Weird Molecules, Inconceivable Microbes, and Unlikely Environmental Proxies: Marine Ecology Revised
Anaerobic methanotrophs are not the only ecologically important archaea to surprise microbiologists in the last decade. And their isoprenoid ethers are not the only useful lipids—and certainly not the strangest—to have joined the lexicon of microbial biomarkers. Though much of that lexicon is still too generic to be of much use in understanding geologic history, some of these structures have allowed geochemists to transcend biological complexity and garner clues to past climates and environments. In the 1990s, when Stefan Schouten first started finding ring-containing biphytanyl ethers in his sediment samples, he was still working on his doctorate at NIOZ. Like everyone else at the time, he assumed that they derived from the lipids of methanogenic archaea and that it was only a matter of time before ring-containing biphytanyl tetraethers would be identified among the lipids of some newly isolated culture of methanogens, as Guy Ourisson had predicted. Schouten was studying oxygen- and sulfur-bound biomarkers, which meant he treated his sediment extracts chemically to cleave the ether and sulfur bonds, and the treatments often turned up biphytanes. But then, he says, he and another student started finding the ring-containing compounds in some really unlikely places, such as the oxic surface layer of marine sediments where neither methanogens nor extreme thermophilic and halophilic archaea were likely to make a home. The only thing they could think of at the time was that the tetraethers had come from methanogens that lived in the oxygen minimum zone, the layer of water beneath the photic zone where heterotrophic bacteria are active, sometimes to the point of using up all of the oxygen. When Schouten presented these ideas at the 1995 organic geochemistry meeting, Stuart Wakeham immediately piped up with the suggestion that they look for the lipids in the water column—and offered the perfect samples for the enterprise. He had collected particulate matter at different depths in the Black Sea and Cariaco Basin, just the sort of anoxic environments where one might expect to find methanogens in the water column. . . .