Universal screening for Lynch syndrome (LS) in colorectal cancer (CRC) and survival.
415 Background: It has been argued that universal screening for LS should be performed on all patients (pts) diagnosed with CRC because screening LS pts and their relatives can detect early cancers and improve outcomes. This approach is being adopted by many comprehensive cancer centers around the country. The Ohio State University (OSU) began screening for deficient mismatch repair (dMMR) proteins by immunohistochemistry (IHC) on all CRC cases in 2006. This retrospective study aims to assess whether universal screening with IHC followed by conclusive testing (BRAF mutation in setting of MLH1 deficiency, and/or gene sequencing) affects pts survival. Methods: All CRC pts diagnosed at OSU from 3/2006-6/2012 with dMMR testing per IHC were included, and their charts were reviewed. Chi-square test was used to for categorical parameters, t-test was used for continuous variables, and the log-rank test for overall survival (OS) to compare the difference between pts with full conclusive testing vs those without full testing. Patients who expired within 4 weeks of diagnosis were excluded (n=10) from the OS analysis. Results: One hundred and twenty-two tumors (15.7% of 777 tumors tested) had dMMR by IHC during the study period. Fifty-one pts went on to have conclusive testing done; thirteen patients (25.5%) were diagnosed with LS, 29 patients (56.9%) had MLH1-hypermethylated tumors, and 9 patients (17.6%) were not found to have MMR mutations on gene sequencing. In an OS analysis, patients undergoing conclusive testing had significantly longer survival as compared to those with abnormal IHC without further testing (median OS not reached vs. 38 months, p=0.04). The difference was similar and remained marginally significant (p= 0.04-0.09) after correcting for age, stage and testing date using different models. Conclusions: Patients who had conclusive testing after initial abnormal universal screening with IHC had significantly longer OS compared to pts who had abnormal IHC without follow-up testing. It is possible that ascertainment bias and pts compliance influenced survival so larger prospective studies that document stage and treatment are needed to determine if increased surveillance in the setting of a LS diagnosis leads to better OS.