Legal Exemptions for Religious Feelings
This essay examines official forms of governmental inquiry into the religious feelings of Muslim citizens. It identifies a series of normative problems with currently available investigative practices in that regard. Government can push too far in its investigations of religious practitioners’ feelings, and various forms of investigation, currently allowed under liberal-democratic legal codes, appear to permit violations of citizens’ basic rights. The essay offers grounds for restructuring conditions under which government officials may permissibly question Muslims about their emotions and sentiments; for rethinking how far government functionaries may proceed in their examinations; and supporting a more general right of citizens to refuse to disclose their feelings to government officials, when questioned about them.