Abstract
Introduction
Deaths and epidemics due to vaccine-preventable diseases still occur even though there are effective vaccines available. Albeit recommendations released by the Italian Ministry of Health, vaccination coverages remain unsatisfactory. An improvement is therefore needed and new strategies are deserved in order to increase coverage. Nevertheless, neither a validated tool nor an institutional guideline to plan and/or evaluate vaccination strategies are available. The aim of BRaVE project was to build an evidence-based tool to develop and assess them.
Methods
In May 2019, a scoping review in MEDLINE and a search of ECDC and WHO websites were performed to look for validated tools to plan and/or evaluate vaccination strategies. The results of the search and the four phases of the Deming cycle (Plan, Do, Check, Act) were used to develop a grid. A multiprofessional panel of 7 experts validated the items included in the grid through a Delphi process followed by a face-to-face meeting.
Results
The original grid submitted to the panel of experts included 30 items (13 planning, 7 implementation, 4 check, 4 act, 2 other). The first round of Delphi led to the suggestion of 11 additional items and to the amendment of 4 out of 30 original items. During the second round of the Delphi the 41 items proposed were approved. At the end of the face-to-face meeting, 1 item was split. Seven items belonging to “Planning” (Plan) and “Implementation” (Do) were labelled as requisites for launching a vaccination strategy and the remaining 35 as items to be considered in their evaluation (15 planning, 11 implementation, 8 check, 4 act, 4 other).
Conclusions
Despite its importance, vaccination coverage is low. Evidence shows possible improvement in coverage, if innovative vaccination strategies are put in place. The developed grid is proposed as an organizational instrument which could improve and standardize vaccination strategies fostering their success and transferability.
Key messages
Novel organizational strategies could be a useful answer to improve vaccination coverage. The proposed grid could be used for the development and assessment of vaccination strategies.