Hypothetical Situations and Particularistic Requests: A Test in Three Hospitals
Physical, biological, and social scientists are well aware that some events and processes in field research are more difficult to study directly than others. For this reason, problems of considerable theoretical import are sometimes neglected. The obstacles may arise from the relative infrequency and irregularity with which certain classes of events occur, the lower visibility of certain events to observations at the time and place they occur, or the costs of studying such classes of events. Yet the difficulties involved in no way reduce the theoretical or practical importance of these phenomena. It is precisely with respect to these difficult cases that social scientists find laboratory experimentation and the hypothetical situation in field research most useful. The relative advantages and disadvantages of laboratory methods for studying human behavior have been well documented. By comparison, the usefulness and limitations of the hypothetical situation technique as a viable alternative have been almost totally neglected.