scholarly journals Origin of a Jury Trial in the European Countries

2017 ◽  
Vol 6 (5) ◽  
pp. 152
Author(s):  
Radik N. Hamitov ◽  
Dmitriy Yu. Tumanov ◽  
Rinat R. Sakhapov

<p>Traditionally it is believed that the birthplace of the jury trial creation is England, but the issue of the birthplace location of this particular form of popular participation in the criminal justice administration is not yet fully resolved by the historical science. The continental lawyers were particularly interested in the jury trial among other institutions of English law, in which the English themselves identified the stronghold of the country's law and order, its political and civil freedom. It is not difficult to see that the main role was not played by the judges, but by the community representatives in this form of justice administration. Since then the community has been gaining more and more importance in England as a state body in the matter of justice administration, and the initial forms of its activity have being further developed in this direction. This works investigates roots of jury trial by basing on such methods as historical, systemic, formally logical, concrete-historical, comparative legal analysis method.­ The authors, in turn, come to the conclusion that the jury trial has its roots still in the Ancient States, but the classical modern model owes its origin to England.</p>

Legal Ukraine ◽  
2020 ◽  
pp. 80-86
Author(s):  
Mykhailo Yurkevich

The article considers the issues of legislative regulation in the ancient monument of law – Ruska Pravda, issues of forest protection in the territory of Kievan Rus, in order to form a general comprehensive concept of forest protection in Ukraine in different periods of state formation. The relevance of the study is justified by the change of economic, political, social and legal development of Ukraine, which influenced the transition from the monistic paradigm of legal reality research methodology to the pluralism of research paradigms and allows a new assessment of development of forest protection norms on the territory of Ukraine. The most important factors that led to the formation of forest protection legislation of Kievan Rus are highlighted. A comparative legal analysis of the Short and Spatial editions of Russkaya Pravda was carried out. It is established that the Spatial edition differs from the Short edition by a larger number of articles on the protection of forestry, which is due to the process of formation of feudal society and the need for more detailed regulation of property rights. The features of this monument of law, which distinguished it from the legal acts created in subsequent periods, are indicated. Attention is drawn to the enshrinement in Russkaya Pravda of the norms of customary law, according to which «what is given by nature belongs to the whole society». Therefore, deforestation was not prohibited, but liability for theft of firewood was imposed by imposing a fine of 9 kunas, and for each cart with firewood – 2 kunas separately, while the law regulated fishing related to forests. The system of fines provided by Ruska Pravda for offenses related to forestry is described. Organizational principles of forest protection in Kievan Rus are considered. It is established that in this period there were no special organizational structures in this area and that law and order in the forests was provided by princely warriors with the participation of hunters. Key words: «Russian Law», Kievan Rus, forest protection, forestry, liability for violation of forest protection norms, theft, fine.


2020 ◽  
pp. 71-75
Author(s):  
O.V. Seletskyi

One of the main factors for ensuring effective and honest work of civil servants is the formation of proper motivation and remuneration for the performance of tasks. Officials, along with other employees, strive public recognition of the results of their work. Encouragement of civil servants promotes the development of initiative, responsibility, confidence in their actions, a conscious attitude to work, mobilization to overcome difficulties and increase their credibility. Measures of material and moral support of civil servants help to realize the correct understanding of their labor obovyazkiv, helps to increase labor activity and improve the performance of the state body. The article analyzes the views of scholars on the interpretation of such a legal category as "encouragement". The provisions of the Law of Ukraine "On Civil Service" and bylaws regulating the grounds, types and procedure for applying incentives to civil servants are analyzed. It is established that the following types of incentives can be applied to civil servants: 1) announcement of gratitude; 2) awarding a diploma, a diploma, other departmental awards of a state body; 3) early assignment of the rank of civil servant; 4) presentation for awarding by government honors and awarding with a government award (congratulatory letter, thanks, diploma); 5) submission for state awards. The author proposes to expand the existing list of types of incentives for civil servants with such incentives as rewarding with a valuable gift and paying a bonus. The article also draws attention to the imperfections of the legal regulation of the procedure for applying certain types of incentives in the civil service. The author's definition of the term "encouragement of a civil servant" is proposed. It is concluded that the incentives for civil servants play an important role in enhancing their professional activities and are aimed at forming in them a conscientious attitude to work. However, some issues in this area still need significant refinement at the legislative level.


Author(s):  
Andrey M. Lushnikov ◽  
Marina V. Lushnikova

This article is devoted to a whole range of topical problems associated with understanding the legal regulation of wages as one of the main institutions of labor law. In preparing this article, the authors relied on historical, comparative legal and systemic structural methods. The authors linked the genesis of the teaching on wages with the work of the British scientist J.S. Mill. It is reasonably argued that his broad approach, based on a sociological, philosophical, economic and legal analysis of this phenomenon, allowed him to come to very significant conclusions regarding the economic incentives for labor. In the opinion of the authors, the decisive contribution of the British scientist lies in the fact that he separated the «laws» of production from the «laws» of distribution. This opened the way to the possibility of establishing state standards for wages, as well as its legal regulation at three levels: state, social partnership and individual contractual. For the British scientist, the mechanism for fixing wages was a compromise between the interests of workers and employers, taking into account the interests of the state and society. The authors concluded that this approach meets modern realities and is consistent with the important role of collective agreements and local acts in establishing the remuneration system.


Author(s):  
Iryna Rozman

The article is devoted to the analysis of the problem of periodization of the research of pedagogical personnel. The theoretical and methodological approaches of Ukrainian and foreign scientists to the periodization of the development of historical and pedagogical science, which are based in general on the technologies of using the methodological tools of historical science, are determined. The role, significance, potential of comparative – historical, comparative, and other methods that are used in studies devoted to life and various directions of creative and social activity of pedagogical personalities are described. Two methodologically important approaches are found for conducting studies in the field of pedagogical biography, which are related to the study of a person in a universal coordinate system: a synchronous system, projecting its analysis in a specific time period and diachronic, projecting the study of personalities in a time «vertical». Disadvantages of periodization as an instrument and means of scientific and cognitive activities are shown; the ways and possibilities of their minimization and increase of the scientific and heuristic efficiency of the periodization method are determined in the studied periods (stages) of the life path of the pedagogical personalities. The article substantiates the position according to which the correct application of methodological tools allows to avoid various manifestations of dichotomy (illicit division) in pedagogical and biographical research.


Author(s):  
Александр Трофимик ◽  
Aleksandr Trofimik

The monograph is devoted to complex and system research of the problems in legal regulation concerning invalidity of related-party transactions in the context of the last short stories contained Chapter 11 of the Federal Law «On Joint-Stock Companies». With the application of comparative legal methodin this article is an attempt to establish fundamental primary legal unities of law and order in Germany and the Russian Federation in corresponding regulation and to differentiate substantial characteristics of theologically equivalent legal mechanisms. In this article such aspects of counteraction to conflict of interest in Germany’s Joint-Stock Companies are considered, which have not been presented in Russian research works earlier. In the article is given a doctrinal definition of the term «related-party transactions», analyzed a new order of making related-party transactions with relation to given guaranties for declaring a transaction voidable, formulated the invalidity elements of related-party transactions. The author made an attempt of technical legal analysis of invalidity elements correlation, established by the paragraph of third point 1 of Article 84 of the Federal Law «On Joint-Stock Companies», and in accordance with point 2 of Article 174 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation.


2020 ◽  
Vol 3 (1) ◽  
pp. 116
Author(s):  
Yurii Barash ◽  
Tetiana Vlasova ◽  
Larysa Martseniuk ◽  
Tetiana Charkina

The aim of the article is the conceptual reconstruction of the origin of the Crimean Karaims as an ethnic group and determination of the factors which played the main role in the formation of their faith – the Karaism. The actual topicality of the theme under analysis is stipulated by the definite factors, which are of both ethnic and religious origin. At present there still happen fervent academic debates that make the borderline between two opposing scientific approaches concerning the key issues of the Karaims’ origin and their faith. The opponents – or the proponents – of both scientific trends are claiming that the problem is “absolutely and fully” solved, but this very fact speaks for the evidence of its definite ambiguity in solving the problems of theory and in approaching the issues of research. The methods. The methodology, used in the article, is stipulated by the specific features of the research object, which calls for the complex interdisciplinary analysis including both the approaches of the hermeneutic interpretation and the comparative historical methods. The interdisciplinary dialogue serves its goal in this paper, involving different academic subjects in one attempt at the whole analysis. This methodology is so important in this case because the objective covers the analysis of the generalized vision of the wide problematic field. The latter includes historical-comparative methods, hermeneutic approaches, deconstruction techniques, etc., which can help history and theology communicate in the mutually beneficial dialogue. The main results. The research of the ethnic origin of the Crimean Karaims in the context of the transformations of their faith – the Karaism reveals the ambivalent interpretations of their history and worships. The authors’ conception confirms the hypothesis of the Karaims’ origin as the Turks and substantiates the idea of the Biblicism as a source of their faith. The concise conclusion. The Crimean Karaims (Karai) being the Tengrianists before the 1st century A. D. then adopted the pure Biblicism through the Crimean local ethnic groups. Anan’s teaching having complemented the Biblicism did not change its main ideas. The practical meaning is connected with the accentualization of the scientific interest in the historical heritage of the non-numerous ethnic group – the Karaims under the conditions of the risks and the threats of the globalization processes. The project of Man has been constructing the system of values for thousands of years, and nowadays the critically minded postmodern man or woman cannot be free from the absolutes of faith, from the ultimate concepts of philosophy. And namely at this historical stage those obvious criteria can help the postmodern person to perceive that moral law that is the intrinsic value of the human being. The originality. The research problems have not been yet the subject of the special investigation in the Ukrainian science. The scientific novelty. The foundation of the Karaims’ religion is the Biblicism which had come into existence 500 years before the Judaism appeared as the worship. Thus, the Karaism cannot be considered a sect of the Judaism. The type of the article: analytical.


2021 ◽  
Vol 7 (12) ◽  
pp. 271-277
Author(s):  
G. Kaparova ◽  
D. Mazhitova ◽  
Zh. Abdullaeva

Research relevance determined by the importance of tax regulation, which allows the state to concentrate its financial resources, with the ability to significantly influence the economic development of the country at every stage of its development. The article examines the processes and stages of the emergence and evolution of theses on the essence of taxation. Research objectives: analysis of the main and fundamental tax theories, as well as tax systems of ancient states. Research materials and methods: analysis of the history of formation, development, evolution of one of the initial forms of taxation — payment (tax) from the people. Also considered the legal content and the economic content of the tax. Research results: the basic principles of taxation are considered on the basis of the definitions of Adam Smith, who established the basic principles of taxation, which exist and operate to this day. An assessment and comparison of taxation in Kyrgyzstan with other countries is given. Conclusions: a decrease in the tax rate will entail an increase in production, which in the future will compensate for a temporary decrease in tax revenues.


2021 ◽  
Vol 1 ◽  
pp. 15-21
Author(s):  
Marina S. Savchenko ◽  
◽  
Svetlana A. Kuemzhieva ◽  
Vitaliy V. Goncharov ◽  
◽  
...  

This article is devoted to the constitutional and legal analysis of the judiciary as an object of public control in the Russian Federation. Object of research: public relations related to the organization and implementation of public control in the Russian Federation. Subject of research: the current legislation regulating both the organization and implementation of public control, and the formation and functioning of judicial authorities in Russia, as well as the Russian legal doctrine in the field of organization and implementation of public control in relation to the activities of courts. The article develops and substantiates the author’s definition of public control in the Russian Federation. The author substantiates the system of measures necessary to ensure the full organization and implementation of public control over the judiciary in Russia. This article uses a number of methods of scientific research, in particular: analysis; synthesis; historical; comparative law; classification; modeling.


2016 ◽  
Vol 1 (6) ◽  
pp. 0-0
Author(s):  
Игорь Ирхин ◽  
Igor Irkhin

On the basis of the analysis of federal and regional level legislations, as well as judicial practice this article studies the issues of constitution-legal regulation of the order of formation and redistricting of electoral districts in the regions of the Canadian federation from a perspective of ensuring the implementation of the provisions of the Supreme Court of Canada to ensure an effective national representation (Reference re Prov. Electoral Boundaries (Sask.)). The article outlines proposals on mainstreaming the multifaceted approach of Canadian legislators and the expansion of the list of conditions that affect the ability to make decisions on formation and adjustment of electoral districts in the Russian Federation. The author uses general scientific methodology (analysis, synthesis, analogy, comparison), as well as other methods (historical, legal, historical, comparative law). For the first time the constitution-legal analysis of the Canadian Constitution provisions was carried out, as well as that of the acts of judicial practices and regional legislation regulating the procedure of the electoral districts’ formation and redistricting in the constituent entities of the Canadian federation from a perspective of ensuring the implementation of the provisions of the Supreme Court of Canada to ensure an effective national representation.


Author(s):  
Sergey M. Ryazanov

The local Ural material on the 19th century police has attracted researchers only since the second half of the 1990s. Yet, it mainly concerned the South Ural, as special studies in the Middle Ural and in the Vyatka Ural have not been carried out. This article aims to fill in this lacuna. The object of this study is the transformation of the factory police in the 19th century. The relevance of this topic for historical science lies in the active character of the processes, associated with modernization, and the timeliness of the police reform. To study this, the author has used such historical methods, as historical-genetic, historical-comparative, and historical-typological. This article has examined the measures taken by the authorities of the Urals to improve the police supervision of factory settlements in the second half of the 19th century. The author has compared the pre-reform and new police states, emphasizing the development of the Izhevsk and Votkinsk factory settlements police. The results show that the slowness in carrying out police reforms led to an increase in unrest and crime in factories. The redistribution of local police resources, intended for the countryside, to the cities and factories of the Ural could somewhat mitigate the negative consequences of the inaction of the central government. Thus, the liquidation of the mountain police in the middle of the 19th century significantly weakened police forces in factory settlements, which were restored only in the 1890s.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document