Exploring students’ procedural flexibility in three countries

Background In this cross-national study, Spanish, Finnish, and Swedish middle and high school students’ procedural flexibility was examined, with the specific intent of determining whether and how students’ equation-solving accuracy and flexibility varied by country, age, and/or academic track. The 791 student participants were asked to solve twelve linear equations, provide multiple strategies for each equation, and select the best strategy from among their own strategies. Results Our results indicate that knowledge and use of the standard algorithm for solving linear equations is quite widespread across students in all three countries, but that there exists substantial within-country variation as well as between-country variation in students’ reliance on standard vs. situationally appropriate strategies. In addition, we found correlations between equation-solving accuracy and students’ flexibility in all three countries but to different degrees. Conclusions Although it is increasingly recognized as an important construct of interest, there are many aspects of mathematical flexibility that are not well-understood. Particularly lacking in the literature on flexibility are studies that explore similarities and differences in students’ repertoire of strategies for solving algebra problems across countries with different educational systems and curricula. This study yielded important insights about flexibility and can push the field to explore the extent that within- and between-country differences in flexibility can be linked to differences in countries’ educational systems, teaching practices, and/or cultural norms around mathematics teaching and learning.

Social background and school track choice: An analysis informed by the rational choice framework

We investigate social inequalities based on social background in the choice of the academic track among equally performing students, and how indicators derived from the rational choice framework contribute to account for such inequalities. We discuss the main theoretical concepts underpinning rational choice theory as applied to educational decisions: perceived costs, benefits, and risks of failure; relative risk aversion; and time-discounting preferences. In the empirical section, we use a unique dataset concerning the transition to different tracks in upper secondary school in a large Southern Italian region. By using various regression methods and the Karlson/Holm/Breen decomposition technique, we show that social inequalities in access to the academic track are considerable, even in recent cohorts, and that they are largely not explained by previous academic performance. Indicators linked to key concepts proposed by the rational choice theory—as measured in this study—account, as a whole, for 31% of the gap based on parental education, and for 40% of the gap based on parental occupation. The most important sources of inequalities among those this study examines are the expected benefits associated with the educational alternatives and the time-discounting preferences, while relative risk aversion and the perceived chances of success play negligible roles.

Fellow As Clinical Teacher, Benign Hematology Curriculum Improves Learning and Reaction to Academic Medicine

Introduction: The expansion of medical schools, faculty attrition, and trainees' disinterest in academia, all highlight the need to encourage the next generation of academic physicians. The published literature indicates that early academic career awareness and involvement in scholarship activities can positively influence trainees' interest in academia. Teaching experience has been shown to positively influence interest in an academic career, trainees who can engage in educational activities, and who transform their work into educational scholarship are more likely than their counterparts to pursue the medical educator academic track. We hypothesized that heightening diverse trainees' awareness of opportunities to engage in various educational roles through the fellow as clinical teacher (FACT) may help them consider future academic positions as well as improve their medical knowledge. Method: We implemented a hematology FACT program that utilized an hour didactics session that is held every month focused on benign hematology curriculum. We aimed to help fellows to 1) develop as teachers, 2) improve knowledge in benign hematology, and 3) increase their career interest in educators' academic track. After implementing the program, post-intervention surveys focusing on evaluating their reaction to the program, whether participation in the program increased their interest in academic medicine, and whether attending the program benefitted their knowledge and advanced their learning. Focusing on level 1 and 2 on the Kirkpatrick four-level educational model. Results: The FACT program included nine participants, all participants served as trainees and educators in the program. Participants were asked to indicate the most challenging topics in the benign hematology field to guide building the content of the curriculum. The cellular basis of hematopoiesis was noted as the most challenging for six participants. Majority of participants reported having struggles evaluating hemoglobinopathy disorders, hematologic women's health issues, bleeding disorders, and transfusion medicine challenges. Those subjects concluded majority of the curriculum content. Post-intervention surveys were sent out to all participants after eighteen months of implementing the program, asking their feedback about the program, their reaction about the program and knowledge benefit, nine surveys were collected. The implemented program helped improving participants' level of knowledge for hemophilia and other bleeding disorders such as Von Willebrand Disease, in most participants (7 of 9). Also, five participants reported a benefit in regards to cellular basis of hematopoiesis and hemoglobinopathy disorders. The majority of participants (7 of 9) found that the course material was very useful and they rated the lectures to be very good to excellent. And all participants agreed on the discussed topics to be appropriate for their level of training, moreover, it improved the overall understanding and level of interest in benign hematology. All participants noted the impact of the program on augmenting their teaching skills and interest in exploring the academic medicine track. The drawback of the program reported by participants (3 of 9) was experiencing a communication barrier and feeling restricted communicating their questions, opinions, and concerns to their co-fellow educators. Discussion: Implementing the fellow as clinical teacher program has been a strategy that is used to increase trainees' interest in academic careers and educators' tracks, although its barriers and impact on fellow's education is not clear. In this review, we aimed at evaluating the program from trainees' perspectives. The program was beneficial to all trainees, all served as educators at a certain time, it was appropriate for their level of training, it improved the overall knowledge for benign hematology topics, and it positively impacted their teaching skills and interest in academic medicine. With a longer follow-up time, it would be beneficial to evaluate the program's impact on the fellows' commitment towards academic medicine. Conclusion: Fellow as clinical teacher program could be a tool to increase hematology fellows' interest in academic educators' track, increase level of knowledge and confidence managing different challenging topics, without affecting the quality of medical education. Disclosures Ellis: Rafael Pharmaceuticals: Consultancy.

Yes, You Can! Effects of Transparent Admission Standards on High School Track Choice: A Randomized Field Experiment

High school track choice determines college access in many countries. We hypothesize that some qualified students avoid the college-bound track in high school simply because they overestimate admission requirements. To test this hypothesis, we conducted a randomized field experiment that communicated the admission standards of local secondary schools on the academic track to students in Hungary before the application deadline. We targeted the subset of students (“seeds”) who occupied the most central position in the classroom-social networks, aiming to detect both direct effects on the track choice of targeted seeds and spillover effects on their untreated peers. We found neither a direct effect nor a spillover effect on students’ applications or admissions on average. Further analyses, however, revealed theoretically plausible heterogeneity in the direct causal effect of the intervention on the track choice of targeted seeds. Providing information about admission standards increased applications and admissions to secondary schools on the academic track among seeds who had a pre-existing interest in the academic track but were unsure of their chances of admission. This demonstrates that publicizing admissions standards can set students on a more ambitious educational trajectory. We discuss the implications for theory and policy.

Comparing Assessment Methods of Attribute Importance in Teachers’ Decisions: The Importance of Different Criteria for Tracking Recommendations after Primary School

The importance of different criteria for tracking recommendations is usually inferred using regression weights as a cross-student measure. The few studies that have applied alternative approaches or differentiated between student groups sometimes reach different conclusions. According to research on judgment and decision making (JDM), different methods operationalize different facets of importance. Given this, we investigate whether the importance of criteria for tracking recommendations depends on a direct vs. indirect operationalization (regression weights vs. ratings). A total of 181 teachers selected four students from their most recent fourth-grade class using a 2 × 2 design (certain vs. uncertain qualification for the Realschule (vocational track) vs. the Gymnasium (academic track)). Then, they reported on the level and the importance of predetermined criteria for each student. Contrary to JDM research, we found few method-related differences, but striking differences between cases with a certain vs. an uncertain qualification. For the latter, the importance of the criteria is more homogeneous, the regression prediction is less successful and the importance varies with the dependent variable in the regression (actual recommendation vs. perceived qualification). We conclude that further research should focus on uncertain cases rather than method-related differences and suspect that, in uncertain cases, the formation of the recommendation is a multistage decision process.

Analysing Diversion Processes in German Secondary Education: School-Track Effects on Educational Aspirations

Educational aspirations can be regarded as a predictor of final educational attainment, rendering this construct highly relevant for analysing the development of educational inequalities in panel data settings. In the context of the German tracked secondary school system, we analysed school-track effects on the development of educational aspirations. Using data from five consecutive waves of the National Educational Panel Study (NEPS), we selected a sample of high-performing students with initially high aspirations. Our results indicate that pupils in the nonacademic track or with a low social origin tend to lower their aspirations significantly more often than pupils in the academic track or pupils with a high social origin. With mediation analyses, we demonstrate that these differences can be attributed to learning environments at the school level. We also show that the downward adjustment of aspirations in the nonacademic track is less pronounced for students from highly educated families than for students from low-education family backgrounds.

Social Stratification in secondary school success after ambitious track decisions

It is well established in the literature on social stratification in educational attainment that children in families with high socio-economic status (SES) choose more academically demanding educational pathways than children in low SES families, particularly if they did not perform well in school. However, little is known about whether children succeed on these tracks. We make two contributions to this literature: First, we evaluate whether children with low academic preparedness successfully graduate from the academic track in Germany and whether a high SES compensates for low academic preparedness. Second, we try to identify the underlying mechanisms of differences in success rates: Differences could either be attributed to children catching up academically or different reactions to low performance on the academic track. We do so by following the educational trajectories of 2,371 children who transferred to the academic track in 2010 for nine years using survival analysis. In general, children with low academic preparedness are much more likely to downgrade to another track. However, among the children with low academic preparedness, particularly high SES children succeed on the academic track. Yet, little of the differences in success rates by academic preparedness and SES can be attributed to performance in the academic track which limits the contribution of both proposed mechanisms.

Senior high school track and strand preference using the SOAR Intervention Program

The purpose of this study was to examine the students’ track and strand preferences after the SOAR (Student Orientation, Awareness, and Redirection) Intervention Program. This action research employed the descriptive quantitative research design using a researcher-made survey questionnaire that were administered to Grade 10 students from Santa Cruz National High School – Junior High School (n=319) and Manuel Francisco C. Ramos Sr. National High School (n=64). Frequency, percentage and ranking were utilized as statistical tool for this study. Results revealed that the majority of respondents opted to enroll at Sta. Cruz National High School – Senior High School. The Humanities and Social Science strand under the Academic Track had the largest number of students who favoured it over the other strands. Furthermore, it was clear that the majority of them chose the Technical Vocational Track over the Academic Track. The findings can be used to improve Career Guidance in the school, especially parents' engagement in their children's career decisions. Similarly, it is suggested that a standardized enrolment process be developed in which students undergo career assessments in order to help direct them in deciding which strand to pursue.

Mindsets and Self-Concepts About Self-Regulated Learning: Their Relationships With Emotions, Strategy Knowledge, and Academic Achievement

Being a self-regulated learner and believing that deliberate strategy use might be an effective way of overcoming learning challenges is important for achieving academic success. Learners' self-theories about their abilities might explain why some students are more inclined to engage in self-regulated learning (SRL) than others. This study aims to investigate the relationships between students' mindsets and self-concepts about SRL and their correlation with enjoyment, boredom, strategy knowledge, and academic achievements. As covariates, we included gender, age, and academic track. We surveyed 244 students (46.3% female) from the lower secondary school level with a mean age of 14.57 years. The results revealed that mindsets about SRL support more adaptive learning emotions (i.e., higher enjoyment and lower boredom) and positively relate to students' strategy knowledge. The students' self-concepts about SRL are positively related to their enjoyment and academic achievements. Gender-specific differences between the students revealed a disadvantage for the boys, who had lower self-concepts about SRL, lower strategy knowledge, and lower academic achievements in comparison to the girls. Furthermore, the study also revealed that students in the lower academic track adhered more to a fixed mindset about SRL and had lower strategy knowledge than their peers in the higher academic track. Finally, we found an indirect relationship between mindset about SRL and academic achievement via self-concepts about SRL. Overall, our results emphasize the importance of students' mindsets and self-concepts about SRL for their learning and academic achievements.