Evaluating the Effect of Natural Third Body Layers on Friction Using the Virginia Tech Roller Rig

Author(s):  
Ahmad Radmehr ◽  
Karan Kothari ◽  
Mehdi Ahmadian

In this study, the effect of natural third body layers on the coefficient of friction and contact forces is evaluated using the Virginia Tech-Federal Railroad Administration (VT-FRA) roller rig facility. The test rig allows us to precisely control the contacting surfaces to study its effect on the wheel-rail interface forces and moments. Experiments have shown while running the tests, a slight amount of wear occurs at the running surfaces. The worn material deposits at the surface and behaves like a “natural” third-body layer at the contact, resulting in changes in traction coefficient and creep forces. The material wear and its accumulation on the running surfaces change with wheel longitudinal load and creepage. A series of organized time-based experiments have been conducted with the running surfaces cleaned at the beginning of the test to study the effect of material wear accumulation on selected parameters including traction coefficient and creep forces over time. In order to highlight the effect of the natural third body layer on the wheel-rail contact forces, a series of experiments were conducted, in which the wheel and roller surfaces were cleaned in one case and left uncleaned in another. The results of the experiments are quite revealing. They indicate that when the running surfaces are cleaned after each test, the maximum creep force (or adhesion) is far lower than when the running surfaces are not cleaned, i.e., the natural third-body layer is allowed to accumulate at the surfaces. The results indicate that the wear debris act as a friction enhancer rather than a friction reducer.

Author(s):  
Ahmad Radmehr ◽  
Arash Hosseinian Ahangarnejad ◽  
Ali Tajaddini ◽  
Mehdi Ahmadian

Abstract The surface profile wear and the resulting third-body layer accumulation are investigated on the Virginia Tech-Federal Railroad Administration Roller Rig (VT-FRA Roller Rig), using a high-precision 3D laser profiler by Keyence. It is observed that the wheel surface gradually wears and the fine worn material accumulates on the running surfaces. It is further observed that with the progression of the wear and accumulation of a powder-like material at running surface, a preocular change in wheel-rail traction occurs. The first step in exploring the physics of the changes in traction is quantifying, precisely, the micron-sized surface finish changes and wear material accumulation. This paper provides the process of choosing a suitable surface profiler for the VT-FRA roller rig adaptation, and the results of a series of tests under various wheel load and contact configurations. A baseline experiment is conducted to evaluate the wheel wear and the accumulation of the naturally-generated third body layer (the worn material) on the wheel’s running surface. Before each series of experiments, the wheel and roller running surfaces were polished and thoroughly cleaned to make sure that they are perfectly smooth (finished) and free of any debris or dust. The wheel surface profile is measured in the perfectly cleaned condition using the 3D laser scanner. Time controlled experiments are run with different wheel loads, % slippage, and angle of attack (AoA) for 500 seconds. For each run, the change with surface finish and accumulated third body layer build up is measured. It is consistently observed that the traction forces increase gradually with time until they reach a stable level, presented by a plateau in the traction-slippage curves. The time to reach the plateau is directly related to wheel’s dynamic conditions including load, %slippage, and AOA. For some of the conditions, such as wheel load, the relationship is linear and for others (such as AOA) it is nonlinear. Concentrating on the analysis of the baseline results, it is observed that the change in surface finish and the third body layer that naturally accumulates at the running surface — hence, referred to as “natural third body layer” or “NTBL” — is directly correlated and somewhat linearly with NTBL and change in the running surface from smooth to rough. The correlation is most noticeable for the NTBL. With increasing NTBL, traction increases rapidly until the running surface is saturated with the accumulated wear material, presumably a ferrous oxide. There is far weaker correlation between the change in surface finish and traction variations. It is noticed that the surface finish continues to change beyond the time that the traction forces reach their plateau, and its effect remains far more gradual than NTBL.


Author(s):  
Ahmad Radmehr ◽  
Ali Tajaddini ◽  
Brian Marquis ◽  
Mehdi Ahmadian

A detailed description of the Virginia Tech-Federal Railroad Administration (VT-FRA) Roller Rig measurement capabilities, along with the efforts in establishing the accuracy, repeatability, and integrity of the results are presented. The results of a series of baseline tests are also documented in an effort to provide an indication of the type of experiments that can be achieved on the rig. The one-fourth scaled rig is intended to be used for evaluating wheel-rail contact mechanics and dynamics with a high degree of precision. The rail is represented by a roller with a diameter that is five times larger than the wheel, in order to maintain the contact ellipse distortion to less than 10 percent. The primary point of differentiation between this rig and others that have been used in the past or are presently in use is that it is able to measure the wheel-rail contact forces with far greater precision than achieved in the past. The rig is also designed such that it provides a high degree of repeatability in testing, often needed for performing design of experiments accurately. The VT-FRA rig is capable of precisely controlling the lateral positioning of the wheel and rail, rail cant angle, the wheel-rail angle of attack, and the speed of the roller and wheel independently. The latter is intended to provide precise control of the relative speed of the wheel and roller, which amounts to precisely controlling creepage. Beyond presenting the rig’s capabilities, the paper provides a discussion of the initial results from the commissioning of the rig. It is concluded that the rig is ready to be commissioned for studies that are of interest to the practitioners in the rail industry and scientists in the research community.


Author(s):  
S. V. Tankeev ◽  
◽  
A. E. Kolodin ◽  
V. B. Sverdlov ◽  
A. V. Nazarov ◽  
...  

The damage assessment of freight cars during shunting and loading and unloading operations was made. The need to review the normative documents regulating the relationship between the owners of rolling stock, owners of non-public tracks and the carrier is noted. The reasons for formation of damage on the wheel pairs of freight cars when disbanding on low-power sorting slides are considered. The conditions for ensuring the deceleration of detachments on non-mechanized sorting slides without damaging the wheels are determined. The analysis of methods for ensuring braking on low-power slides is carried out. A method was chosen to ensure the wheel set rotation by introducing a third body between the rubbing surfaces during the braking of cars, which will take over a part of the resulting heat flow, reducing the temperature and increasing the coefficient of friction in the «wheel-rail» contact zone. A method is proposed to provide braking on the non-mechanized sorting slide during shoe braking by applying a friction compound to a non-working rail. Laboratory tests were carried out, which showed that the introduction of a friction additive can achieve the necessary coefficient of friction to comply with the standard parameters of deceleration of the car in the braking zone.


2019 ◽  
Vol 821 ◽  
pp. 321-326
Author(s):  
Olusoji Oluremi Ayodele ◽  
Mary Ajimegoh Awotunde ◽  
Mxolisi Brendon Shongwe ◽  
Adewale Oladapo Adegbenjo ◽  
Bukola J. Babalola ◽  
...  

Ti6Al4V alloy was consolidated by hybrid spark plasma sintering at a temperature of 1200 °C, pressure of 50 MPa, holding time of 5 min and heating rate of 100 °C/min. This resulted in the maximum value of sintered density. Microstructural evolutions of the sintered compact were analysed with SEM. Sliding wear test were accomplished at different sliding loads of 5, 8 and 10 N using ball on disc tribometer configuration with stainless steel as the counterface material. Wear debris obtained was found to contain mostly the sintered materials with minute traces of the counterface material. The coefficient of friction reaches the maximum with increase in applied load. Worn surface analyses revealed the wear mechanism was abrasive. The potentiodynamic polarisation of the sintered compact showed the sintered compact in 0.9 wt % NaCl solution exhibited more resistance to corrosion.


Author(s):  
Sajjad Z. Meymand ◽  
Milad Hosseinipour ◽  
Mehdi Ahmadian

This paper discusses the development of a state of the art single-wheel roller rig for studying contact mechanics and dynamics in railroad applications. The use of indoor-based simulation tools has become a mainstay in vehicle testing for the automotive and railroad industries. In contrast to field-testing, roller rigs offer a controlled laboratory environment that can provide a successful path for obtaining data on the mechanics and dynamics of railway systems for a variety of operating conditions. The idea to develop a laboratory test rig started from the observation that there is a need for better-developed testing fixtures capable of accurately explaining the relatively unknown physics of the wheel-rail contact mechanics and dynamics. Developing a better understanding of such physics would assist with designing faster, safer, and more efficient railroad systems. A review of the existing roller rigs indicated that many desired functional requirements for studying contact mechanics are not readily available. The Virginia Tech Railway Technologies Laboratory (RTL) has embarked on a mission to develop a state-of-the-art testing facility that will allow experimental testing for contact mechanics in a dynamic, controlled, and consistent manner. The VT roller rig is intended to allow for actively controlling all the wheel-rail interface degrees of freedom: cant angle, angle of attack, and lateral displacement. Two AC synchronous servomotors, accompanied with proper gearheads, accurately drive the rotating wheels. A novel force measurement system, suitable for steel on steel contact, is configured to precisely measure the contact forces and torques. The control architecture is developed based on the SynqNet data acquisition system offered by Kollmorgen, the drive-motor and actuator supplier. The Synqnet provides a unified communication protocol between actuators, drives, and data acquisition system; therefore eliminating any difficulty with data conversion among these units. Other auxiliary sensors and measurement systems are implemented to help with characterizing the contact mechanics and contact geometry. This paper will describe the main steps in the design process of the VT roller rig and the final design solution selected. It will also present the testing capabilities of the rig. The design analysis indicates that the rig can successfully meet the set requirements: additional accuracy in measurements, and better control on the design of experiments.


1974 ◽  
Vol 96 (3) ◽  
pp. 931-935
Author(s):  
T. R. Robe ◽  
S. E. Jones

An analytical solution is developed for the tapered arbor spring slip clutch by introducing approximations that do not appreciably affect the accuracy of the important clutch quantities. In addition, the influence of the coefficient of friction on the output torque, the axial force on the spring coil, and the radial contact forces alongthe tapered arbor are shown.


2016 ◽  
Vol 2016 ◽  
pp. 1-10 ◽  
Author(s):  
Jens Wahlström

Airborne particulate emissions originating from the wear of pads and rotors of disc brakes contribute up to 50% of the total road emissions in Europe. The wear process that takes place on a mesoscopic length scale in the contact interfaces between the pads and rotors can be explained by the creation and destruction of contact plateaus. Due to this complex contact situation, it is hard to predict how changes in the wear and material parameters of the pad friction material will affect the friction and wear emissions. This paper reports on an investigation of the effect of different parameters of the pad friction material on the coefficient of friction and wear emissions. A full factorial design is developed using a simplified version of a previously developed cellular automaton approach to investigate the effect of four factors on the coefficient of friction and wear emission. The simulated result indicates that a stable third body, a high specific wear, and a relatively high amount of metal fibres yield a high and stable mean coefficient of friction, while a stable third body, a low specific wear, a stable resin, and a relatively high amount of metal fibres give low wear emissions.


2021 ◽  
Vol 88 (6) ◽  
Author(s):  
Alejandro Roda-Buch ◽  
Valentine A. M. Magnin ◽  
Sandra Guadalupe Maldonado ◽  
Stefano Mischler

Abstract The lubrication regimes of a contact pair escapement-ruby pallet of a Swiss lever escapement have been investigated combining the theory of fluid lubrication with a well-established kinematic and inverse dynamic multibody model. The kinematic analytical results have been confronted with experimental measurements. The developed model allows to easily obtain, for the three operating phases of the Swiss lever escapement, the relative speed and the contact forces and, by considering a hydrodynamic lubrication regime, the lubricant minimum film thickness and the coefficient of friction. The presented formulation allows to study the influence of crucial technical parameters in the Swiss lever escapement lubrication. The spout radii of curvature have been identified as the optimal parameters to control the lubrication regimes in the pallet/escapement contacts. In that sense, an interesting result is that the lubrication regime moves away from the boundary lubrication by increasing these radii.


2018 ◽  
Vol 2018 ◽  
pp. 1-11 ◽  
Author(s):  
Nicola Bosso ◽  
Nicolò Zampieri

The study of railway dynamic strongly depends on the estimation of the tangential forces acting between wheel and rail. Simulation of the dynamical behaviour of railway vehicles is often performed using multibody codes, and the calculation of the contact forces must be efficient and accurate, even if the contact problem is strongly nonlinear. Therefore, the contact problem is still of great interest for researchers. This work proposes an analytical and efficient algorithm to calculate wheel-rail tangential forces. The proposed method is compared with the most commonly used algorithms under different conditions. In addition, experimental tests are performed on a scaled prototype on roller-rig to demonstrate that the method can be easily adjusted using experimental results. The benefit of the proposed method is to provide an analytical and fast solution, able to obtain accurate results and to allow corrections based on empirical evidence.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document