Syntactic and semantic data: replication results
Keyword(s):
Substantially all recent work in syntax and semantics is based on the linguist's introspective judgments of meaning and grammaticality. As is well known (cf. Labov 1972: 197ff.), other linguists often disagree with the original judgments; and such disagreements are, if anything, more common on examples of major theoretical importance. These disagreements cast doubt on introspection as a primary method for data collection, which in turn casts doubt on all the recent theoretical work using this methodology. It is therefore a crucial problem to develop an improved methodology to control or replace the use of the linguist's introspection.
1990 ◽
Vol 55
(12)
◽
pp. 2889-2897
1992 ◽
Vol 128
◽
pp. 56-77
◽
Keyword(s):
1996 ◽
Vol 10
(08)
◽
pp. 863-955
◽
Keyword(s):
2019 ◽
Keyword(s):
2002 ◽
Vol 2
(5-6)
◽
pp. 41-46
◽