scholarly journals Does Data Availability Constrain Temperature-Index Snow Models? A Case Study in a Humid Boreal Forest

Water ◽  
2020 ◽  
Vol 12 (8) ◽  
pp. 2284
Author(s):  
Achut Parajuli ◽  
Daniel F. Nadeau ◽  
François Anctil ◽  
Oliver S. Schilling ◽  
Sylvain Jutras
Keyword(s):  
Surface Temperature ◽  
Snow Water Equivalent ◽  
Predictive Ability ◽  
Data Availability ◽  
Snow Surface ◽  
Canopy Interception ◽  
Eastern Canada ◽  
Temperature Index ◽  
Snow Surface Temperature ◽  
Snow Water

Temperature-index (TI) models are commonly used to simulate the volume and occurrence of meltwater in snow-fed catchments. TI models have varying levels of complexity but are all based on air temperature observations. The quality and availability of data that drive these models affect their predictive ability, particularly given that they are frequently applied in remote environments. This study investigates the performance of non-calibrated TI models in simulating the subcanopy snow water equivalent (SWE) of a small watershed located in Eastern Canada, for which some distinctive observations were collected. Among three relatively simple TI algorithms, the model that performed the best was selected based on the average percent bias (Pbias of 24%) and root mean square error (RMSE of 100 mm w.e.), and was designated as the base TI model. Then, a series of supplemental tests were conducted in order to quantify the performance gain that resulted from including the following inputs/processes to the base TI model: subcanopy incoming radiation, canopy interception, snow surface temperature, sublimation, and cold content. As a final test, all the above modifications were performed simultaneously. Our results reveal that, with the exception of snow sublimation (Pbias of 5.4%) and snow surface temperature, the variables mentioned above were unable to improve TI models within our sites. It is therefore worth exploring other feasible alternatives to existing TI models in complex forested environments.

scholarly journals Modeling the snow surface temperature with a one-layer energy balance snowmelt model

2013 ◽  
Vol 10 (12) ◽  
pp. 15071-15118 ◽  
Author(s):  
J. You ◽  
D. G. Tarboton ◽  
C. H. Luce
Keyword(s):  
Energy Balance ◽  
Surface Temperature ◽  
Snow Water Equivalent ◽  
Effective Conductivity ◽  
Energy Content ◽  
Single Layer ◽  
Conductive Heat ◽  
Snow Surface ◽  
Snow Surface Temperature ◽  
Snowmelt Model

Abstract. \\label{sec:abstract} Snow surface temperature is a key control on energy exchanges at the snow surface, particularly net longwave radiation and turbulent energy fluxes. The snow surface temperature is in turn controlled by the balance between various external fluxes and the conductive heat flux, internal to the snowpack. Because of the strong insulating properties of snow, thermal gradients in snow packs are large and nonlinear, a fact that has led many to advocate multiple layer snowmelt models over single layer models. In an effort to keep snowmelt modeling simple and parsimonious, the Utah Energy Balance (UEB) snowmelt model used only one layer but allowed the snow surface temperature to be different from the snow average temperature by using an equilibrium gradient parameterization based on the surface energy balance. Although this procedure was considered an improvement over the ordinary single layer snowmelt models, it still resulted in discrepancies between modeled and measured snowpack energy contents. In this paper we examine the parameterization of snow surface temperature in single layer snowmelt models from the perspective of heat conduction into a semi-infinite medium. We evaluate the equilibrium gradient approach, the force-restore approach, and a modified force-restore approach. In addition, we evaluate a scheme for representing the penetration of a refreezing front in cold periods following melt. We also introduce a method to adjust effective conductivity to account for the presence of ground near to a shallow snow surface. These parameterizations were tested against data from the Central Sierra Snow Laboratory, CA, Utah State University experimental farm, UT, and Subnivean snow laboratory at Niwot Ridge, CO. These tests compare modeled and measured snow surface temperature, snow energy content, snow water equivalent, and snowmelt outflow. We found that with these refinements the model is able to better represent the snowpack energy balance and internal energy content while still retaining a parsimonious one layer format.

scholarly journals Modeling the snow surface temperature with a one-layer energy balance snowmelt model

2014 ◽  
Vol 18 (12) ◽  
pp. 5061-5076 ◽  
Author(s):  
J. You ◽  
D. G. Tarboton ◽  
C. H. Luce
Keyword(s):  
Energy Balance ◽  
Surface Temperature ◽  
Snow Water Equivalent ◽  
Effective Conductivity ◽  
Energy Content ◽  
Single Layer ◽  
Snow Surface ◽  
Snow Surface Temperature ◽  
Energy Exchanges ◽  
Snowmelt Model

Abstract. Snow surface temperature is a key control on and result of dynamically coupled energy exchanges at the snow surface. The snow surface temperature is the result of the balance between external forcing (incoming radiation) and energy exchanges above the surface that depend on surface temperature (outgoing longwave radiation and turbulent fluxes) and the transport of energy into the snow by conduction and meltwater influx. Because of the strong insulating properties of snow, thermal gradients in snow packs are large and nonlinear, a fact that has led many to advocate multiple layer snowmelt models over single layer models. In an effort to keep snowmelt modeling simple and parsimonious, the Utah Energy Balance (UEB) snowmelt model used only one layer but allowed the snow surface temperature to be different from the snow average temperature by using an equilibrium gradient parameterization based on the surface energy balance. Although this procedure was considered an improvement over the ordinary single layer snowmelt models, it still resulted in discrepancies between modeled and measured snowpack energy contents. In this paper we evaluate the equilibrium gradient approach, the force-restore approach, and a modified force-restore approach when they are integrated as part of a complete energy and mass balance snowmelt model. The force-restore and modified force-restore approaches have not been incorporated into the UEB in early versions, even though Luce and Tartoton have done work in calculating the energy components using these approaches. In addition, we evaluate a scheme for representing the penetration of a refreezing front in cold periods following melt. We introduce a method to adjust effective conductivity to account for the presence of ground near to a shallow snow surface. These parameterizations were tested against data from the Central Sierra Snow Laboratory, CA, Utah State University experimental farm, UT, and subnivean snow laboratory at Niwot Ridge, CO. These tests compare modeled and measured snow surface temperature, snow energy content, snow water equivalent, and snowmelt outflow. We found that with these refinements the model is able to better represent the snowpack energy balance and internal energy content while still retaining a parsimonious one layer format.

scholarly journals Evaluation of alternative formulae for calculation of surface temperature in snowmelt models using frequency analysis of temperature observations

2009 ◽  
Vol 6 (3) ◽  
pp. 3863-3890 ◽  
Author(s):  
C. H. Luce ◽  
D. G. Tarboton
Keyword(s):  
Time Series ◽  
Energy Balance ◽  
Surface Temperature ◽  
Energy Flux ◽  
Frequency Analysis ◽  
Energy Content ◽  
Balance Model ◽  
Snow Surface ◽  
Fourier Frequency ◽  
Snow Surface Temperature

Abstract. The snow surface temperature is an important quantity in the snow energy balance, since it modulates the exchange of energy between the surface and the atmosphere as well as the conduction of energy into the snowpack. It is therefore important to correctly model snow surface temperatures in energy balance snowmelt models. This paper focuses on the relationship between snow surface temperature and conductive energy fluxed that drive the energy balance of a snowpack. Time series of snow temperature at the surface and through the snowpack were measured to examine energy conduction in a snowpack. Based on these measurements we calculated the snowpack energy content and conductive energy flux at the snow surface. We then used these estimates of conductive energy flux to evaluate formulae for the calculation of the conductive flux at the snow surface based on surface temperature time series. We use a method based on Fourier frequency analysis to estimate snow thermal properties. Among the formulae evaluated, we found that a modified force-restore formula, based on the superimposition of the force-restore equation capturing diurnal fluctuations on a gradually changing temperature gradient, had the best agreement with observations of heat conduction. This formula is suggested for the parameterization of snow surface temperature in a full snowpack energy balance model.

scholarly journals Improving the snow physics of WEB-DHM and its point evaluation at two SnowMIP alpine sites

2010 ◽  
Vol 7 (3) ◽  
pp. 3481-3519 ◽  
Author(s):  
M. Shrestha ◽  
L. Wang ◽  
T. Koike ◽  
Y. Xue ◽  
Y. Hirabayashi
Keyword(s):  
Surface Temperature ◽  
Liquid Water ◽  
Snow Depth ◽  
Hydrological Model ◽  
Snow Water Equivalent ◽  
Bias Error ◽  
Snow Albedo ◽  
Basin Scale ◽  
Snow Water ◽  
Snow Physics

Abstract. The snow physics of a distributed biosphere hydrological model, referred to as the Water and Energy Budget based Distributed Hydrological Model (WEB-DHM) is improved by incorporating the three-layer physically based energy balance snowmelt model of Simplified Simple Biosphere 3 (SSiB3) and the Biosphere-Atmosphere Transfer Scheme (BATS) albedo scheme. WEB-DHM with improved snow physics (WEB-DHM-S) can simulate the variability of snow density, snow depth and snow water equivalent, liquid water and ice content in each layer, prognostic snow albedo, diurnal variation in snow surface temperature, thermal heat due to conduction and liquid water retention. The performance of WEB-DHM-S is evaluated at two alpine sites of the Snow Model Intercomparison Project with different climate characteristics: Col de Porte in France and Weissfluhjoch in Switzerland. The simulation results of the snow depth, snow water equivalent, surface temperature, snow albedo and snowmelt runoff reveal that WEB-DHM-S is capable of simulating the internal snow process better than the original WEB-DHM, with the root mean square error and bias error being remarkably reduced. Although WEB-DHM-S is only evaluated at a point scale for the simulation of snow processes, this study provides a benchmark for the application of WEB-DHM-S in cold regions in the assessment of the basin-scale snow water equivalent and seasonal discharge simulation for water resources management.

scholarly journals The influence of the forest on night-time snow surface temperature

2001 ◽  
Vol 32 ◽  
pp. 217-222 ◽  
Author(s):  
Peter Höller
Keyword(s):  
Surface Temperature ◽  
Open Field ◽  
Air Temperature ◽  
Forest Canopy ◽  
Small Range ◽  
Snow Surface ◽  
Net Radiation ◽  
Night Time ◽  
Near Surface ◽  
Snow Surface Temperature

AbstractSnow surface temperature (Ts) plays an important role in the formation of surface hoar or near-surface faceted crystals The goal of this study was to obtain detailed information on Ts in different forest stands nelr the timberline. The investigations were conducted during clear nights and showed that the snow surface temperature is influenced very strongly by the forest canopy. While the air temperature was very similar on the different experimental sites, Ts was higher in the forest than in the open field; on the south-facing slope the difference between the forest and the open field was 3–4.5°C, and on the north-facing slope approximately 3–7°C. Taking into account that εair is 0.7 and εtree is 0.94, the incoming radiation (I ↓) for the different experimental sites was calculated by the equation of Brunt (the canopy density was estimated using photographs taken with an 8 mm fish-eye). To calculate Ts, air temperature and averaged values of the net radiation (because the net radiation (I) has only a small range of variation during clear nights) were used. The results show that the calculated values were higher than the measured values (by approximately 2°C). However, a better correlation was found by using lower values of the emissivity (εair0.67 and εtree0.91).

scholarly journals Homogenisation of a gridded snow water equivalent climatology for Alpine terrain: methodology and applications

2014 ◽  
Vol 8 (2) ◽  
pp. 471-485 ◽  
Author(s):  
S. Jörg-Hess ◽  
F. Fundel ◽  
T. Jonas ◽  
M. Zappa
Keyword(s):  
Land Surface ◽  
Snow Water Equivalent ◽  
Winter Season ◽  
Data Availability ◽  
Model Systems ◽  
Added Value ◽  
Data Sets ◽  
Atmospheric Models ◽  
Catchment Areas ◽  
Snow Water

Abstract. Gridded snow water equivalent (SWE) data sets are valuable for estimating the snow water resources and verify different model systems, e.g. hydrological, land surface or atmospheric models. However, changing data availability represents a considerable challenge when trying to derive consistent time series for SWE products. In an attempt to improve the product consistency, we first evaluated the differences between two climatologies of SWE grids that were calculated on the basis of data from 110 and 203 stations, respectively. The "shorter" climatology (2001–2009) was produced using 203 stations (map203) and the "longer" one (1971–2009) 110 stations (map110). Relative to map203, map110 underestimated SWE, especially at higher elevations and at the end of the winter season. We tested the potential of quantile mapping to compensate for mapping errors in map110 relative to map203. During a 9 yr calibration period from 2001 to 2009, for which both map203 and map110 were available, the method could successfully refine the spatial and temporal SWE representation in map110 by making seasonal, regional and altitude-related distinctions. Expanding the calibration to the full 39 yr showed that the general underestimation of map110 with respect to map203 could be removed for the whole winter. The calibrated SWE maps fitted the reference (map203) well when averaged over regions and time periods, where the mean error is approximately zero. However, deviations between the calibrated maps and map203 were observed at single grid cells and years. When we looked at three different regions in more detail, we found that the calibration had the largest effect in the region with the highest proportion of catchment areas above 2000 m a.s.l. and that the general underestimation of map110 compared to map203 could be removed for the entire snow season. The added value of the calibrated SWE climatology is illustrated with practical examples: the verification of a hydrological model, the estimation of snow resource anomalies and the predictability of runoff through SWE.

scholarly journals Evaluation of alternative formulae for calculation of surface temperature in snowmelt models using frequency analysis of temperature observations

2010 ◽  
Vol 14 (3) ◽  
pp. 535-543 ◽  
Author(s):  
C. H. Luce ◽  
D. G. Tarboton
Keyword(s):  
Time Series ◽  
Energy Balance ◽  
Surface Temperature ◽  
Energy Flux ◽  
Frequency Analysis ◽  
Energy Content ◽  
Balance Model ◽  
Snow Surface ◽  
Fourier Frequency ◽  
Snow Surface Temperature

Abstract. The snow surface temperature is an important quantity in the snow energy balance, since it modulates the exchange of energy between the surface and the atmosphere as well as the conduction of energy into the snowpack. It is therefore important to correctly model snow surface temperatures in energy balance snowmelt models. This paper focuses on the relationship between snow surface temperature and conductive energy fluxes that drive the energy balance of a snowpack. Time series of snow temperature at the surface and through the snowpack were measured to examine energy conduction in a snowpack. Based on these measurements we calculated the snowpack energy content and conductive energy flux at the snow surface. We then used these estimates of conductive energy flux to evaluate formulae for the calculation of the conductive flux at the snow surface based on surface temperature time series. We use a method based on Fourier frequency analysis to estimate snow thermal properties. Among the formulae evaluated, we found that a modified force-restore formula, based on the superimposition of the force-restore equation capturing diurnal fluctuations on a gradually changing temperature gradient, had the best agreement with observations of heat conduction. This formula is suggested for the parameterization of snow surface temperature in a full snowpack energy balance model.

scholarly journals Evaluation of CLASS Snow Simulation over Eastern Canada

2017 ◽  
Vol 18 (5) ◽  
pp. 1205-1225 ◽  
Author(s):  
Diana Verseghy ◽  
Ross Brown ◽  
Libo Wang
Keyword(s):  
Snow Cover ◽  
Land Surface ◽  
Snow Water Equivalent ◽  
Climate Model ◽  
Regional Climate ◽  
Eastern Canada ◽  
Fractional Snow Cover ◽  
Forest Regions ◽  
Snow Water ◽  
Snow Model

Abstract The Canadian Land Surface Scheme (CLASS), version 3.6.1, was run offline for the period 1990–2011 over a domain centered on eastern Canada, driven by atmospheric forcing data dynamically downscaled from ERA-Interim using the Canadian Regional Climate Model. The precipitation inputs were adjusted to replicate the monthly average precipitation reported in the CRU observational database. The simulated fractional snow cover and the surface albedo were evaluated using NOAA Interactive Multisensor Snow and Ice Mapping System and MODIS data, and the snow water equivalent was evaluated using CMC, Global Snow Monitoring for Climate Research (GlobSnow), and Hydro-Québec products. The modeled fractional snow cover agreed well with the observational estimates. The albedo of snow-covered areas showed a bias of up to −0.15 in boreal forest regions, owing to neglect of subgrid-scale lakes in the simulation. In June, conversely, there was a positive albedo bias in the remaining snow-covered areas, likely caused by neglect of impurities in the snow. The validation of the snow water equivalent was complicated by the fact that the three observation-based datasets differed widely. Also, the downward adjustment of the forcing precipitation clearly resulted in a low snow bias in some regions. However, where the density of the observations was high, the CLASS snow model was deemed to have performed well. Sensitivity tests confirmed the satisfactory behavior of the current parameterizations of snow thermal conductivity, snow albedo refreshment threshold, and limiting snow depth and underlined the importance of snow interception by vegetation. Overall, the study demonstrated the necessity of using a wide variety of observation-based datasets for model validation.

scholarly journals Daytime preservation of surface-hoar crystals

1998 ◽  
Vol 26 ◽  
pp. 22-26 ◽  
Author(s):  
Akihiro Hachikubo ◽  
Eizi Akitaya
Keyword(s):  
Shear Strength ◽  
Surface Layer ◽  
Relative Humidity ◽  
Solar Radiation ◽  
Surface Temperature ◽  
Snow Surface ◽  
Previous Night ◽  
Snow Surface Temperature ◽  
Transfer Method

Surface hoar growing for several clear and humid days were observed. During daytime, air and snow-surface temperature increased and relative humidity decreased, hence evaporation (sublimation) occurred at the snow surface. The amount of evaporation calculated using a bulk-transfer method suggests that the surface-hoar crystals which grew during the previous night should have disappeared but they were observed to survive on the snow surface even during the daytime. During the following night, new surface-hoar crystals formed on top of the older ones and grew even larger. This result indicates that, although the surface-hoar crystals evaporated into the air during the daytime, snow grains beneath the surface were warmed by solar radiation and evaporated to the air. They may partially condense into the surface-hoar crystals and make up for the reduction in size. Depth-hoar crystals formed beneath the snow surface for several days and the surface layer, composed of both types of hoar crystal, showed a very weak shear strength.

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document