EMPLOYEE LOYALTY IN RELATION TO THE WHISTLEBLOWER DIRECTIVE
The whistleblower protection directive may have a significant impact on the essence of understanding employee loyalty in employment relationships. In this paper I argue that the possibility of whistleblowing does not contradict employee duties as expressed in Article 100 § 2 section 4 of the Labor Code. In my opinion, the thesis should be put forward that the employee’s duty of loyalty is limited to the employer’s lawful actions. It would be unacceptable to state that the employment relationship restricts the employee’s freedom of speech in the sense that it prohibits the employee from opposing the employer’s unlawful conduct. Moreover, in my view, the employee’s duty of loyalty should be interpreted in such a way that it is horizontal in nature. This is because it refers to business relations between market entities. The doctrine and judicature extensively describe breaches of the duty of loyalty by employees in the context of horizontal relationships, relating to other market players, particularly those engaged in competitive activity (the unit-unit relationship). In contrast, the provisions of the Directive on the protection of whistleblowers are vertical standards, relating to the relationship between the individual and the state (public interest). Thus, in my view, the duty of loyalty to the employer cannot outweigh the possibility of acting in the public interest, which is emanated by the provisions of the Directive.