Persuasion Wars as a Useful Tool for Teaching Social Influence: A Replication With Direct Measure of Pedagogical Effectiveness

2021 ◽  
pp. 009862832110481
Author(s):  
Krzysztof J. Leoniak ◽  
Zuzanna Gazdowska

Background Persuasion Wars are exercises for teaching social influence that have not been directly assessed with the use of students’ knowledge gain as an indicator. Objective This study aimed to establish the extent to which these exercises led to students’ knowledge increase in comparison to traditional teaching method. Method In a between subject design, 142 undergraduate students participated in two exercises: Persuasion Wars or Article Analysis. Pre-test and post-test measurements of students’ knowledge were collected to compute knowledge gain scores. At the end of the study, an exercise evaluation survey was distributed among students. Results Both teaching methods increased students’ knowledge about social influence. Regardless of the topic, students from Persuasion War group gained more knowledge when compared to students from Article Analysis group. Students assessed both teaching methods to a similar extent. Conclusion Persuasion Wars may serve as a useful teaching method in familiarizing students with the basic concepts of social influence despite being rated similarly to a more traditional activity. Teaching implications To improve the teaching outcomes of classes concerning basic topics of social influence, teachers should consider the use of Persuasion Wars exercises as well as should incorporate the use of a direct assessment of pedagogical effectiveness to avoid misleading predictions.

2021 ◽  
Vol 5 (9) ◽  
pp. 53
Author(s):  
Jannat Falah ◽  
Mohammad Wedyan ◽  
Salsabeel F. M. Alfalah ◽  
Muhannad Abu-Tarboush ◽  
Ahmad Al-Jakheem ◽  
...  

Multidisciplinary topics in education pose a major challenge for traditional learning and teaching methods. Such topics can deter students from selecting particular courses or hinder their study progress. This study focused on the subject of medicinal chemistry, which is a discipline combining medicine and chemistry. This combination of applied and basic science creates a complex field of education that is challenging to both teach and learn. Chemical and pharmacological principles are typically presented in 2D molecular structures and, recently, 3D molecular models have been utilized to improve the visualization of chemical compounds and their chemical interactions. Contemporary studies have presented Virtual Reality (VR) as an alternative method for improving the learning and teaching of multidisciplinary specialties such as this. However, current educational efforts employing VR offer limited interactivity and a traditional teaching method previously presented in 2D. This reduces students’ interest and concentration in the taught subjects. This paper presents the development rationale of a novel VR educational application based on the evaluation of the user requirements by 405 pharmacy undergraduate students. The results informed the development and preliminary evaluation of a proposed VR serious game application, which was deployed in a real-life class environment and evaluated in contrast to traditional teaching methods by 15 students. The derived results confirmed the advantages of VR technology as a learning and teaching tool, in addition to the end-users’ willingness to adopt VR systems as a learning aid.


2011 ◽  
Vol 1 (1) ◽  
pp. 33-38 ◽  
Author(s):  
Ömer Faruk Özeken ◽  
Ali Yıldırım

Sciences is explained as thinking of the nature of knowledge, the process of producing new things with present data (Ayas, Çepni, Johnson and Turgut, 1997), it can also be explained as understanding and examining already known and seen parts of the events and an effort to guess the unobservable events (Çepni, 2005). In science education which starts with these general goals, there are some targets such as knowing and understanding the scientific information, studying and discovering, imaging and improving, being affected and appreciating and practicing (Çepni, 2005). Therefore, training activities and different teaching methods to provide students with these goals are needed. Today, some different training activities, as an alternative to traditional teaching, have been put into practice in order to provide these goals. The easiest way to teach knowledge and processes to students by removing the memorization is to adopt an education of which the students are on the centre in the process of teaching and to teach science lesson which relates with daily life, is far from unnecessary memorized knowledge, focuses on problem solving and has more practice. It also helps to have an attitude towards sciences (Kıyıcı, 2008). Problem-based learning connected to constructivist education has been becoming more and more important due to the fact that it is an approach centered on problems. In sciences, it is crucial to study, examine, deal with problems and practice. Thus, it is necessary to follow acid-base subject with a different teaching method in which the students themselves can be active.   In this study, it is aimed to examine the effect of problem-based learning in acid-base subject to academic success.   The samples of this study are first grade 95 students at Erzincan University in the Faculty of Education Department of Science Teaching. One of the classes has been randomly selected and has formed the experiment group (47 students) and the other one constitute as the control group (48 students). In the experiment group, problem-based learning has been used in acid-base subject and within the control group traditional method has been applied. A 30- question- test covering the whole subject has been prepared with the help of the literature studies related to acid-base subject and already asked questions of Student Placement Examination (SPE), Student Selection Examination (SSE) for the data of this study and academic success test in acid-base subject (ASTABS) of which the first 24 questions are multiple-choice and the rest 6 questions are open-ended and related to concepts that have been prepared. Multiple-choice questions have been mostly selected from daily life and prepared as similar to problem situations. The reliability quotient (Cronbach's Alpha) of the test has been found as 0,705. The analysis of students' answers to the achievement test has been carried out with SPSS 17 Program. The points acquired from pre-test and post-test for the given variables have been compared with independent group T-test.   The pre-test result between the groups is (t(93) = -.371; p<0,05). According to this result, there is no significant difference between the experiment and control groups' average points of ASTABS. While the experiment group pre-service teachers' average pre-test point of ASTABS is X=38.62, the control group pre-service teachers' is X=39.77. The results of post-test between the groups are (t(93)=3,178; p<0,05).    According to this result, there is no significant difference between the experiment and control groups' average post-test points of ABTABS. While the experiment group pre-service teachers' average post-test point of ASTABS is X=51,77, the control group pre-service teachers' is X=41,96. Conclusion: The experiment group pre-service teachers'-in which problem-based learning (PBL) method has been used- average pre-test points of ASTABS is close to the control group preservice teachers'- in which traditional teaching methods have been used- average points from the same test (Table 1). Before the application, there is no significant difference between these groups and this situation is suitable for defining the efficiency of applied approach. The difference, between the posttest points acquired after the experimental process of the experiment group students to whom PBL approach has been applied and the control group students to whom traditional teaching approaches have been applied, has increased. After the application, a significant difference between the two groups' success has been discovered. These obtained results have shown that the classes to whom problem-based teaching method has been applied learn how to learn and they increase their academic success (Sungur and Tekkaya, 2006), and in the light of previous studies related to improving problem-solving skills, it can be concluded that problem-based teaching method is more effective than traditional teaching methods.


2022 ◽  
Vol 75 (2) ◽  
Author(s):  
Fernanda Letícia da Silva Campanati ◽  
Laiane Medeiros Ribeiro ◽  
Izabel Cristina Rodrigues da Silva ◽  
Paula Regina de Souza Hermann ◽  
Guilherme da Costa Brasil ◽  
...  

ABSTRACT Objectives: to evaluate students’ knowledge gain after the implementation of clinical simulation in Nursing Fundamentals disciplines. Methods: a quasi-experimental intervention was carried out with 60 students, distributed in comparison and intervention groups, who underwent traditional teaching and traditional teaching associated with simulated teaching, respectively. Pre-test and post-test instruments were applied to both groups. Results: after analyzing the students’ performance through the applied instruments, both groups had a cognitive evolution along with the taught content, however, when compared, the intervention group obtained a higher knowledge gain than the comparison group (p = 0.016), demonstrating progressive and increasing improvement with the use of the methodology. Conclusions: simulated teaching significantly helps students in gaining technical-cognitive knowledge. Therefore, it is recommended to adhere to the use of this methodology for teaching Nursing Fundamentals.


2019 ◽  
Vol IV (I) ◽  
pp. 61-66
Author(s):  
Muhammad Kamran ◽  
Namra Munir ◽  
Rashid Minas Wattoo

This study explores the effect of differentiated teaching method vs. traditional teaching method on students’ learning at ‘A’ level. It is an experimental research, conducted in Aitchison College. By applying simple random sampling technique, 70 students are selected as a sample from the population. Pre-test and post-test are conducted for data collection. Research investigates, how differentiated method of teaching effects learners’ academic achievement. The retention level of the students who are taught via differentiated teaching and traditional teaching method is. After conducting a posttest, data is analyzed with pair-sample and independent sample t-test by using SPSS. Analysis shows that the students taught via differentiated teaching have more power of retention than the students taught via traditional teaching methods. The control group perform up to application level while experimental group perform up to evaluation level of cognitive domain.


2019 ◽  
Vol 4 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Ying Yang

English has been a subject in the university classroom since the 1980s. This subject helps produce more excellent talents in economics, politics, and culture who are proficient in English language in China, and enable our country to better integrate with the global economy. At the same time, the relationship between our country and the international community has become closer. However, the social environment is constantly developing and changing. The traditional teaching methods can be said to be ineffective and associated with many shortcomings. Traditional teaching methods were used in the English lessons. Under this teaching mode, students were the passive subjects on the receiving end of what have been taught. The teacher was always talking in the classroom and the students were listening. This teaching style also affects the effectiveness of learning. Compared with traditional teaching, interactive teaching method has its unique advantages. It is a new teaching mode and under this teaching mode, students can actively communicate with teachers in the classroom to complete learning tasks. The initiative to perform self-directed learning is also greatly improved, and the students’ English proficiency can be improved.


2021 ◽  
Vol 12 ◽  
Author(s):  
Zeyu Wang ◽  
Run Tang ◽  
Xin Cheng

The purpose of the study is to solve the problems existing in entrepreneurship education and management under computer technology. The teaching content of entrepreneurship education in colleges and universities is proposed. Since entrepreneurship education is practical, the auxiliary mechanism of entrepreneurship education also needs to be highly integrated with entrepreneurship practice. First, the network entrepreneurship teaching and management system is constructed, and students’ entrepreneurial creativity, communication ability, leadership ability, and qualities are taken as the research object. Second, the traditional teaching method, case study method, and scene simulation method are used to analyze and discuss the influence of the entrepreneurial teaching mode, entrepreneurial experience, and entrepreneurial ability on students’ entrepreneurial psychology. Finally, the questionnaire survey is used to conduct the relative sample t-test (Student’s t-test), and the influence of three teaching methods on students’ learning effects is analyzed. The influence of the three teaching methods on students’ entrepreneurial psychological states is further analyzed by the statistical method. The experimental results show that the test result of the scene simulation method and the traditional teaching method is 0.584, the test result of the scene simulation method and the case study method is 0.842, and the test result of the case study method and the traditional teaching method is 0.595. This shows that the scene simulation method has a significant impact on students’ entrepreneurial psychology and their entrepreneurial ability. In addition, students’ cognition of professional status significantly affects their entrepreneurial psychology and attitudes, and the correlation coefficient is 0.576. Therefore, it is suggested that colleges and universities should adopt the scene simulation method to improve the teaching quality of entrepreneurship education and strengthen students’ cognition of professional status and their entrepreneurial practice.


Nutrients ◽  
2020 ◽  
Vol 12 (11) ◽  
pp. 3475
Author(s):  
José-Antonio Marín-Marín ◽  
Rebeca Soler-Costa ◽  
Antonio-José Moreno-Guerrero ◽  
Jesús López-Belmonte

Vocational training of students in diet habits and active lifestyle habits has recently become an important issue, given the health problems caused as a result of a poor diet. The objective of this study is to analyze the effectiveness of different training actions (traditional method and digital resources) carried out in a program of dietary habits and active lifestyle at the vocational training stage. A quasi-experimental design of the pre-post type was developed. A sample of 177 participants was chosen. The instrument to collect the data was the validated ECHAES questionnaire. The results show that all study groups demonstrated similar averages across all dimensions, except in the digital resource post-test design, where the averages were higher than the rest. There was a significant relationship between the traditional teaching method and the post-test digital resources design in all dimensions. There was also a significant relationship between the pre-test and post-test of the traditional teaching method and the digital resource group in the dimensions. It can be concluded that both the traditional and the innovative method lead to learning in the vocational training student, although the values achieved by the group where the innovative method was adopted were much higher than in the traditional group.


2020 ◽  
Vol 2 ◽  
pp. 61-81
Author(s):  
Mohd Azrin Mohd Nasir ◽  
Ros Idayuwati Alaudin ◽  
Suzila Ismail ◽  
NorA’tikah Mat Ali ◽  
Farah Nadia Mohd Faudzi ◽  
...  

The purpose of this study is to measure the effectiveness of the flipped classroom strategy for self-directed learning among undergraduate students in Mathematics courses. A forty-six (46) students of Actuarial Mathematics course from one university were participated to measure their academic performance during-the-class. A six number of students were randomly selected for a survey with open-ended questions via google form to explore their experiences using this approach. For this study, there was a pre-experimental research design with a group of students in one class. There were two ways of teaching techniques to make a comparison in this study. First, the undergraduate students were taught using a traditional teaching method to provide a baseline, where the instructor showed and explained all the steps to solve mathematical problems, and the understanding of the students will be assessed by conducting a pre-assessment quiz. Second, the students were taught using flipped classroom strategy, where the students were given the solutions including all the steps to solve mathematical problems without guidance or explanation from the instructor, then the students were given similar mathematical problems to be solved by themselves by referring to the example given, then the understandings of students will be assessed by conducting a post-assessment quiz. Third, reimplementing the flipped classroom strategy by conducting the third quiz. Finally, the effectiveness of the flipped classroom strategy is measured by comparing the results from all assessment performance. Also, teacher reflection and students’ feedback were gathered to access self-directed learning effectiveness. The result showed that the post-assessment performance from a flipped classroom strategy was significantly higher than the pre-assessment performance from traditional teaching methods. The lowest score of the pre-assessment using the traditional teaching method was less than one (1) score. On the contrary, the lowest score of the postassessment performance using the flipped classroom strategy was five (5) scores. Moreover, the majority of the respondents achieved eight to ten scores. From the result, it was found that both teaching methodologies produced different results in students’ performance for this study. Besides, the students also provided good feedback from the strategy based on the result of the interview: (a) fun and interesting, (b) curiosity, (c) providing students’ autonomy, (d) initiating communication, (e) integrating the use of technology in learning mathematics, (f) preparing for the final exam. Overall, the students found that the flipped classroom strategy is potentially enhancing student’s engagement and performance in mathematics education. The findings have implications for the instructors to implement the flipped classroom strategy for mathematics subjects to acquire better performance among undergraduate students. The flipped classroom requires self-directed learning among students that can be more interesting learning experiences among the students.


Author(s):  
Ma. Mheliza S. Valiente ◽  
Rema Bascos-Ocampo

The researchers aimed to find out the effectiveness of Scie-chain method on students’ academic achievement and attitude in managing large classes in Science 10 of Flora National High School.  Specifically, it identified the difference and effect to the academic achievement of students and students’ attitude towards Science of the traditional method and Scie-chain method of teaching. The researchers employed the two-group pretest- posttest quasi-experimental design which made use of the Scie-chain method (Inquiry-based, ICT utilization, and flock system) in the experimental group. The data were analyzed with the use of weighted mean. Results of the study showed thatoriginally the experimental group and the control group are equal in terms ofacademic achievement and attitude towards Science. After the intervention, the experimental group yielded better result in terms of academic achievement and attitude towards Science as Manifested in the difference in their post test. From the findings of the study, the following conclusions were drawn:1. students exposed to the Scie-chain method attained better academic achievement compared to students exposed to traditional teaching method; the intervention (Scie-chain method) enhanced the level of attitude of students towards Science; and the Scie-chain method is an effective strategy to manage large classes.


2020 ◽  
Vol 4 (9) ◽  
Author(s):  
Danfeng He ◽  
Fujiang Zhou ◽  
Jinjun Deng ◽  
Cheng Chen ◽  
Chao Liu ◽  
...  

As one of the teaching methods of chemistry in colleges and universities, experimental teaching is the inevitable path of teaching development that is obviously different from traditional teaching, and it is also an indispensable part of constructing and perfecting teaching system and implementing teaching reform. In this case, this paper analyzes and explores in detail the problems existing in inorganic chemistry experiment teaching in colleges and universities, and puts forward relevant methods and measures to provide some valuable references for the optimization of inorganic chemistry experiment methods.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document