Abstract
Background and Aims
Conventional 2D mono-culture in vitro models using immortalized cell lines are still widely used in experimental nephrology, although their value is limited by poor translatability and predictive value for the in vivo or even human situation. The implementation of more sophisticated in vitro assays as routine cell culture systems is often limited by complex protocols and long lasting procedures. We aimed to establish and validate a relatively easy-to-use but yet (patho-) physiologically relevant cell culture assay that mimics key aspects of the in vivo situation of renal tubules, including a leak-thight epithelium with a luminal and baso-lateral side, interstitial matrix, a peri-tubular capillary and circulating blood cells inside its lumen.
Method
We utilized the 3-lane OrganoPlate® system (Mimetas, Leiden, Netherlands) as a scaffold. After infusing a collagen I matrix in the middle channel (C2), primary human renal progenitor cells are seeded into the upper channel (C1), adhering to the C2-matrix. The plate is put on a perfusion rocker (Mimetas), that facilitates continuous gravity-triggered bi-directional perfusion of C1. Within 48h the cells form a leak-tight tubular structure with a continuous lumen. Next, human endothelial cells are seeded into the bottom channel (C3), which adhered to the opposite site of the C2-matrix and – upon continuous perfusion – formed a vessel-like structure with a continuous lumen, as well. Finally, primary human white blood cells were isolated and seeded into C3 (see figure).
Results
Establishing the whole tubule-on-the-chip as described above takes on average three days. We investigated its operational life span by monitoring the barrier integrity of the tubular structure in C1 using a fluorescence-labeled dextran (150 kDa). Over a course of 5 days the tubular integrity did not decline, suggesting that the co-culture system remains stable and functional for at least 5 days. In accordance with other studies, the primary human tubular cells constituting the 3D tubule-on-the-chip expressed higher levels of functionally relevant proteins, e..g the tight-junction protein ZO-1 and the sodium-potassium-pump Na-K-ATPase, compared to standard 2D settings without perfusion. This emphasizes, that even primary cells show a physiologically reduced phenotype in standard 2D settings, which possibly impedes the identification and representative quantification of physiologically and hence also patho-physiologically relevant mechanisms in vitro. To study the interaction of cells in the tubule-on-the-chip, we investigated the recruitment of immune cells from C3 (vessel) across C2 (interstitium) to C1 (renal tubule), which - in vivo - represents a detrimental mechanism of action in intrarenal forms of AKI. Under baseline conditions the immune cells inserted into C3 did not leave their compartment. Upon damaging the tubular cells in C1 with extracellular histones, neutrophils and monocytes left C3 (extravasation), migrated through C2 and could be found in close contact with epithelial cells of C1. This serves as a proof of principle, that the tubule-on-the-chip is applicable to study complex cell-cell and cell-substrate interactions, such as chemokine-mediate immune cell homing. Measuring lactate dehydrogenase release for a number of known nephrotoxic agents revealed, that tubular cells forming a 3D-structure while kept under perfusion show significantly different responses to the same dose compared to standard 2D conditions, suggesting that dose-response studies using target cells out of their tissues context can be misleading when extrapolating results from in vitro to in vivo.
Conclusion
The results of this study suggest, that sophisticated 3D co-culture models of a renal tubule including an interstitial compartment, a peri-tubluar capillary and circulating immune cells are feasible and potentially suited to allow for in depth mechanistic studies in vitro.
How Do Broken Bones Heal?
