LSI CBFB, LSI 1p36/1q25, and LSI 5,9,15 from Abbott Molecular. Fisher's exact test evaluated the association between MLL and selected abnormalities. Kaplan-Meier methodology estimated overall survival from the date of BM evaluation, and survival was compared using a logrank test. Results In unselected bone marrow specimens, abnormalities were detected by karyotype in 17% (27/156) and FISH in 47% (87/186) of patients tested. Hyperdiploidy, which has been associated with longer survival, was identified in 23% (43/187) of patients, while the unfavorable risk abnormalities, including loss of p53, deletion 13q (by karyotype), translocation (4;14) and excess 1q were seen in 8% (15/179), 8% (12/156), 4% (7/176) and 16% (29/178) of patients, respectively. Translocation (11;14) was seen in 4 patients; translocation (14;16) was not identified in any patient. 28% (51/183) of patients had extra copies of MLL, which was the most frequent genetic abnormality identified. Unexpectedly, this abnormality was significantly associated with both favorable (hyperdiploidy, P = <0.001) and unfavorable (deletion 13q, P = 0.043; excess 1q P = 0.001) risk genetics. While having excess MLL had no impact on the overall survival of standard-risk patients, defined as neither hyperdiploid nor with unfavorable genetics (N = 100), patients with poor-risk genetics (N = 46) and extra copies of MLL had a trend toward better survival, P = 0.06 (Figure 1). Conclusions Karyotype and FISH studies identified excess MLL as the most frequent cytogenetic abnormality in a large cohort of newly diagnosed MM patients. In patients with MM and unfavorable cytogenetics, the presence of excess MLL may ameliorate some of the adverse impact of associated with these abnormalities. Understanding the functional significance of excess MLL, perhaps as it relates to frequently dysregulated HOXA9 in MM, may provide insight into disease pathogenesis and/or identify drugable targets. Disclosures: No relevant conflicts of interest to declare.


2018 ◽  
Vol 19 (7) ◽  
pp. 2031 ◽  
Author(s):  
Domenico Ribatti ◽  
Angelo Vacca

Angiogenesis is a constant hallmark of multiple myeloma (MM) progression and involves direct production of angiogenic cytokines by plasma cells and their induction within the bone marrow microenvironment. This article summarizes the more recent literature data concerning the employment of anti-angiogenic therapeutic agents actually used in preclinical models and clinical settings for the treatment of multiple myeloma.


Blood ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 138 (Supplement 1) ◽  
pp. 4717-4717
Author(s):  
Masha Frenkel ◽  
Zoya Alteber ◽  
Ning Xu ◽  
Mingjie Li ◽  
Haiming Chen ◽  
...  

Abstract Introduction Blocking inhibitory immune checkpoints holds promise to treat multiple myeloma (MM) patients. However, currently available checkpoint inhibitors have not shown significant clinical benefits for MM patients, warranting the need for alternative checkpoint blockers. The immune checkpoint TIGIT was recently shown to be the most upregulated immune inhibitory receptor on CD8+ T cells in MM patients' bone marrow (BM), compared to other checkpoints (Guillerey C., Blood. 2018). Preclinical models demonstrated the dominant effects of TIGIT blockade or depletion, by significantly improving mice survival, reducing myeloma cell numbers and exhausted T cell hallmarks (Minnie S., Blood. 2018). As a result, several clinical trials using anti-TIGIT monoclonal antibodies have been recently initiated in MM patients. The DNAM-1 family, in addition to TIGIT, also includes the inhibitory receptor PVRIG, that competes with the co-activating receptor DNAM-1 for the binding to the shared ligand PVRL2, similarly to the TIGIT/PVR/DNAM-1 interaction. Accordingly, TIGIT and PVRIG co-blockade were shown to synergize in enhancing T cell activity and anti-tumor activity in preclinical models (Whelan S., Cancer Immunol. Res. 2019). PVRL2 together with PVR (ligand of TIGIT) were shown to be highly expressed on plasma cells and on CD14+ cells in BM of MM patients (Lozano E., Clin. Cancer Res. 2020). This study aimed at evaluating DNAM-1 axis receptors expression in MM patients' BM. Methods Fresh BM aspirates were collected from 21 MM patients with progressive disease (PD) or in complete response (CR) after obtaining IRB approval. BM mononuclear cells were isolated and single cell suspensions were obtained followed by staining with anti-human antibodies to evaluate DNAM-1 axis members and PD-1 expression. BM biopsies from 6 MM patients (each patient had 4 core on the Tissue Micro-Array T291 USBiomax) were stained for PVRL2 expression by immuno-histochemistry (IHC). Results Flow cytometry analysis of PD-1 and DNAM-1 axis receptors revealed a significant lower fraction of PD1+ cells among cell populations examined compared with other receptors. TIGIT expression was the highest on NK, CD8+ and NKT cells compared to CD4+ T cells, which is in line with previous published data (Lozano E. Clin. Cancer Res. 2020). In contrast, DNAM-1 was expressed on CD8+ T, NK and NKT cells with prominent high expression on CD4+ T cells (Fig 1A). The highest expression among the receptors was of PVRIG on all lymphoid populations, except CD4+ where DNAM-1 was more highly expressed. Importantly, 50% of CD8+ T cells co-expressed TIGIT and PVRIG, supporting a combinatorial therapeutic approach (Fig. 1B). Additionally, the expression of the PVRL2 ligand on MM plasma and endothelial cells was demonstrated by IHC. FACS analysis further supported PVRL2 expression on plasma cells in MM BM (Fig 2). A higher expression of PVRIG, TIGIT and PD-1 was present on DNAM-1 negative CD8+ T cells (Fig 3A, B), suggesting accumulation of exhausted cells in MM tumor microenvironment (TME) as previously described (Minnie S., Blood. 2018). PVRIG had significantly higher expression on DNAM+ cells, compared to PD-1 and TIGIT (Fig 3C), suggesting the potential of its blockade to enhance DNAM-1 activation and subsequent proliferation of earlier differentiated memory cells in MM TME. Finally, CR patients had a trend for higher DNAM-1 expression on CD8+ T cells compared to those with PD (Fig 3D). This is consistent with other reports in mice showing that the expression of DNAM-1 negatively correlates with BM myeloma cell numbers (Minnie S., Blood. 2018). Conclusions DNAM-1 axis receptors are dominantly expressed on lymphocytes in BM of MM patients, with PVRIG exhibiting the most prominent expression. The reduced expression of DNAM-1 in PD patients' TME, compared to CR patients, suggests a link between DNAM-1 axis and clinical outcomes. Recent data suggest TIGIT is an attractive target for blockade in MM. Our new findings highlight for the first time the dominant expression of PVRIG, as well as TIGIT, and suggest that combined blockade of TIGIT with PVRIG may potentially benefit MM patients, placing the DNAM-1 axis as a dominant pathway in MM therapy. Figure 1 Figure 1. Disclosures Frenkel: Compugen Ltd.: Current Employment, Other: in the event of frontal participation, I will be reimbursed for my travel expenses by Compugen Ltd.. Alteber: Compugen Ltd.: Current Employment. Cojocaru: Compugen Ltd.: Current Employment. Ophir: Compugen Ltd.: Current Employment.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document